Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Traditional Spindle Gouge

Posts

Traditional Spindle Gouge

#1

Traditional Spindle Gouge

David Cockey

>I recently acquired a traditional, forged spindle gouge, a Henry Taylor 3/4" HS41 in particular. http://www.henrytaylortools.co.uk/chisels.html It seems to be a great tool for turning tapers and large radius "coves" and "beads" such as used on a tool handle for example. The cuts are smoother and more even than trying to do the same with a modern, smaller round gouge. It it isn't as bulky as a large roughing gouge. The larger forged gouge isn't the tool for details, but for longer, more gradual sections it's now my prefered tool.

Any idea why this shape gouge isn't more popular for spindle turning? The current philosiphy seems to only consider roughing gouges and gouges milled from round stock. In smaller sizes I suspect the forged gouge may be more prone to chatter than the round gouge.

Disclaimer: I'm basically a novice turner still building skills, but I'm reasonably comfortable using both gouges and skews.

Re: Traditional Spindle Gouge

#2

Keith Tompkins

Re: Traditional Spindle Gouge

Keith Tompkins

>Hi David, I think mostly it's economics....round gouges are easier to produce. You would be surprised to learn that the "continental" style gouges you describe will actually go where the round types will not. The secret is turning with the gouge on its side...in that way, the gouges will cut smaller coves than their shape will suggest, and will cut deeper beads than a round gouge. The round gouges will need a severe swept back grind to go where the "flat" gouges will go. The biggest advantage of the round gouge is ease of use....the point of the tool is closer to the toolrest compared with the older style continental gouges when used on edge, so are less prone to catch. My drawing shows the round gouge being used, the technique is the same for the continental gouges as well. Cutting on center is important, otherwise the tool will tend to spiral out of the cut, similar to a skew. Old training manuals from the turn-of-the-century show this technique; I have adapted it to all of my spindle-turned work, including the skew. This tehcnique, I believe, is an essential skill to master.


img

Re: Traditional Spindle Gouge

#3

Re: Traditional Spindle Gouge

Ken Grunke from SW Wisconsin

>I like the forged spindle gouge and used it often before I became comfortable with the skew. The forged gouge is a good alternative for the skew in the novice's hands and does most of the same cuts except for getting into sharp corners.

Maybe it seems to be less popular because of being replaced by the deep forged spindle gouge, which is in just about every turner's collection I know. I haven't directly compared the two, but I think the original style gouge has basically the same profile as the center of the deep gouge, but without the high sides.

Re: Traditional Spindle Gouge

#4

Re: Traditional Spindle Gouge

john lucas

>I've always wanted one of the really big spindle gouges like Rude Osolnik used to use. It does do a lot of things the skew does but is easier to sharpen.

Re: Traditional Spindle Gouge

#5

why don't we see them?

john lucas

>Because very few people in this country turn spindles, especially large spinldles like stair banister which is where it would really pay off.

Re: Traditional Spindle Gouge

#6

Steven Antonucci

They're in every Sears set of tools

steve antonucci

>I gave them away when I sold one of my earlier lathes. Don't need one to make a bowl or a hollowform. Not sure if I'd even know what to do with one.

Steve

Re: Traditional Spindle Gouge

#7

Re:I believe the death knell of .....

Jamie Donaldson

>......the continental gouge was caused by the ease of machining round stock into a fluted shape, without the extra cost of forging the flat stock into a gouge. I had an old carbon steel continental gouge when I started turning and learned to spindle turn with it, but don't have a clue what happened to it?

Re: Traditional Spindle Gouge

#8

Re: Traditional Spindle Gouge

peter kolb

>what does the ground edge look like. thanks for your help Peter in south central nj

Re: Traditional Spindle Gouge

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: They're in every Sears set of tools

Keith Tompkins

>Hey Steve, I'll share a secret....a honed continental gouge is unbeatable for the final cut on the exterior of a bowl,especially on tough grain, held on its side. It works great on hollow form exteriors as well.

Re: Traditional Spindle Gouge

#10

Steven Antonucci

I've been using a skew

steve antonucci

>That also works pretty nicely... :-)

Not for the meek...

Steve

Re: Traditional Spindle Gouge

#11

Sharpening

David Cockey

>Ground at a 40 degrees, rotating handle about it's axis. The Henry Taylor one came with a very slight curve in plan view which I've kept. As some else said it's very similar to the center section of a much larger "roughing" gouge. The 3/4" gouge is somewhat similar to the center of my 1 1/2" roughing gouge, except it doesn't have the wings which get in the way when turning beads and coves.

Re: Traditional Spindle Gouge

#12

British, German & Continental

David Cockey

>Several different names are used.

Tools for Working Wood carries two varities by Ashley Illes.

"Standard Traditional Pattern Spindle Gouges" are described as This is a traditional English tool that dates from the days of hand production turning. It has a heavy section but a fairly shallow gouge, so it is great for both roughing and shaping between centers. It's very appropriate for large turnings such as staircase balustrades. It's an extremely versatile and good value tool. The standard grind is 40 degrees but for soft wood, you might consider going to 25 degrees which will enable a very fine cut." "Continental Gouges" are described as "These Continental gouges are shorter, thinner variations of the tradition English gouge. They are shallower and should not be used for roughing. However, they shear like a skew and leave a wonderful finish."

Henry Taylor calls theirs "Spindle Gouges forged to the traditional shape".

Hamlet calls theirs "German Spindle Gouges".

Sorby calls theirs "Continental Style".

Re: Traditional Spindle Gouge

#13

Re: they are good inside too *LINK*

Russ Fairfield

>They work very well for finishing cuts on the inside of a bowl too, if they are held right and you keep on the bevel.

There is a photo of one being used and how I grind them in the "Grinds Library (last item).


http://www.woodcentral.com/newforum/grinds.shtml

Re: Traditional Spindle Gouge

#14

Ellis Walentine

***Hey, speaking of the Tool Grinds Library...***

Ellis Walentine

>...if anyone would like to submit their special grind for inclusion in this oft-overlooked resource, just e-mail me the pictures and descriptions. Be sure to say what this grind is good for and for which tools.

Ellis Walentine, Host