>How long would you expect, on average, to spend on sanding, let's say, a 12 inch bowl? For the sake of argument, assume that you have to start with 100-120 grit paper.
And for gallery pieces? For instance, Steve, how long did you spend sanding the three top-notch hollow forms you showed us the other day?
The reason I ask is that I often have the feeling that something must be wrong with my approach to sanding, since it takes a lot of tedious work to achieve a good result.
The answer is it depends. Do you power sand? Power sanding reduces the time to sand dramatically.
So, as a guess, the outside of a 12" bowl I typically start with 120 grit and power sand for about 5 minutes or less, then I work my way up to 600 grit, only taking about a minute or two per grit. So, total time for the outside of a bowl which hs no tear out, good shape and few tool marks is about 15 minutes. On the outside, I start typically with 80 grit and it takes a little more time to sand. So total time to sand a bowl is abot 30 to 40 minutes. The better the tooling is the less time I sand. When I had poorer surfaces to start, it took me what semed like hours to sand a bowl.
As a for instance, last night I made a small (41/2" high by 3" Diameter) Hollow Form. The tooling on the outside was good and I started sanding at 180 and sanded up to 1200 grit. It took me total less than ten minutes to sand the piece and about an hour total to make the piece. The finer the grit you can start with the less time it will take to sand. Sorry for the long response.
>I can relate 100%. I used to spend more time sanding than I did turning. 3 things helped a lot in this respect. One is to learn to look at the piece and decide what grit to start at. For example I used to start at 80 or 100 all the time. Eventually my skills got better and I could start with 120.
You have to sand out all the defects with the first grit. Then the other grits go real fast. The biggest mistake many people make is to start too fine (which goes against what I just said) and then they stay there sanding and sanding trying to get rid of that tearout or whatever. If you start with one grit and notice it's not getting rid of some defects fairly quickly, stop, and go back down to a courser paper. You will save time. Also trying to sand out a defect with the wrong paper will make ripples in the bowl around that defect.
Second is to learn to cut cleaner. Make your final passes with freshly sharpened gouge. Speed up the lathe a little and use very light forward pressure to let the gouge cut at the rate it needs to without tearing out the fibers.
Learn to shear scrape. If you can't get the hang of gouge control which does take a lot of practice, shear scraping will remove a lot of defects and tool marks that you would normally have to sand out. I use a John Jordan shear scraper on the outside and really thick Henry Taylor curved scraper for the inside. If I have an area with a lot of tearout I stop the lathe and use a cabinet scraper to clean up these areas. This will eliminate a lot of sanding.
Just as a point of reference I rarely need 120 anymore. I can usually start with 150,180 or even 220. In fact on bowls 6" or smaller I don't even power sand. I can usually cut them clean enough to touch them lightly with 180 or 220 and then go on up to 400 with just a handheld piece. I slow the lathe down and move the paper constantly and check for clogging. I've watched Stewart Batty turn a piece the looked like it had been sanded to 600. It was spectacular and I hope to get there some day.
Oh I still have my days and pieces of wood that take the old 80 grit or courser but I'm getting better and it's a lot more fun when can turn instead of sand. On the plus side, Proper sanding is what will make a piece stand out from the crowd so don't be afraid to do it. Grit your teeth and go at and you will be rewarded when you put the finish on.
>I honestly don't sand all that much on the smaller stuff. Like John said, the key is to learn to cut with proper technique so you can start with a lower grit, but even more importantly, reduce the mistakes you introduce in cutting.
I have been working with a bunch of relatively new turners and there should be a teaching aid for rubbing the bevel. Most tearout in a bowl comes from improper gouge presentation, not the wood or the tool itself. If you watch a new turner, you'll often see them hogging off huge chunk of wood. If you watch me, you'll see long THIN ribbons in the same wood. Same lathe, same tools- different presentation of th bevel. The key is slowing down the tool to match the speed that the wood can be effectively cut and not taking a 3/4" final pass.
I usually start at 120, but could probably start at 180. The amount of sanding I do is usually <15 min on a piece, and I never skip a grit. If I find that I missed a spot, I have to go all the way back to 120 to get it out, so I spend the most time there. When I am done, I usually resand the last grit with the grain as a final step. and I rarely go past 320. (I'm lazy)
>A good quality sandpaper will cut the wood faster and reduce your sanding time. So don't buy cheap sandpaper. For a 12" bowl, I sand about 30 minutes from about 120 to 400 grit. Also, suggest you try to get a copy of Russ's finishing CD's or read Russ's corner here at Wood Central. He talks about the sanding process.
>I can't tell you how much time I wasted with mediocre sandpaper. I now use either the Eagle brand abrasive, Norton 3x or the blue paper from Vince's woodnwonders. It cuts so fast and clean it save you time and money.
>Thanks for good advice, especially underlining the importance of the first grit. I've often wasted time having to return to a courser grit towards the end of a sanding session.
But you also confirm that most of us are in the same boat relative to sanding and that the challenge remains to hone our cutting skills. I also use Vince's blue disks. (Slightly off topic, at the Symposium I bought a nifty three inch wool-like polishing "cap" for hook and loop from Vince. I've used it with an abrasive wax I picked up from another vendor at the Symposium. It seals up end grain in preparation for oil and leaves a very smooth surface.)
>New to turning so learning by looking, and listening to other turners. I have yet to gauge it right for what grit to use and not cause more work. If I turn smooth I guess I pick too large of grit to start and then go through more sanding grits. Turned too rough and I have to back up a grit or spend to much time sanding. How do you pick starting grit to turned finish other than experience?
Viewed a video of John Mahoney turning a bowl and he too had torn grain and power sands them out, not a better cut. Maybe it is a trade off if he is a production woodturner. I guess for being retired due to health I I hope I got time to learn tool selection, grinds, tool presentation, sanding and finishing. Comments on trade off in smooth turning and power sanding would be helpful.
>If you'll read what Russ Fairfield wrote in the Articles section... you'll see what I do. I've been sanding woodwork that way for years. With a good incandescent light, you can see when the marks from the previous grits are gone. If they are gone, you are just removing wood, not sanding marks.
When I start with a grit, I let the marks on the wood make my decision for me. If I sand with say, 120 grit, and I see marks that are not coming out, I go back to 100 or 80.
12" dia bowl would probably take 20 to 30 minutes, typically, if there isn't any tearout, or filling to be done.