Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

New locust vessel

Posts

New locust vessel

#1

New locust vessel

john lucas

>A friend gave me what he thought was a bunch of good turning wood. It was all rotten and very checked Locust branches. I tossed all of it out but this one piece and even thought it was cracked, rotten,and had a rotten limb section in it I just had to give it a try. Besides I haven't been doing hollow vessels in a long time and I'm rusty. I did a pretty good job on the inside all except the very bottom. I got rid of the bump but have a large ridge right outside that. I'll have to work on that.

It's about 5" tall and 3 3/4 wide. It turned out pretty fair but I don't like the shape. I would have liked the bottom to be much thinner. This one sort of looks like a light bulb without the base. It would have been better if the base was longer or the base sloped in to be much thinner, I think. I also think all the holes and patched crackes take away from the nice wood. However I needed the challenge of trying to save a piece like this and my friend will enjoy seeing it.


img

Re: New locust vessel

#2

backside

john lucas

>I think it looks better without the hole in the side but you can only have that in a photo. This is what I call the backside.

So all in all I agree with John Jordan, at least most of the time. Life is too short to turn crappy wood. However some of us like the challenge. It' just not as nice as it could be if the wood was clean.

It has a small ebony lip because the top was so rotten the lip wanted to crumble. I made the ebony lip about 1/4" larger than it needed to be to support this bad wood.


img

Re: New locust vessel

#3

Re: backside

Barry Turner

>So......is the ebony collar just glued in? Cyanoacrylate? Titebond? Does wood movement between two dissimilar woods ever cause the glue joint between the collar and vessel to fail?

Re: New locust vessel

#4

Re: backside

Mike Jones, Redding, CA

>I like the form in this view a lot!


img

Re: New locust vessel

#5

Re: backside

john lucas

>Barry I used CA on this one. I turn a tenon on the ebony to provide more glue surface. The end grain locust will move very little and the ebony in that size will move very little so I don't think it will be a problem.

When I suspect I will have a problem such as a side grain vessel and end grain collar I will use a flexible glue such as Elmers f26 or Clear silicone caulking. I will also leave a little room for it to move by making the tenon a little smaller and the outer surface a little wider to give more glue surface.

Re: New locust vessel

#6

Steven Antonucci

I like hole, but hate cracks

steve antonucci

>Agree with you on the shape. It's not my favorite. If you could do it over, the lightbulb form wouldn't be keeper.

I hate cracked wood. Not only do I worry about spontaneous failure, but I just don't like the look. When I have cracks, they become "experimental pieces" or what we call "high value-added firewood" in my house. Holes are good because I spend much less time blowing out shavings.

Steven

Re: New locust vessel

#7

Re: New locust vessel

Molly Winton

>Well John, I have to say I agree with you about your concern regarding the form. I think I would have liked it better had you followed through with the curve coming down from the shoulder. When you reversed your curve leading into the base you lost me. It also gives the impression of melting into the table. I think you forgot the 'tuck'. I do really like the drama of the wood, and the collar is a nice finish to the rim.

I hope you don't mind my critique. It's meant to be helpful not critical.

Re: New locust vessel

#8

Re: New locust vessel

john lucas

>Molly I love critic. Even when I don't agree with the person it's still a different point of view and something to consider later. It this case I agree 100 percent. When I was working on the piece the little rotten knot section had to be cut away. This led to the reverse slope. When I looked at it on the lathe sideways it looked fine. I should have made the whole thing smaller to get a better shape instead of falling into that trap of trying to use as much of the wood as I could. Small and perfect is always better than big and sloppy.