Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

how do people sharpen scrapers?

Posts

how do people sharpen scrapers?

#1

how do people sharpen scrapers?

Woody in VT

>How do you sharpen your scrapers? I have a tormek and a veritas burnisher, but I can't seem to get my scrapers so they don't cause tear out when using them. Any suggestions? as usual, thanks in advance.

Re: how do people sharpen scrapers?

#2

Re: how do people sharpen scrapers?

Barry Irby

>I have a slow speed cheap-o Woodcraft grinder. On the left side I have a tool rest set and "the right angle" for scrapers. 80 or 85 degrees or maybe it's 86.3478 degrees, but it looks about right. The edge of the scraper is slightly under cut and has the profile of the wheel ground into it, so it is hollow ground. I press the scraper onto the tool rest with my thumb and guide it gently past the wheel with the other hand. I do this on the one I have that is about 3/8" thick and on the little amoeba shaped ones on my Sorby tools. A very light pass cleans up the edge and gives me a burr. The tools are right side up on the rest. I have the Veritas Burnisher, but I had forgotten it.

Re: how do people sharpen scrapers?

#3

Re: how do people sharpen scrapers?

GaryG in MD

>Woody,

Even if your scrapers are very sharp, they can still cause tearout on end grain if used flat on the rest. Look into "shear scraping".

...Gary

Re: how do people sharpen scrapers?

#4

Re: how do people sharpen scrapers?

Chuck Engstrom

>Hi Woody -- my practice is much like Barry's except that I do scrapers upside down -- the top of the scraper faces DOWN on the grinder rest so that the grinder wheel is turning toward the top of the scraper. Before taking a scraper to the grinder to be refreshed I polish the top surface with a small diamond hone held flat to the surface. I am using a fairly steep angle just like Barry, probably greater than 85 degrees.

Most folks regard this as unorthodox but it seems to work for me. I think Jimmy Clewes also does it this way. I don't use a burnisher, and I have covered the top of my grinder rest with a piece of Formica-type stuff to provide a surface less likely to booger up a small fine burr. When I get it right, the scraper brings off small fine shavings rather than dust.

And I do generally present my scrapers to the wood at as much angle as circumstances permit, rather than just flat on the tool rest. The idea here is that the fine burr, held at an angle, can actually cut rather than just scrape.

Try it both ways and let us know what works for you.

Best--

Chuck Engstrom

Re: how do people sharpen scrapers?

#5

Re: how do people sharpen scrapers?

John K Jordan

>I sharpen scrapers with the flat rest on the Tormek, flatten the top with a diamond hone, then use the Veritas burnisher (the one that fastens to a worksurface with screws) to raise a sharp edge. This works extremely well. That burnisher is easier to use than a hand-held one and leaves a smooth, tough, and very sharp edge which holds up far better than a burr left by a grinder. Note that it is easy to raise the cutting edge too much with this burnisher.

If you are getting tearout after sharpening this way, I suspect you are either burnishing too heavily or taking too heavy of a cut for that piece of wood. As someone mentioned, shear scraping (turning the scraper to present an angle instead of holding it flat) may help.

JKJ

Re: how do people sharpen scrapers?

#6

Re: how do people sharpen scrapers?

robo hippy

>I also have a platform on the 80 grit side of my grinder for scrapers, and it is set blunt, in the 75 degree range, but not measured. First, I take it to a diamond stone (320 grit) and wipe off the old burr. Then I place it right side up on the platform. I actually press it into the grinding wheel, not just a light kiss. This gives a nice firm sharp edge. I don't have conventional wheels, I have CBN (cubic boric nitride) wheels. They are very hard, and made for grinding steel, and leave a finer edge than the common grinding wheels, and possible a better edge, but it has been so long since I used a standard wheel that I don't know. I don't burnish a burr on mine. I have used a triangle burnisher with some success, and didn't think the result was any better. With a round burnisher, I didn't get good results. Some people prefer to hone the burr off, and I really haven't experimented with that much, but should. I have heard that really hard woods cut best this way.

Now if you can get a good burr, you still have to learn to cut with it. With the scraper held flat, if you are taking heavy roughing cuts, you will get heavy tear out. With lighter cuts, you will get light tear out, and with whisper cuts, you will get barely any tear out. If you do a shear cut, with the scraper at a 45 degree angle, you can get glass smooth cuts. The best cuts come with a fresh edge. Harder woods tend to give smoother cuts than softer woods.

robo hippy

Re: how do people sharpen scrapers?

#7

Re: how do people sharpen scrapers?

john lucas

>I agree with Robo about the cutting action of a scraper. You have to be really light if you want to reduce tearout and shear scraping with a light cut works best.

I grind my scrapers at 45 degrees and then polish off the burr on the top. I raise a new burr by running the diamond hone up the bevel about 3 or 4 times. I use the medium diamond hone mostly but on some woods I'll go to the fine to make a smaller burr. On most of the woods I use straight off the 100 grit grinder works fine but If it doesn't seem to be cleaning the wood up well enough I knock the burr off and use the diamond hone.

Except for platters, some box interiors, and vases I almost never use the scraper flat.

Re: how do people sharpen scrapers?

#8

Claphams Sanding & Cutting Lubricant

Mike Brazeau

>No, I don't sharpen with this, but it really helps on that last cut on endgrain. I sharpen using pretty much methods outlined by everyone else. You spray it on and then make the final cut. This lubricant has a mineral solvent and beeswax and softens the fibers so that tearout is minimized. As stated by others a very light cut is taken also. Probably a water mist would do the same thing. Apply and then take the cut immediately. Art Liestman introduced our guild to it during a tour in '03. Was developed by Claphams in conjunction with a Canadian West Coast turner, Jason Marlow, I believe. Also reduces sanding dust dramatically.

Re: how do people sharpen scrapers?

#9

Rob Wallace

Re: Claphams Sanding & Cutting Lubricant

Rob Wallace

>Mike: This stuff sounds interesting... Where do you get it? Ordering information? Doesn't get much on a Google search.... Any info would be appreciated... Thanks, Rob

Re: how do people sharpen scrapers?

#10

Re: how do people sharpen scrapers?

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>I sharpen my scrapers to 80 degrees on my Sorby ProEdge, shaping them by hand.

keithz

Re: how do people sharpen scrapers?

#11

Re: I agree with "robo" on the ......

Jamie Donaldson

>... angled shear/scraping method, and for a final cut I prep most surfaces with a lacquer cut with a bit of acetone to stabilize the fibers and reduce tearout. This surface prep works well regardless if the final cut is with scraper or gouge, because anything that reduces sanding is legal in my shop!

Re: how do people sharpen scrapers?

#12

Re: Claphams Sanding & Cutting Lubricant *LINK*

Russ Fairfield

>It's probably their furniture wax with a different label on the can. Crystal Clear works just as well for half the price, and it is available at Staples, Woodcraft, etc.

Most of the brands are available here - - -


http://www.thefurnitureconnoisseur.com/store/cart.php?m=product_list&c=51

Re: how do people sharpen scrapers?

#13

Beg to differ *LINK*

Mike Brazeau

>I have had personal communications with Roger Clapham on the product, trying to get them to give it more profile and have the MSDS on it. It is mostly solvent. I purchase from Woodchuckers in Toronto. Suggest emailing Roger at the link below.


Claphams

Re: how do people sharpen scrapers?

#14

Re: how do people sharpen scrapers?

Mitchell Cholewinski

>If I use my grinder, I set the angle to sharpen to 45degrees. Use a diamond dresser on the top of the scraper before grinding.After 2 passes on grinder I use the Veritas table mounted burnisher, about forty bucks, and worth it.Put a slight burr on the scraper,just a small one will do fine. Now I'm ready to turn. When you sharpen this way your no longer scraping, your cutting and if done right it works beautifully. As for tear out on the wood, the only wood I ever remotely see any tear out on is soft pine.Since this works so good for me I find myself using the scraper a lot more than the gouges. Mitch