Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?------We

Posts

Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?------We

#1

Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?------We

charlie belden

>Michaelangelo was said to have described his approach to sculpting in marble as "seeing the piece in the block of marble and merely freeing it from the surrounding stone".

A while back Gary Knox Bennett / Bennet / Benett (I've seen his last name spelled various ways) submitted a cube of wood, with the largest circle which could be inscribed within each of the six square sides, with centers, to a woodturning competition. His "piece" won the competition. The judges' explanation - the sphere is the perfect 3 dimensional form and the piece submitted had all the information needed to create it - the rest was merely wood removal.

Before "post lathe" work began its dominance of woodturning, it was The Perfect Shape, either in itself, or for a given piece of wood, that was the Holy Grail of woodturning. And short of making The Perfect Shape in ceramics, on a potter's wheel, creating The Perfect Shape involved a lot of time and skill hogging off, and then carefully removing 90 to 95 percent of the wood. OK - so you only needed the outside of The Perfect Shape, the inside was most of the grunt work, some of it butt cheek clenching, teeth grinding grunt work. The point is that to really "see" the piece you had to physically remove everything that didn't look like The Perfect Shape.

Then CAD came along - 3-D CAD specifically. But the learning curve was far steeper than the turning learning curve, and just as fraught with lurking disasters, without the potential broken bones and blood - though heart attacks and migraine headaches rank up there with turning accidents. And when it came to modeling curvilinear surfaces - well the slope of the learning curve was like climbing Everest.

Now along comes Google's SketchUp. SketchUp has taken a new approach to the user interface for 3-D computer modeling, making much of the mental grunt work a LOT easier, but by no means easy.

One of the neat, though not obvious, features of SketchUp is the use of a "tool" called "follow me". Here's how it's used for virtual "turning":

1. using "line" and "curve" tools, create the cross section of your shape in the XZ plane, with the centerline about which you'll later rotate on the X-axis.

2. on the YZ plane, using the X-axis as the center, create a circle.

You now have two virtual "objects" in your computer model

- a flat disk square to your "cross section", centered on the "bottom" of your "cross section"

- your shape's cross section, the bottom of which falls on the centerline of the disk

Think of the disk as your headstock / chuck / headstock drive center.

Using the "select tool", select the disk to tell the program what path you will later want it to follow as it "extrudes" your profile.

Switch to the "follow me" tool and click inside your cross section to select it for "extrusion"

Now move the "follow me" cursor around the perimeter of the "chuck" disk - all the way around if you want a complete shape or as far around as you want if you want a "cut open" part of the shape.

Ta-Da you've got a 3-D model of the shape which you can rotate about to change your view - in real time. Want to add color, using the "select" tool, select a surface on your shape then pick the "paint bucket" tool, pick a color, and "paint" the selected surface with that color. Repeat until all the surfaces are "painted". Now rotate around, changing the view of the piece 'til you see an orientation you like. "Grab" the area of the screen you want, or do a "screenshot" of the screen to create a PhotoShop readable file and then edit that file in PhotoShop (or Adobe Elements 6) to tweek it to the way you like it, then save THAT image to a JPEG or PNG file format for uploading or viewing later.

Attached is an image, the top two items are the SketchUp versions of the shape, the bottom two are Adobe Elements 6 "tweeked" versions. Though I used a simple cylinder to "hollow" the "piece", there's an "offset" tool that yo can use to create the wall thickness in order to create a true (though only virtual) hollow form.

Oh - and you can use a digital image of a piece of wood and use it to "skin" the virtual turning. Haven't tried THAT - yet - but it seems like it'd let you get closer to the look of a real turning.

(This SketchUp "turning" thing has no doubt been posted here before - but it's new to me, and perhaps others in the group).

Back to the reason for this post - my question:

Given that many turners aspire to turn The Perfect Form for a given size blank

and

Given that SketchUp makes it quicker and easier (after a learning curve that's a LOT shallower than that of a turning tool and technique) to create a virtual shape/form

Is creating the "virtual" form the IT for turning, eliminating, or leaving the Wood + Time + Skill for others, along with any post lathe "enhancments", or merely another tool in a turner's bag of tricks?

(I'll leave the "Which is the more important part of the finished piece - the turned piece or the finished (read post lathe "enhancements"/ modifications)- to another time) piece"?

charlie belden

------WebKitFormBoundaryRAJXf+7BC99A1xLv


img

Re: Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?------We

#2

Re: Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?----

Atwerz

>Could you repeat that please?

Re: Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?------We

#3

Re: Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?----

Barry Elder

>I don't care to, thank you very much.

Re: Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?------We

#4

Steven Antonucci

Perfect pieces are illusive

steve antonucci

>Forget about what you can model in SketchUp. The perfect form is a lot more than design. It is the marriage of a great many elements.

Start with an idea. Find the right piece of wood for that idea. Practice your technique so that can actually make the tools do what they need to do. Sand to the appropriate grit. Embellish with whatever technique you need to finish the piece.

In the end, you hope it looks like the SketchUp file.

At least at this point, my use of the computer for turning is limited to posting pictures after the turning is complete.

Steven

Re: Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?------We

#5

Re: Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?----

Mike Jones, Redding, CA

>It's the journey, grasshopper...not the destination.

Re: Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?------We

#6

Re: Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?----

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I turn primarily because I enjoy the physical and creative processes involved. I throw pots for the same reasons.

The pieces are just the by-products of the process...

...and each piece is just practice for the next piece.

Re: Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?------We

#7

Re: Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?----

john lucas

>I see where your going with this but that assumes that the wood doesn't have any figure, grain, defect, etc. Ideally the shape of the wood should have something to do with the characteristics of that piece of wood. Therefore the perfect shape can only be arrived at by removing some of the wood and looking at what's left.

Or we could just design it in one of the cad program. Turn the perfect shape, sand to perfection, finish to perfection, and drive a bent nail in it. :)

Re: Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?------We

#8

Denis Putland

Re: Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?----

Denis Putland

>Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?----

Your ideas would sure take the fun out of woodturning for this guy.

In my feeble mind the true satisfaction comes when my hands and me eyes and the piece of wood combine into that near perfect???? piece.

Don't need no cottonpicking computer programing for me to have fun wid my wood pile:::))))

Denis

Re: Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?------We

#9

Re: Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?----

John Jordan

>Well, it proves that you can make not very good shapes without turning. That pieces has 5 distinctly different curves going in 5 directions, if it were made it wood, it would not be good. I don't mean to be overly critical here, but I'm not sure I get it. Generally we want fair curves. Fair curves don't always = good, but it's a good start.

A chunk of green wood and a bowl gouge can work through explorations in form very quickly, and you can't shorten the learning curve of using a gouge sitting at the computer. (though there's nothing wrong with sitting at the computer)LOL

John

Re: Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?------We

#10

:-)

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?------We

#11

Brad Vietje

Re: Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?----

Brad Vietje

>I was going to point out what John did, and I especially like the comments of John Jordan, too. Wood is not homogeneous and uniform, and each piece is different, so you have to use all your experience and skill to create the nicest piece you can with that particular piece of wood.

I have always believed this concept makes it difficult for some metal workers to become good woodturners, as wood is not metal. It not only WAS alive, but green wood IS alive, and in a sense, wood continues to be alive as it swells and contracts with changes in humidity, which are pretty severe here in New England.

So Charlie, like a lot of others here, I'm not really sure what you are asking or proposing. I agree that the process is just as interesting to me as the outcome, that computers can make sexy-looking approximations of pretty awful forms, (and hey -- my hollow forms are not 3" thick with a mere cylinder drilled in 'em; I gotta give that computer of yours a few lessons!), and that I don't need any computer skills to avoid all the fun I would have in learning to master a certain art or craft form.

And here's the really BIG point: if all this could be done with a computer and a nice printer, we'd only have to buy TWO FREAKIN' TOOLS -- now what's the fun in that???

Having fun way up in Moose country...

Safe spinning,(that would be the actual, not the virtual kind),

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?------We

#12

Dick Hines

Re: Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?----

Dick Hines

>Works good on a computer but can you do it on the lathe. As they say " the proof is in the pudding". In this case in the wood.

I can sse hwre this would be nice to play with if you can't into the shop though. You can play with the shapes that pop in your head and print them and try them on the laihe.

Re: Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?------We

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?----

Keith Tompkins

>HI Charlie, In my opinion, while it's quite amazing what can be done with computer programs, using these programs to design your work is completely missing the point.....take a close look at the furniture that was being built in the centuries prior to ours; all done with hand tools and with no design software or any kind, yet the quality of construction and design have not been improved upon. This work was done by craftsmen who spent years learning their various trades while refining and honing their skills. In contrast, today's furniture is designed on a computer, the drawings are converted to numerical code, and parts are machined by the thousands to within .0005". A person can call themselves a cabinetmaker, yet not know how to sharpen a hand plane or chisel...tools that are now obsolete in a modern shop. Long gone are hand-cut dovetails or intricate joinery of any kind; all production is based on the limitations imposed by the design programs incorporated by the factory. Real wood? Salespeople brag about how their manufactured products looks more like REAL wood than their competitors! My point is, none of this has anything to do with CRAFT or art for that matter, rather, it is about production, speed, and profit....that includes drawing programs. Learning to draw by hand is quite different, and is something I urge all turners to practice. BTW, my day job involves managing a production woodworking shop; my duties include training people to program and operate a $300,000 Onsrud twin-head CNC 27 axis router. Cool? Absolutely. Craft? NO.

Re: Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?------We

#14

Re: Concept ----

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Charlie,

Not long ago there was a movement in the "Art World" known as Conceptual Art. It produced little, if any, actual works which was, actually, the Point; that the "IDEA" was the "Art", the mere "making" was merely craft. In its extreme form, the "artist" wrote up a proposal containing descriptions of the conceptual piece and a dialectic on the strengths and weaknesses of its various aspects; the pieces having never been done, only the pamphlets remain. I regarded these as exercises in literature and wetdreams for art historians.

When doing my Master's at IU in Bloomington, I was briefly influenced by several sculptors who, following others such as Alexander Caulder and George Rickey, were working with large steel and some industrial processes. I had the idea of doing a large 2-part piece in steel, but we had a rule to submit proposals for pieces more that 6' tall to the Department chairman before starting actual construction. I therefore did a number of very detailed drawings including placement of the piece in a particular location, and a write-up of what the piece was about. When my proposal was turned down because of space considerations, I expressed some disappointment at not being able to actually do the piece. The professor acknowledged my feelings but pointed out that I had actually already done the piece as I had very accurately visualized it from most every angle, and had confronted and internalized both the problems and the solutions in my written/drawn proposal. My own foray into the world of conceptual art.

I came away from the effort wiser but very unsatisfied, and also determined to never let the physical part of making take a back seat to thinking the piece through. If we become too cerebral about what we do, we can lose the connection with whatever material we're using, and cut ourselves off from very valuable feedback.

Play with your CAD program all you like. It is, after all, an artform in and of itself. But once you go to the real wood and the physical tools, leave your blueprint behind, and be prepared to take advantage of new ideas that develop along the way.

|;-}}

mm

Re: Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?------We

#15

Re: Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?----

Barry Irby

>It seems to me that the computer generated image is a form of art or craft in itself, just as Mark said. There is a learning curve and skill set involved in generating the image and some tools necessary. But in the end, the image is still a two dimensional representation of a three dimensional object. The Artist must learn to work with the software and machines involved to make it generate and image that represents what he wants to make, but the rest of us must learn to perceive that image in the same way the artist does. The concepts of perspective and 3D images are "learned" and a skill for both the artist and the viewer. I wonder if even the best two dimensional image could convey the same sense of being as the actual object?

Re: Concept + Wood + Time + Skill = THE Piece?------We

#16

Re: Images

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Barry,

As more and more of our information comes from 2-D sources (paper, or monitor screens) I have to wonder if we are creating a generation with seriously deficient spacial abilities. Perhaps the sci-fi writers' fantasy of true hologram projections will reverse the trend.

mm