Re: food safe finishes
Greg Haugen
>Oh Woody. I think you just opened a "can of worms" or "poured fuel on a fire". There's not one subject that is more explosives as this one. Are you a AAW member? If not, find someone who is and find the spring 2008, I think, issue of the "journal" and read Flexner's article on Food Safe Finishes. The short side of it is most any finish is food safe "ONCE CURE". Watco Danish Oil, Waterlox, Lacquer, shellac, etc. all are and "state" on the label "non toxic once cure." This is where the "finish" itself varies. Finishes have different curing times. There is something to be said though for "maintenance." I don't care what finish it is, a single application will not withstand a lifetime of use. The mineral/walnut oil finishes do add some protection but are also easy to "maintain" by recoating and "combustible" rags aren't an issue where as they are with "fast drying oil" finishes. On the other hand tung oil, and other finishes provide a better protection initially it most customer's don't have the know how to "recoat" a bowl with Salad Bowl Finish or something else without wrecking the bowl or burning down the house with oily rags. I'm not saying one or the other is better, it's preference.
Here's a few tips. When you finish a bowl and it's dry. If you want to know if it's cured put it in a cupboard or box for a day. Open the door, or box lid, and smell. If you smell anything it's not cured yet.
As a woodturner, I'd use about anything and feel comfortably safe, I'm educated on the finishes and what's safe or not. The "common" customer is not. There are alot of "myths" that have to be overcomed. I have heard someone freak out about a tung oiled bowl being it was "varnished-that's poison". And then I've heard another freak out about "Mineral Oil-I'm not going to use a bowl that you're using something as it's finish that my Mom used to give me as a laxative." Also some like a "flat" finish and some like a "sheen" finish. People are VERY picking when it comes to anything that touches their food.
If the bowl will be sold, find out what the customer wants, and then use it. If it's not being sold, and it's for yourself use what you want-just make sure the smell is gone before use and enjoy your turning.
There's also something to be said about no finish at all and just a good patina.
Hope that Helps.
Greg H.