Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

DNA

Posts

DNA

#1

DNA

Bob Rogne

>How do you test or check DNA? My last bunch of rough turns mostly all cracked. Wood was Apple, Birch, and Green Ash. Does it absorb water and then dilute itself.

Thanks

Bob R WestMac Turnings

Re: DNA

#2

Re: DNA

Cyril Griesbach

>Yes it will dilute over time as well as evaporate. I don't test it I just add more DNA to my bucket. However, if you check on Dave Smith's blog I believe he has a method for testing it and if I recall correctly it's a test for specific gravity.

Re: DNA

#3

Rob Wallace

Re: DNA *LINK*

Rob Wallace

>I have had good results using denatured alcohol (which should be more appropriately 'acronymized' as "DA", since DNA is a well-established abbreviation for something entirely different!) when drying turned pieces of various species. I use this technique almost routinely when the piece can fit into my alcohol bath, and do think it speeds-up drying and helps reduce cracking/checking. I have some controlled experiments in progress about this, but data are still being collected.

With each use, the alcohol picks-up water from the wood (and likely also from the air), and, over time, becomes more "dilute" with higher and higher water concentrations. Although no true experimental evidence has been shown to date, the recommendation is that alcohol concentrations of less than 70 to 75% are no longer effective in removing water from the turned wood. If you are using "watery" alcohol in your D"N"A bath, this may account for the additional cracking you have reported, since the alcohol treatment is probably doing little to remove the water from within the wood.

The elaborate method that Dave Smith posted about using an electronic balance, standardizing weights of fixed volumes of water and alcohol, and interpolating from a nomograph to determine alcohol concentration is far too much work (IMHO) and expense (time and money) to see if your alcohol has taken-on too much water. He cites the 'high cost' of hydrometers as the reason for using the "Coke bottle and balance" technique. While it is true that laboratory grade hydrometers are costly, the accuracy of measurement needed for this application is far lower than that needed in a research lab. All that is needed to see whether your alcohol is "too wet" is an inexpensive "Proof" measuring hydrometer available from various home beermaking or winemaking stores (available at local homebrewing stores, or on the Internet, including eBay). You would look for a hydrometer that measures alcohol concentration, also known as a "Proof and Tralle" hydrometer, used for distilled spirits. I have purchased them specifically for measuring alcohol concentration of my woodturning alcohol bath at costs per unit of between $8 and $17 --- this is FAR lower than the cost of a decent electronic balance. Furthermore, it takes less than a minute to see what the concentration of the alcohol is.....and you don't have to use a "costly" balance, measure volumes accurately, use a nomograph (with its own errors of use), or take time to try to figure out what the concentration is!

Simply buy a Proof and Tralle hydrometer, float it in your alcohol bath (or, better, use a hydrometer jar or graduated cylinder with the alcohol sample in it), and just read the alcohol concentration from the hydrometer. Most instruments will allow you to read to within 1% - accurate enough for this "ballpark" measurement, since all we are after is a "GO - NO GO" determination of whether the bath has too much water. Reading to "fractional percentages" is entirely unnecessary, and probably exceeds the limits of resolution of the technique anyway.....(significant figures are significant for a reason).

You can check-out various methods of drying woods at the link below, including Dave Smith's information on the alcohol soaking method.

Hope this helps!

Rob Wallace


Processing Woods - Rob Wallace's Woodturning Links

Re: DNA

#4

Ric Taylor

Keep it Simple

Ric Taylor

>Most woods will sink in fresh alcohol. If the wood floats, there is too much water in the alcohol, and it's probably time to change it out.

This is what works for me.

Ric