Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Turning Boxes

Posts

Turning Boxes

#1

Turning Boxes

BobM

>Since attending the symposium and Box making SIN I have gotten interested in turning some boxes. I have some green walnut I would like to use. I cut it into 5� x 5� x 8� rectangles last night and waxed the ends. Using green wood is it best to rough turn it, let it dry and then finish turn it or can I turn them green like a hollow form? They will be end grain boxes. I would like a snug fit lid, but I'm not up to threaded lids yet. Maybe someday!

Re: Turning Boxes

#2

Re: Turning Boxes

Don at Central Illinois

>From evertything I've heard and read and the limited experience with boxes, use dry wood. You might be able to turn to a very rough shape, but if you want a snap fit (tight) the wet wood will warp too much. I'm sure other, more experienced, box makers will add better insight.

Re: Turning Boxes

#3

Mike Stafford

Re: Turning Boxes

Mike Stafford

>Patience is required when starting from green wood for box turning. It is best to rough turn, alcohol soak and let dry for as long as possible before turning a finished shape. The longer you can let the wood sit and dry the better.

Even if I am using dry wood I rough hollow and let the wood acclimate to its surroundings for a month or so. Invariably these rough hollowings will have gone a little oval due to the inside wood being exposed to new levels of humidity.

Re: Turning Boxes

#4

Re: Turning Boxes

john lucas

>Mike said it, patience. If I need a box real quick I rough turn the blanks and then microwave it. Weight it and keep microwaving until it doesn't lose any more weight. Then I try to let them set overnight to pick up a little room moisture. That's the best method I've tried so far on green wood.

By the way, any exotic wood that you buy that has waxed ends it is best to assume that it's still green and follow the above procedure.

Re: Turning Boxes

#5

Re: Turning Boxes

Bill Howatt

>Boxes and spindles are things I generally turn from dry wood. One of the desired characteristics of a box is a nicely fitting lid with a very smooth "jointless" outside surface unless you are making one with an overhanging lid.

When you turn the wood you also are changing any internal tensions so it is a good if you can turn it, let it relax and come to equilibrium with the moisture content, and then finish it off. If you have good dry wood with a straight grain then you can typcially go right to the finish product.

As you can see, my vote is to stay away from green wood for boxes. Nothing wrong with building up a collection of green wood, sealing it and letting it dry. Surprising how fast the time flys by when you are into turning.

Bill

Re: Turning Boxes

#6

Re: Turning Boxes

Barry Irby

>John and Mike are right.

My son and I turned some boxes and the approach we used was to turn blanks....cylinders with a chuck foot on each end, then part them into two pieces and hollow each piece, leaving them plenty thick. Then we taped the two pieces together and put them into a grocery bag for a year or more. Keep the pieces together so you can get matching grain when you turn the box. Write a date on them so when you find them later, you will know how old they are. Never did one with the alcohol soak or the microwave drying, but it would work. (We blasted a holly blank in the microwave so hard it caught on fire, so take it easy.)

Re: Turning Boxes

#7

Re: Turning Boxes

Ed in Leaside

>A buddy of mine had seen a cherry teardrop box I'd made, and asked if I could make one for his wife (Valentine's '07). We decided to make it from green walnut so as to have the contrast from the sap & heartwood. Roughed it out and put it beside the woodstove for a 3 or 4 days, rotating it every hour or so. Trimmed a bit more off it and back beside the stove for another day. IIRC it took about 1 week from start to finish.


img

Re: Turning Boxes

#8

Re: Turning Boxes

Nick

>I've been turning boxes for the past eight years or so. I use green wood whenever I can get it because it hollows quickly. After rough turning, I put the pieces in two layers of paper bags to dry. Generally, 3 months per quarter inch of wall thickness is sufficient. Be sure to let the dry pieces rest for a while after final turning but before fitting the lid. Most of this can be found in Richard Raffan's excellent book, "Turning Boxes." By the way, walnut doesn't change shape much while drying; it's very good for boxes.

Re: Turning Boxes

#9

Re: Turning Boxes

Ron in Drums PA

>Whenever I turn green wood for boxes, I rough and hollow out, then wrap them in a brown paper bag. I place the bag next to my oil burner. They dry out in 2-3 weeks in the winter, longer in the summer, maybe 4-6 weeks. Then I turn to finish.

I know it's just me, but I don't like to turn wood after it's been nuked. The wood just doesn't feel right. It's all dry and unfriendly.

Re: Turning Boxes

#10

Re: Turning Boxes

Don at Central Illinois

>I'd be unfriendly too, if I was stuck on some machine spinning at who knows how many RPM's and someone sticking a sharpened steel whatever in me!!

Re: Turning Boxes

#11

Re: Turning Boxes

BobM

>Thanks for all the good tips and advice. I'll let you know how they turn out. This is a great group of people and always willing to help.

Re: Turning Boxes

#12

Bob, I think you would benefit ...

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>from Richard Raffan's book, "Turning Boxes", and his tape. He very clearly believes in rough turning box blanks if the wood is not dry. He stayed with us for a few days before the Symposium and he brought me a box blank of Gidgee that was taped together and told me about how long ago it had been rough-turned. I went to one of his rotations in Richmond and he mentioned what happens if a box is made from wood that isn't completely dry. The box and the lid will each oval a little, which means that the lid can be too tight if it is not precisely aligned.

Be patient. Let your wood dry and take your time when fitting the lid. Heat builds up when you hollow a box, so if you make the lid first and try to fit the lid immediately after hollowing the box, the box will cool later and you will end up with a loose-fitting lid. RR suggested that you eat your lunch before the final fitting of the lid. I have a very pretty black and white ebony box with a loose-fitting lid for exactly this reason. I should have let things cool down and equalize a bit, but I was in a hurry. If there is some moisture present and the box is still warm, then you double the chance of getting a loose lid. Letting it sit overnight before final fitting the lid would be a smart move.

Do not assume that kiln-dried wood is dry. A few years ago I made fifteen collection plates for our church when we got a new sanctuary. Now I am making five more. I have rough turned the 12/4 mahogany and have let the "plates" sit for a couple of months even though the mahogany was kiln-dried. There is a little evidence of movement in the original plates and I hope to avoid that this time. After I turn some boxes I will finish that project.

Ed

Re: Turning Boxes

#13

Re: Bob, I think you would benefit ...

BobM

>Ed,

Thanks for the input. I have the RR book and have been reading and studying it. There is a lot of information in it. I don't have the tape but, will try to find it, hopefully in our club library.