Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Good With A Few Or Adequate With Many (again) *LINK*

Posts

Good With A Few Or Adequate With Many (again) *LINK*

#1

Good With A Few Or Adequate With Many (again) *LINK*

charlie belden

>Turning is such an expansive branch of woodworking, with new materials, new tools and new techniques popping up constantly and, thanks to the internet, lots of turners become aware of the changes very quickly. Then someone sees a potential market and Madison Avenue gets into the act to convince turners You Gotta Have THIS Blurfle! And THEN - YOU can make Thing-A-Majigs JUST LIKE _______!

The reality is that regardless of what tool or technique you use to turn any of the myriad of things you can make using a lathe - there is a learning curve. Where on the learning curve you choose to stop may be an hour into it or a lifetime of learning.

But until the last 25 or 30 years, turners used a few gouges and chisels and "made do" with those - in many instances, "making do" was pretty damned amazing and really really good. In no small part, this was probably because they got really really familiar with using just a few tools - and used those few tools for all kinds of things which are now done with a myriad of new specialized tools, each with its own learning curve.

When I first got into turning I bought a small set of mini- tools, a 1/4" spear point parting tool, a 1/2" skew and a spindle gouge (which was so small it was dangerous - catching at every opportunity). With only a few tools to play with I used the skew a lot. And once Peter Pipe showed me how to put a curve in the cutting edge I used it in new ways - and eventually used it to do both the outside AND inside of turned lidded boxes. And for realy tight beads and small balls I used a 1/4" single bevel bench chisel from my flat work rack full of bench chisels and a 1/16th inch parting tool made from an old bayonet saw blade - teeth ground off of course.

Because I didn't know that there were "better ways" of doing the things I was doing, two things happened. First, I get pretty good with a skew - using it a lot of different ways to do a lot of different things, some of which it was probably never intended do - the Ignorance is Bliss thing.

(all the finialed lidded boxes - with the exception of the three sided box at the bottom of the page - at this link were done with three of the four tools noted above)

BUT - the second things was that I was limiting the possibilities of what I COULD turn. Hollow forms - with a single small opening - which had undercuts INSIDE - well I COULD "cheat" and open up the "bottom", do the inside, then plug up the bottom hole - but that seemed somewhat dishonests.

THEN - I bought a few books, got a few DVDS, discovered some turning forums - and Became Aware - Enlightened as it were, to a BUNCH of other possibilities. BUT - many of those possibilities required getting and learning to use New Tools and New Techniques. And like a kid in a candy store - I began bouncing around like a BB in a box car - OH! Try THIS! - No Try THAT!.

Now it's a given to many here that ANY new tool or new technique requires an investment in time to get good with a tool or technique, despite what the advertisements and reviews say. And by the time you're getting pretty good with THAT tool or technique - there's another New And Better Way that's come out.

Steve A. asked, in an earlier post, "Are You A Learner?" which included "And why not shoot for - and expect to get to - near perfection rather than to adequate?".

The reality is that there are so MANY possibilities in the wood turning universe and hundreds of tools to do some of them - is it even possible to get really good with all of them or even half of them?

With the skew I followed James Krenov's lead - do a few things, but do them as close to perfection as you can - and keep trying for perfection.

BUT - I also have a gouges and chisels holder full of gouges and chisels - some I haven't even used yet - AND - I just got the articulated arm MiniMonster captured hollowing system for - a JET mini. The MiniMonster cost more than the lathe I use it on. And now I'm starting to lust after an "eccentric" chuck.

So for those here who spend time and effort -and money - on more than just a handful of tools - and for whom anything less than getting VERY good - or excellent - with each and every one is disappointing - HOW THE HELL DO YOU DO IT? (and when do you sleep?). More important - can it still stay fun if you go that route?

charlie belden

aka Bouncing BB


lidded boxes with a skew and a parting tool

Re: Good With A Few Or Adequate With Many (again) *LINK*

#2

Steven Antonucci

Foundational Learning

steve antonucci

>The approach that many people fail to digest is that there are two basic ways to cut wood: scraping and cutting (bevel contact).

If you were to hand me a "new tool" that was somehow better than my old tools, I would likely ask you how it cut. Whether it was a cutting tool or a scraping tool, I would know how to use it immediately, because I've developed those skills and can appreciate when and where both are applied.

Until people that these things to heart, they can only do what they can do. There isn't a lot to be taught, but tons of practice until it becomes second nature.

I picked up a skew to face off a piece of wet walnut. One of the guys uttered a caution about how he wouldn't do that, and a crowd formed to watch me "implode". Know what? I didn't, because I know how to use a skew for that cut through countless repetition. On that day, I turned with a spindle gouge, a bowl gouge, and a skew.

We all build skills on top of skills, and it lets us do the things we want to do without having to stress over "if" we can do them. "If" disappears, and the challenges become much more about vision than execution.

Once you get past the tools, it actually gets harder...

Steven

Re: Good With A Few Or Adequate With Many (again) *LINK*

#3

Re: Good With A Few Or Adequate With Many (again)

Halsey

>I like your site and tutorials. Nice job . Thanks you for posting it. Halsey

Re: Good With A Few Or Adequate With Many (again) *LINK*

#4

Thoughtful exploration, Thanks!

Jerry Hall

>

Re: Good With A Few Or Adequate With Many (again) *LINK*

#5

Re: Good With A Few Or Adequate With Many (again)

Mike Jones, Redding, CA

>A fine art painter may have lots of brushes...and use them all as the work requires. Why would the mechanic have so many wrenches? Wouldn't one or two crescent wrenches be sufficient if he just learned to use them proficiently? I think my dentist is the biggest tool junkie I've ever seen and I am glad that he dosen't use just one burr.