Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Two more bowl gouge flute profiles *LINK*

Posts

Two more bowl gouge flute profiles *LINK*

#1

Two more bowl gouge flute profiles *LINK*

Gordon Seto

>In addition to those I posted earlier, these are the side by side comparison of the Thompson 5/8� �V� and �U� bowl gouges.

The pictures of the other gouges can be found here:

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/turning3.pl?frames;read=185334#185334

Gary Guenther (GaryG in MD) has approached me and suggested he would write an article summing up the collective wisdom from posts regarding the effects on flute profiles. We hope this will generate a lot of subjective comments so we can all benefit from the findings.

Gary has two PSI Benjamin�s Best LX230 5/8� bowl gouges; he is going to loan them to me at the Richmond Symposium. I am going to include them when I come back from Symposium.

Gordon


img

Bowl gouge flute shape

Re: Two more bowl gouge flute profiles *LINK*

#2

Re: Two more bowl gouge flute profiles

Gordon Seto

>When I posted the pictures, a keen turner noticed the flute on the Mastercut gouges was not symmetrical and asked whether the mold got deformed when I remove the gouge. So I did another casting. It confirmed that it is slightly lopsided. I didn�t buy this gouge brand new. I bought it from a member who moved to a retirement community. I don�t know whether he bought it as seconds or not. I had the gouge for several years; I never noticed any irregularity in its flute until in the cast. This proves my point that casting the molds helps us to see the difference better.


img

Re: Two more bowl gouge flute profiles *LINK*

#3

Re: Two more bowl gouge flute profiles

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Thank you taking the time to cast each flute... a article would be interesting.

To me my flute shapes look very shallow but they are below the centerline which is needed so a bowl gouge handles well.

Re: Two more bowl gouge flute profiles *LINK*

#4

Re: Two more bowl gouge flute profiles

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>The flute is off center, it shows much better in the second casting.

Re: Two more bowl gouge flute profiles *LINK*

#5

further information...

GaryG in MD

>I quit using the BBs when I started buying Doug's A-11s. Haven't touched them since -- once you've used a Thompson tool, there's no going back.

What's interesting is that although they carry the exactly same "LX-230" designation, the flutes on the two BBs are as different as apples and oranges. I don't remember which one I got first, but they're both PSI. One has a moderately deep parabolic flute, and the other has a very deep V flute. The only thing they have in common, other than the designations and the handles, is the rod diameter. (I actually bought the second one specifically because it was different.) For that reason, they will be interesting to see from the perspective of Gordon's cross-section molds. ...Gary

Re: Two more bowl gouge flute profiles *LINK*

#6

I have a question and a theory

Gordon Seto

>My experience with smaller diameter bowl gouges is they can�t extend over the tool rest much. They are likely to chatter. Doug Thompson has been recommending turners, who don�t know what to get, to get a 3/8� or �� bowl gouge if they have a mini lathe. He uses 3/8� and �� bowl gouges to turn his full size cowboy hat at his demo.

I already have enough bowl gouges of various sizes; I don�t have a lot of Thompson bowl gouges. (Doug loaned me the 5/8� U & V for making the molds) My chattering experience was based on other brands of smaller bowl gouges.

After carefully examining the flute profiles, I come up with a theory. I want to see whether my theory makes sense. If the smaller gouges are the scaled back version of the 5/8� gouges. The Thompson U & V bowl gouges have thicker steel under the flutes. Of course Doug is making his size recommendation based on his Thompson gouges. Do we need to use a bigger bowl gouge to compensate for gouges with less steel? What is the advantage of having thinner steel?

I have been wondering about this for some time. I didn�t post this in the original post, because I want more diversified discussion.

Re: Two more bowl gouge flute profiles *LINK*

#7

Re: I have a question and a theory

GaryG in MD

>The thicker the steel, the farther off the tool rest you can work without chatter. Offhand, I can't think of any advantages for thin steel other than the fact that a U-shaped gouge will generally have thinner walls than a V shape, and U's definitely have their uses and proponents. I have a Henry Taylor 3/8" U-BG that I like very much, but it's pretty thin, and I have to limit the extension. ...Gary