>The burl has lots of eyes, which can be seen inside the box or on the bottom. The lid is actually walnut that I dyed black and then applied ebony wax (Bri-Wax) and shellac. I do not try for a suction fit when I use an inset lid. Those who buy such a box want the lid to lift off unimpeded. Shellawax finish on the maple.
>That is a great looking box, Ed and I like the way you incorporated the recessed knob. Sleek solution yet practical to use. I look forward to seeing it as well.
>Good looking piece Ed. I like the recess a lot. But. Seems like there is always some but around some where. I would like to see the knob smaller diameter and taller.
>a lid where you start with a curve in profile that extends from one side of the top of the base to the other. Then a knob is achieved by relieving that curved surface.
The profile you suggest would require a much higher arc across top and you would relieve much more. I think you would lose the effect that I was seeking. It might look better as you suggest, but it would lose what I was trying to achieve.
I think this box is a wonderful design and well executed. I love the the contrast of the lid next to the burl and the way the two curves of the lid surface and knob suggest a lens-like volume. I'm not so sure about the side profile of the box, but I suspect we can't appreciate the true shape from the photo alone.
With apology in advance, I plan to steal parts of this design for a box I want to make for a very young lady (soon to be born!). This would be a perfect box to set on a dresser. Very nice.
BTW, for those looking for gift ideas, a little wooden box is a wonderful present for a young lady of any age and can be used for things from diaper pins to jewelry - a hand-made box can be a unique and treasured gift at a baby shower.