Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Club Demo Question

Posts

Club Demo Question

#1

Steven Antonucci

Club Demo Question

steve antonucci

>I'll be doing the club demo next month on hollowing, and I wanted to get a straw poll on education vs. entertainment.

When you go to a club demo, which do you think is more important? I will be teaching the basic techniques of hollowform turning, but my audience will be varied. I know some people want to see how it is done, but will never do it.(Entertainment)

There will also be a smaller subset of people who actually will go out after the demo and try it. (Education) How do you balance the stuff you need to keep it moving with the stuff that you need to get the technical points across?

At this point, my intent is to bury folks in details, but I'm starting to think that might be the wrong way to do it.

So, why do you go to club demos?

Steven

Re: Club Demo Question

#2

Re: Club Demo Question

john lucas

>Steve I try to talk constantly. I find that everyone is actually there to be entertained even though some are actually there to learn.

I try to explain everything that I do so that hopefully I will answer everyones questions. Next time I do hollow turning I'm going to cut holes in the sided of the vessel so we can put a camera over it and they can see how I use the tool. I've done this once before for a home demo and it worked great. If I still have the photo I took I'll try to post it tonight. Obviously they can't see what is happening on the inside which makes hollowing boring. This method should help.

I also liked someones suggestion about taking a flat piece and putting the dimple in the middle. This could be a seperate part of the demo but everyone could see how to remove the dimple.

Re: Club Demo Question

#3

Re: Club Demo Question

Wilford Bickel

>Steve - if I am doing something getting started that I know is a very beginner type of activity I will ask the more experienced turners to please be patient that we were all there at one time and I will get to their interest in just a few minutes. It is surprising how many will start speaking up to add to what I am telling the beginners to even give them more help. The average woodturner is a very sharing individual with beginners and does not mind passing on their mistakes to keep others from making them.

I find the more you can get the crowd asking questions and making comments the better - don't have your demo so structured that you cannot take a minor (or major!) detour if someone asks a question. This keeps the group involved and they get much more enjoyment out of the demo. Some of the demo's I have gotten the best response to have been the ones that the crowd took over and led off in a way I did not plan to go but by rolling with the flow they got what THEY wanted to learn.

Re: Club Demo Question

#4

Re: Hollowing is one of the most .....

Jamie Donaldson

>...."boring" demos around, but many are interested in the process. John's suggestion about a picture window in the side is excellent, a trick that David Ellsworth uses to show how the tool is positioned as well as allowing the shavings to self-evacuate. This saves much time and the need for a compressor or vacuum, and increases the pucker factor for both demonstrator and viewers! Turn a small piece to keep the demo to a reasonably short time period.

Re: Club Demo Question

#5

Re: Club Demo Question

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>When I do my mini hollow form demo, I started by passing out an illustrated 'tutorial' so they could follow along. The primary reason I did this was because my club does not currently have a video system. I have found that having the handout encourages questions from the audience.

Like John said, I try to talk as much as possible and find that I share things that happen while doing the turning. Also, while doing each step, I try to explain the details of what I am doing and why I am doing it. I encourage questions and always stop what I am doing to answer it. Sometimes that leads to more questions from others. After all the questions, I go on.

If the time available to do the demo is short, I set up 3 or 4 key steps ahead of time in order to keep things moving. If I have as much time as needed, I don't.

keithz

Re: Club Demo Question

#6

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Club Demo Question

Jesper, Denmark

>I think people go to demos to learn.

You obviously want to share your knowledge with the audience.

I do not have a clue as to how this principle can be used in a turning demo, but I often have to make presentations to groups of around 10-15 people of what I know about my subject. I do the following:

After the usual polite introductions, I sit down atthe conference table with nothing on the table but a pad and a pencil. No brochures. No visual aids. Nothing.

If I can shut up and not say anything for 30 seconds, someone will ask a question. While answering that question, someone else will have thought up another question, eager to get the answer as soon as I have finished.

Hours later, I have talked about the parts of my subject the audience were interested in.

Had I started from my background, I would never have gotten any feed back from the audience and may have lost a lot of them.

Maybe you chuck a piece up in the lathe and ask the audience: "Where should we start?"

If you can shut up long enough, someone will make the first suggestion. You are off and running - and you will be amazed at the audience participation.

Re: Club Demo Question

#7

Jesper, Denmark

P.S. I know squat about hollowing.

Jesper, Denmark

>

Re: Club Demo Question

#8

Re: Club Demo Question

E. Tabachek

>This is a great question, Steve. I believe that club meeting demos are for entertainment and general information only. There are too many other distractions and the time is too short to get into the details of many techniques (particularly advanced ones like hollowing). A "hands on" workshop is the place to really get into the details and "secrets of the masters" of any technique. I have sat (or rather stood) through many demos where the person lost me in the boring details of a technique that I was never going to remember never mind apply. If I came to your demo, I would like to know more about your approach to what you make and why you do it. What influences your work. How you got started. Take samples of your work; finished and unfinished. Many demo people do not bring finished items to show. And, if you have them, turnings that did not work out. Plan on being too brief rather than too long, if your audience is up to speed (advanced in their turning experience) they will have questions.

ET

Re: Club Demo Question

#9

Re: Club Demo Question

robo hippy

>Steve,

As fate would have it, I am doing our next club demonstration. It will be on end grain cutting tools. This will cover hollow forms, boxes, open vessels, and bowls. It will be about all the specialized tools that I have for this type of cutting: scrapers, gouges, McNaughton, tear drop scrapers, Berger tool, Monster hollowing set up, Eliminator, and maybe a few others. It will be hands on. It won't be about design, only about tools.

I usually start with a disclaimer some thing like: I will be showing you what I do, and how I do it. These are skills that I have developed, and still am developing. What I do may work for you, or it may not. I haven't done anything to the point that I do it the same way every time, which means that I reserve the right to change my mind about how I do things in the future. Some of what I do may be considered 'professional driver on closed course, do not attempt'. Work your way up to things.

I don't go to really entertain, I go to teach what I know. I have been to some demos where the person spent more time talking, and less time doing something, and I find those boring. I go to learn, and even if I know how to do what is being demonstrated, I go to see what they do that I don't. I don't think I have ever seen a demo that I didn't learn some thing from.

I also like demos because of the questions asked. It seems like I always forget to talk about some thing, and some one will always ask a question about it.

robo hippy

Re: Club Demo Question

#10

The disclaimer is very important...

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>as people need to be informed that you are only demonstrating what you know, what you do, and how you do it, and, that what and how you are demoing is not necessarily what and how they should do it.

keithz

Re: Club Demo Question

#11

Steven Antonucci

I always say "If I were you, I wouldn't do this"

steve antonucci

>but I can...

I had a club member in the shop last night, and I was showing him how I cut the outside of my hollowform with a skew to reduce the amount of sanding I need to do. I was getting ready to show him what happened when a catch occurs (and why a catch occurs), and I "demoed' a catch probably better than anyone has ever demoed a catch before.

It was at least 3/4" deep, and cavernous. Scare the be-geebers out of both of us. I then proceeded to demo how to get rid of it with a skew...

Just because I do it, doesn't mean you should...

Steven

P.S. I have a whole list of disclaimers built into the front of my demo... including using a homemade hook tool inside of a hollowform!

Re: Club Demo Question

#12

Steven Antonucci

"Boring"... good one.

steve antonucci

>I'll be sure to make a few "boring" jokes while I turn.

Personally, I'm pretty bored by watching almost anyone turn. I enjoy the demos that don't involve a lathe spinning and cover a topic via conversation and slide show. You can get a lot done with PowerPoint that you cannot with a room full of people watching wood...

steven

Re: Club Demo Question

#13

Re: "Boring"... good one.

E. Tabachek

>That is a better idea, Steve. ET

Re: Club Demo Question

#14

Steven Antonucci

Something for everyone...

steve antonucci

>I have my whole session planned. It starts on the projector, and ends on the lathe. I will cover things that are simple to illustrate with pictures, but require me to pack a small shop into the truck to do in person. If you can't see what I'm doing in the picture, you probably shouldn't try it at home.

Once the lathe goes on, I will have about 30 minutes start to finish to get my point across. This means I need to go from a cylinder to a shape, and then hollow the whole thing in that time. Removing the wood shouldn't take that long, since I will be doing a relatively "easy" form. The only question was how much theory and detail I would cover vs. how much influence and concept. Since you can't see what's happening inside anyway, I figured that the hollowing part wouldn't be the bulk of the program. I might even have a second almost completed form around for the demo...

Now I just need more woodturning jokes to carry the more "boring' sections.

Steven

Re: Club Demo Question

#15

Re: Club Demo Question

E. Tabachek

>Robo, leave something for next time, and the next person. Our club never, ever has to demo hollow turning again. We have been given four monthly meetings of hollowing of all vessels with all kinds of tools by the local hollowing expert. There is nothing left to demo. He sort of expanded what should have been a one or two meeting program into four. no one will pay to see a guest turner do any hollowing, either, so forget that. To many of our new turnimg members woodturning IS hollow turning.

I don't believe that a club membership should be a cheap way to learn how to turn wood. At meetings, we can answer questions, show off our work, brag about having the biggest stash of burls, solve problems, share wood, have coffee and goodies and do clubby kinds of things; but if you want to learn something in depth, pay an expert to teach you.

ET

Re: Club Demo Question

#16

Re: Club Demo Question

John Kyler

>I teach and Demo often all across the country. I would say, entertaining and educational VS just educational.

Why not both!

Learning should never be painful, and should be fun. As I put it in my Demo/classes "misery is optional" you decide.

Get to the point and have fun getting there.

John