Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?
charlie belden
>A quote in an article on Clay Foster in the June 2008 issue of More Woodturning raises some interesting questions.
�The focus of attention for much of contemporary woodturning is on precision, execution and perfection.� Clay Foster chooses to celebrate irregularities, casual execution and spontaneous design.�
Is there a line between �casual execution� and �poor work�? I sthere a point beyond which turning trips over into Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD)?
Where�s the line between the Hyper Control Phreak �perfect form�, �perfect technique� and �perfect finish� - and - the Loosey Goosey - �quick and dirty�, �no design in mind or intended�, "spontaneous" piece?
Since rose engine work involves very little spontanaity, requires bone dry (ok, so THAT dry is too dry) wood and the mindset of a machinist, let�s call that one extreme end of the spectrum.
The charred bandsawn faceted chunk of wood with the RED hemisphere turned off the center of one of those facets - the one on the cover of a recent AAW magazine - is representative of the other end of the spectrum.
With the former, the opportunities for spontanaity are few, mostly mental, at the beginning of what is a slow, precise, repatative procedure that offers few �options� as the piece is being done.
With the latter, I supsect the entire process was spontaneous - �I can�t find ANY good wood in the log I started with - but THIS piece IS big enough to turn SOMETHING in - and I wonder what would happen if I go at it with a propane torch first - THEN mount it on the lathe? Well THAT didn�t go anywhere. Hey - I�ve got this RED paint. . . � Not much precision - but a whole lot of spontanaity.
And then there�s Graeme Priddles sculpted pieces - a curious balance of spontanaity - and precision. Escoulen�s pieces appear to be the result of playful spontanaity - but if you�ve tried that type of turning you know a purely spontaneous approach can lead to a disasterous outcome. Malcom Tibbetts� amazing execution of a thought provoking idea - can there be ANY spontanaity in doing what he does? Or J. Paul Fennel�s pierced and/or carved sensuous pieces - where does he come down on the spectrum?
Personally, I jump around - sort of BiPolar turning. I REALLY enjoy turning lidded boxes, with finials - and maybe a lid inside. This type of piece permits some spontanaity - but doesn�t lend itself to Loosey Goosy. But I also like to experiment - �I wonder what would happen if I ...� If the results can�t be cut or sanded smooth, or if there�s a crack in the piece as it�s being made, or a nasty void, or inclusion in the surface - it�s Bail Out Time - for me. And the fun and games of �hollow forms� - through small openings - starts out spontaneous - while doing the outside forming - but a very focused, very controlled thing once working on the inside begins.
So do YOU trend towards one end of the spectrum? Which one? Why?
What do YOU think of some of the �spontaneous� pieces showing up on the covers or featured articles in woodturning magazines and books?
Perhaps the beauty of wood turning is that there�s room for just about any turning idea and approach - even at the top of the Artistic Heap.



