Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

Posts

Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

#1

Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

charlie belden

>A quote in an article on Clay Foster in the June 2008 issue of More Woodturning raises some interesting questions.

�The focus of attention for much of contemporary woodturning is on precision, execution and perfection.� Clay Foster chooses to celebrate irregularities, casual execution and spontaneous design.�

Is there a line between �casual execution� and �poor work�? I sthere a point beyond which turning trips over into Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD)?

Where�s the line between the Hyper Control Phreak �perfect form�, �perfect technique� and �perfect finish� - and - the Loosey Goosey - �quick and dirty�, �no design in mind or intended�, "spontaneous" piece?

Since rose engine work involves very little spontanaity, requires bone dry (ok, so THAT dry is too dry) wood and the mindset of a machinist, let�s call that one extreme end of the spectrum.

The charred bandsawn faceted chunk of wood with the RED hemisphere turned off the center of one of those facets - the one on the cover of a recent AAW magazine - is representative of the other end of the spectrum.

With the former, the opportunities for spontanaity are few, mostly mental, at the beginning of what is a slow, precise, repatative procedure that offers few �options� as the piece is being done.

With the latter, I supsect the entire process was spontaneous - �I can�t find ANY good wood in the log I started with - but THIS piece IS big enough to turn SOMETHING in - and I wonder what would happen if I go at it with a propane torch first - THEN mount it on the lathe? Well THAT didn�t go anywhere. Hey - I�ve got this RED paint. . . � Not much precision - but a whole lot of spontanaity.

And then there�s Graeme Priddles sculpted pieces - a curious balance of spontanaity - and precision. Escoulen�s pieces appear to be the result of playful spontanaity - but if you�ve tried that type of turning you know a purely spontaneous approach can lead to a disasterous outcome. Malcom Tibbetts� amazing execution of a thought provoking idea - can there be ANY spontanaity in doing what he does? Or J. Paul Fennel�s pierced and/or carved sensuous pieces - where does he come down on the spectrum?

Personally, I jump around - sort of BiPolar turning. I REALLY enjoy turning lidded boxes, with finials - and maybe a lid inside. This type of piece permits some spontanaity - but doesn�t lend itself to Loosey Goosy. But I also like to experiment - �I wonder what would happen if I ...� If the results can�t be cut or sanded smooth, or if there�s a crack in the piece as it�s being made, or a nasty void, or inclusion in the surface - it�s Bail Out Time - for me. And the fun and games of �hollow forms� - through small openings - starts out spontaneous - while doing the outside forming - but a very focused, very controlled thing once working on the inside begins.

So do YOU trend towards one end of the spectrum? Which one? Why?

What do YOU think of some of the �spontaneous� pieces showing up on the covers or featured articles in woodturning magazines and books?

Perhaps the beauty of wood turning is that there�s room for just about any turning idea and approach - even at the top of the Artistic Heap.

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

#2

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

Greg Haugen

>Charlie,

I think the key to it is "intent". Some work that looks "rough" is designed to look that way, other "rough" work is for other reasons. Example of this would be the boxes that Raffan makes that looks like they're relics of an ancient society. Nothing is crisp and defined but has an awesome appearance. "Intent" has to be a factor. Not everyone will like every piece of work they see.

That's one thing that's great about turning, woodworking, or other crafts. The maker can make what they want. It's they're work. When it comes to selling it is where they can start and should take feedback from the customers. Some people like a refined scenic painting and someone may like a painting that could have been made by being a "backstop" for a paintball gun range.

I'm more of a spindle turner, my skews are cherished in my shop. I'm more of a detail or precision oriented turner. That is a requirement of spindle turners. It would be difficult to copy spindles and not be detail driven.

Interesting post though Charlie. Should be interesting to read the responses.

Greg H.

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

#3

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>I like both. I try to do both ends, but have not yet made to either end of the line. It is my feeling that I'm mostly at the precision end and am trying to expand my horizons to get closer to the "spontaneous" end.

I truly believe that in order for one to successful at the spontaneous, he or she must first be successful at the precision end. Learn the tools and techniques, then leave them and take your experiences to new places.

keithz

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

#4

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

Al Neighbors

>Interesting post... I've never thought about the subject, so I don't really know where I am supposed to be in all of it. I don't consider myself in the same category as those you named in your post, Charlie. I've only been turning since 2003, so it's for sure that I'm not a master of the art. I normally consider myself ranking along there with most beginning wood turners.

I certainly have a lot of fun. And I've made a 'good bit' of change, selling at craft shows, for the last few years. But I guess there must be many times that my "intent" sort of fades away... not long after I turn on the lathe. :)

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

#5

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

mpax356

>I am a relatively new turner and tend to be detail oriented. I work on refining by turning abilities and techniques and skill with the different tools and finishes. I tend to be somewhat patient.

It was an eye opener to me to spend some time with a turner with less patience. He carves on his bowls and vases with the design coming from some feature or defect in the wood. He actually gets pretty good money for his work. His turning techniques work for him but tend to be non standard and perhaps a little crude and in some ways dangerous. Example would be his use of a spindle roughing gouge on a bowl. But the results are artistic and beautiful but perhaps not as refined or perfect in the details. I would say he tends toward being impatient and wanting quick results. As I focus on trying to develop my artistic abilities I may get more spontaneous or not. I suspect I will still lean to focusing on craft as I strive for art. I do not believe that spontaneity is synonomous with artistic, in that a spontaneous effort could be judged by many as ugly. Anyway, it is a fun journey!

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

#6

Jesper, Denmark

Re: On my own.......

Jesper, Denmark

>The beauty of turning is that you can take chunk of wood and in a few hours see what you can make of it.

I don't want to sell any.

I don't want to impress anybody - but me. (But I don't always!)( Actually, maybe not even often)

Having made something that I like and someone else is happy to receive is a pleasure.

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

#7

Challenge rules!

Mike Jones, Redding, CA

>I get challenged by a idea and will work on that idea until the results are complete failure or satisfying success. If I have focussed my attention on a difficult form/finish/technique for over a week or two, I seem to need the outlet of whipping out a few quick and easy pieces, but the quick and easy only satisfy briefly, like Chinese food, then I am hungry again...for the "beyond my capability" new experience.

It's the challenge that dictates the patience, the discipline, the planning (or not) and the technique that the piece demands of me.

Sometimes obsessive-compulsive, sometimes not. But when in the shop, always pretty grateful for all that it has taken to allow me to be there...lost in my little world, having a grand time!

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

#8

JL

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

JL

>Like Greg, I'm a spindle turner mostly. You want all of the legs to look alike :) - so I guess I'm detail oriented.

I also have to have the end diameters of my stretchers at just under 5/8" for ~2". Not much of a chance for spontaneity there either :).

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

#9

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

john lucas

>Wow Interesting thread. There seem to be 2 things going on. One is where do I stand in realation to the extremes of woodturning.

The other is a sort of discussion on techniques vs final product.

To me there are actually 3 groups (if you really lump them loosely). First is the perfectionist or purest. As examples I use Stewart Mortimer, David Ellsworth, John Jordan,Malcolm Tibbets and Mark Kauder. These guys go after a perfect form and technique and through years of practice have acheived it.

Then the rough group. With these I would put Mark Linquist, Robyn Horn, Stoney Lamar, Todd Hoyer and maybe somewhat loosely Clay Foster. This group produces rougher looking work but it is well thought out and the roughness is a planned design element to evoke the response they want from the work. This has usually evolved from doing traditional work with all the skills associated with such, but they have chosen to depart from this perfection and have the skills to do so.

Then there's me. I'm tend to either have a design idea in mind and look for the piece of wood or other material that will let me create it. Or I have a piece of material that I look at for months and all of a sudden one day it just comes together and I make something. I still struggle for good form and have the skills to turn most anything.

What I'm lacking in my mind is direction. I need to decide whether I want to say something with my work. If I do then I have to decide what, and how to say it. Do I simply want to sell work to make extra money. If so then mirrors, bowls, vessels, wine stopper, etc are in order and I just have to make a whole bunch of them. If I want my work to go to a higher audience then I have to look at what I'm doing more seriously and decide how to get there. I think my Cardiac Lamp and Tin Man and a few of the other pieces that I'm still hording in boxes are a step in the right direction.

Did I mention there is a third category of turners that I put in the conseptual category. People like Binh Pho, Frank Sudol and Steve Sinner come to mind. They produce work that tells a story.

There are so many other possibilites with Turned work that it boggles the mind. You can take it in just about any direction you want. I guess that is what makes it so fun.

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

#10

Steven Antonucci

I like wood, but I'm no machinist

steve antonucci

>I had an interesting discussion with a well known turner not very long ago. At heart, he is a machinist. His work is exceptionally detailed and precise, almost to the point of obsessive.

Next to his work was one of my pieces. I am not one of those guys who sands wood to 12000 grit with micromesh. Sometimes, I don't even sand it at all. Most times, 220-320 is about my limit.

We both work very thin, less than 1/8" most of the time. In his world, a 1/16" makes a difference. In mine, it's not even noticable. A sanding mistake in his world is inexcusable. In mine, sanding isn't what people notice first.

To an outsider (a non-turner), there wouldn't be a lot of "technical" difference between either his work or mine. They'd both appear to be "pretty nice".

I don't want to be a machinist. I recognize that it is a facet of the craft, and might appeal to some people, but it isn't my thing. I would rather stand at a lathe with a sharp tool, see what happens while making long translucent ribbons of wood fly, and clog my 220G paper- only to come back to a vessel that has moved and deformed in some unexpected and wonderful way.

Steven

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

#11

Re: I like wood, but I'm no machinist

Douglas

>I am or was a journeymen tool and die maker. Working with precision is what a tool and die maker loves doing. Once you get that in your blood it hard to think any other way.

When I started turning wood I worked the same way as I did when making tools and dies. I found out rather quickly a piece of wood is not the same as steel. The things I learned as a tool and die maker help me a lot with turning wood but I needed to learn more and have.

I do not now work with the same precision as a tool and die maker and it really is impossible to do. I still try but wood is wood and steel is steel. I used a lot of the same techniques as a tool and die maker but have adapted many more that works with wood a lot better.

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

#12

Mike Stafford

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

Mike Stafford

>Well, I don't know where I fit into this turning spectrum as I am still learning and have a lot to learn.

I almost never turn spontaneously. I always have a sketch or a plan of what I want to do. If I did not I would never turn anything different. I just don't have the ability yet to turn on the fly.

My goal when turning is to get the most out of each piece of wood, to display it in the best way I can. I want the turning to be crisp, well sanded, free of blemishes and pleasant both to hold and to look at. Sometimes I achieve those goals and sometimes I don't.

When other turners make comments I try to take them into consideration so that the next time I turn a similar form I improve the design, the proportions, the appearance of the piece. I appreciate considered opinions and advice.

I am not a particularly creative person. It is unlikely at this point in my life I will break the mold of what I am. I am too traditional in my thinking so I will never come up with something as creative as a Raffan citadel box or even the charred multi-faceted painted AAW magazine cover piece (which I happened to like).

I am not a machinist but I guess I am a perfectionist or at least try to be. I am much more interested in the process of the piece I am turning than I am in the finished piece. When I am done with a piece I don't give it a second thought and move on to the next one and try to incorporate any suggestions or improvements I think or that others think are needed.

I love turning and I love wood. As long as I am able I will try to do justice for every piece of wood that comes into my possession.

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

#13

Well said, Mike! :)

Al Neighbors

>

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

#14

When Molly Winton sees my work....

Rick Davenport

>.... she rolls her eyes, shakes her head and walks away.

We have work in the same gallery here in Edmonds.

No woodturner would confuse my pieces with hers.

She's got a style and reputation that puts her in a different league.

But I still get lots of positive comments and sell a fair amount of my work.

I like to take odd pieces and let them lead me to a result that I can foresee only about half the time.

I am usually pleasantly surprised, occasionally disappointed.

One thing for sure..... I know I have more fun than she does.

;-)

Unless she gets together with her sister the ceramic artist.

It would take a full house to beat that pair!!

(They are doing a dual demo at the gallery in July.

Y'all come and check it out)

R

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

#15

An excerpt from my Artist Statement

Raymond Overman in SC

>"I use a non-structured technique to realize my vision. It usually starts with me thinking about a piece for days or weeks before going out to my shop and putting something down in wood. In my work, the process isn�t as important as the end product so my array of tools and my liberal use of sandpaper may annoy some other woodturning artists, but it�s the way I work. I enjoy the process of creating in my mind and then translating that to my medium but it�s the goal of the finished work that drives me. In other words, the perfection of a single cut isn�t what I�m looking for, it�s the bowl or vase or sculpture that I saw in my dreams for days that is the goal."

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

#16

The black hole

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>I don't fall into the spectrum. I get sucked into the black hole of wanting to try everything. I agree with the above post that says intent rules how much detail goes into a piece. One thing I seldom do anymore, is just chuck up a piece of wood and have at it. I plan most of what I turn now. I use drawings for the more complicated things. Simple projects are just planed in my head.

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

#17

Re: An excerpt from my Artist Statement

Texian

>Although seldom regarded as such, sandpaper is in fact no less a tool than a hundred dollar bowl gouge. Some folks value the journey (super smooth finish achieved with skew, or whatever), and others value the destination (a beautiful piece of work, however achieved).

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

#18

Re: The black hole

John Jordan

>The only way to real success in "loose" work, is to first have the technical chops. "Loose" work done without skill is generally just clunky, particularly in wood. Poorly made is not the same.

I'm looking at one of those "rough: Citadel? boxes of Richard's on my mantel. Loose? Yep. Rough? You bet. It's also "perfect". :-)

Clay Foster is one of the most technically proficient turners around.

You can see this quality in clay (ceramic NOT Foster) pots made by long time potters. Little bowls or cups with that "loose" quality, but you can sense the thousands of bowls that those hands have pulled before.

It's a good topic, and looking closely at work from some of those mentioned can be very enlightening.

John

John

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

#19

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

Texian

>As previously mentioned or implied, some folks land in multiple places on the "spectrum". While waiting for glue to dry on parts for a segmented or staved piece, intended to be "gallery" if not "museum" quality, it is often useful to have something happening on the lathe as well. The latter may become an attractive and well formed piece, but perhaps of lesser technical and artistic merit than the other work in progress.

Meanwhile to repeat a previous post, forget "practice". Do the best you can on every piece, every time. Some will still become "firewood", but you will not have to say "That turned out so well that I wish I had tried a little harder and made it better".

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

#20

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

Duane C.Leach

>I have never liked the idea of being labled. They tend to keep one on a very narrow path. Rather than allowing him to explor new ideas or new designs that are not in keeping with that lable.

In the work I do.I try to do the very best that I can on each and every piece that I turn.No mater what type of piece i turn I give it my all. I belive the quality of my work is a reflection on me. Some would call what I do as being a perfectionist. Just another label. Some say perfection is unatainable.Is unatainable a good enough reason not to try for it?

Duane

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

#21

My thoughts exactly.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

#22

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

Ed Karch

>My stuff looks spontaneous but has days and weeks of design iterations and brain cramps before it ever hits the wood or glass or metal.

Clay Foster's turnings may look spontaneous, they aren't, but Clay also makes some of the most carefully crafted and beautiful museum quality cabinet work. Check out the cabinets in his shop. His are works of art, mine are slapped together from old crates and junk wood.

Clay actually works on both ends of the spectrum and I suspect many other big name turners do the same.

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum?

#23

Re: Where Do You Fall On the Turners Spectrum? *LINK*

charlie belden

>This thread got pretty interesting pretty quickly and I've gotten some insights into some things I'd misunderstood. Wish more lurkers would come out of the background and provide more perspectives.

I was hoping, with this thread, to reveal some of the WHY that is seldom gotten to in articles, books and videos - and maybe provide a newer than me newbie lurker some insights - and maybe encouragement to jump into the discussion that's not focused on skills and techniques or a particular well known turner - but more on Why first - and then worry about HOW.

The HOW will require tools and techniques - which anyone can acquire - with money and/or time at the lathe with the tool(s). But WHY takes a bit of thinking, some introspection.

And on the HOW side - perfection is a wonderful goal - unless it keeps you from trying - reaching beyond a perceived limit of ability - a barrier which can lock one in a small box of "familiar and safe", cutting off limitless possibilities. And of all the forms of woodworking I've gotten into, turning seems to have the largest universe of possibilities, with space for the full range of WHY - and all levels of experience and skill.

More please.

charlie bleden


Examples of Spontaneous Variations - With A Skew