Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

Posts

Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

#1

Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

Gordon Seto

>Over the years I have accumulated some bowl gouges. When I examined the flutes, I noticed the slight difference, but never thought the difference would be so dramatic. May be all the gouges are sharpened to an angle which is deceiving.

I made a wax mold of each flute; I then used a hand plan to get rid of the overfill. I scanned them on the flat bed scanner and enlarged them 200%. I was surprised that the scanned images have a 3-D effect.

We are all taking about "U" and "V" flutes. But from the pictures, there are variation in flute depth and it is hard to define "U" and "V". Some are hybrids.

If you look at the 1/2" and 5/8" (I am using American Standard here) Crown Pro-PM, the 1/2" is definitely one of the tightest "V" flute gouge, but the 5/8" is one of wider "U".

I don't think I am qualified to give expert opinion that which is better than which. One of the major complaint about the Glaser tool is the "V" flute tends to clog. On the other extreme is a spindle gouge which is the most open flute gouge. We don't want to use it for side grain bowl turning, so there must be a happy medium in the middle.

Alan Lacer did an article "Putting the Steel to the Test" in the current Summer 2008 issue of American Woodturner. I want to do my part and provide some raw pictures of flute cross sections. There are more than difference in steel. I believe with the difference in flute, we can't get the same grind even with identical grinding jig settings.

All my gouges are more than 2 years old, they may not reflect the current gouges.

Gordon


img

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

#2

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

Gordon Seto

>I borrow the 5/8" V gouge from Doug Thompson to do this project. What I had was an early production of the Thompson gouge, I knew he has made some changes in flute design. He has made the flute more open and decreased the depth of the flute. Since mine is no longer available, it would be better to do on the current production.

My Glaser 5/8" was Jerry Glaser production, it may be different than the current Glaser. But it is clear that Thompson "V" is no where near the original Glaser gouge flute shape.

After I have done that, I think I should have included the Thompson "U" gouge, I borrowed one from Doug at today's meeting. I am going to post the casting when I am done.

Gordon


img

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

#3

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

Gordon Seto

>Two more bowl gouges for comparison.

There is a lot to be learned.

Gordon


img

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

#4

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

Cyril Griesbach

>Very interesting, Gordon, and thanks for doing this. Your results are something I've suspected for some time. I'm anxious to see what others have to say about your discoveries.

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

#5

outstanding project...

GaryG in MD

>Gordon,

This is a great technique! Well done. I sincerely applaud what you're doing here, and I hope it will generate a lot of discussion. (I look forward to seeing Doug's "U" in your collection too, in comparison to the other U-like items.)

The two things that come immediately to mind are:

1) it's clear that the cutting characteristics of these different shapes are going to be (very) different. That's not to say 'good' and 'bad' -- but, rather, used for different purposes. I don't want to speak for Doug, and I hope he gets into this thread, but in my discussions with him, I believe it's fair to say that he feels the V has advantages on the outside of a bowl and that the U can have advantages on the inside of a bowl. I think I also recall that Bill G. loves his Thompson V for many applications.

2) it's also clear that some of the gouge profiles you've shown are very thin and unsupported -- I wouldn't want to use those very far off the tool rest. Others have a lot of metal under the flute -- those will be much more stable at longer distances.

It's too bad all the SINs are locked up for Richmond. I think this would make a good one. Perhaps in Albuquerque... ...Gary

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

#6

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Thanks Gordon this is interesting. It's late so just a few thoughts.

1. The bottom of the flute has to be below the center line for a bowl gouge to work well, I wonder why they are so deep... what was there thought behind the design

2. We can learn to turn with any gouge listed above so what makes one better than the other.

3. Why does Gordon own so many tools.

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

#7

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

bowlman

>Maybe its because he can?

Seriously, I believe that most turners purchase additional tools for the following reasons:

1. They can

2. They feel a need to collect tools, just like our customers (hopefully) feel compelled to collect turnings

3. They are bright and shiney things and we all know how we react to bright and shiney things

4. Endorsements by the pros or experts:

Most importantly, we are on a quest to find that one tool that will "do it all" ... a futile quest to be sure (IMHO). We are impressed by the "pros" and when they say "I use the V shape" or "I prefer the 5/8" over all other sizes" or "I only use 2060 steel cryo treated", etc etc etc ... we, like sheep and lemmings head to the nearest vendor to plunk down good money for the latest and greatest tool ever made.

5. Marketing: A mixture of #4 and the slick and glossy catalogues we get in the mail, plus the articles in various turning publicatios, reinforced by communication with other turners (many of whom are inflicted with MTAS syndrome (more tools are better aka toolitis.

Now, I must admit, I used to be a prolific tool buyer. I am sure I helped pay for many nice things for the major vendors over the years. But, as I have grown older, and having adopted a more Zen approach to Life, I have resisted the 2040-2060 trap (I still use M2 a lot). I have also settled on Doug Thompson's tools for my bowl work. And I do encourage other turners to try Doug's products. They are by far the best tools for 99.99% of our work ... if sharpened and used correctly.

For spindle work, I took the plunge and got Alan Lacer's skews. A bit of an extravagance, yes, but well worth it .. again, just MHO. Sorry Doug, I did this well before I was introduced to your line of tools. One of these days I will have to take your skews and scrapers for a test turn or twelve. Maybe then I'll be able to say i use nothing but Thompson turning tools.

BTW, the same principles apply to chucks. Counting my Glaser original screw chuck, 2 Axminster pin chucks, the Oneway vacuum chucks, and the 3 4-jaw scroll chucks, ... that makes 9, plus the various ones I made for turning eggs, jam fit chucks, etc. So, no I am not immune, but I do resist ... with the everpresent assistance of SWMBO!

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

#8

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

Cyril Griesbach

>Well said, Dick. Are you sure you didn't take a tour of my shop before you wrote this? You bring a smile to this old face as I'm in and out grilling brats for our church picnic this rainy early Sunday morning.

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

#9

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

Barry Elder

>My old eyes wonder why the purple background which makes it more difficult to discern the small differences in the shapes? Would not a lighter color make them easier to see? 2 cents!

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

#10

what are the lower numbers? shaft diameter?

Ed Kelle

>

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

#11

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

john lucas

>Great Job Gordon. It makes it much easier to see why the different flute shapes and grinds make different wing grinding angles. I have flutes with wings that are really sharp angles,maybe 25 degrees, and flutes that have wing sharpening angles of about 45 degrees. The nose on these are all ground to around 62 degrees and all sharpened with the same setting on my Oneway Wolverine.

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

#12

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

Steven Kubien

>This is really interesting Gordon and thanks for doing it. Basically, I own 3 types of bowl gouges... A Crown Ellsworth which came with my lathe, a P&N which I use as a roughing gouge and two Thompson U-shaped (3/8" and 1/2"). I tend to use the same set up with my grinding jig and these all become very different tools on the wings and at the nose. The Ellsworth works best for me as a shear scraping tool and for roughing out bowl shapes. For refining shapes and final cuts, I typically reach for my Thompsons. With better tool control I am sure I would use just one like many others do. Hmmm, perhaps a Thompson V-shaped is just what I need? Yeah, I can justify that!

Steve Kubien

P.S. The order will be in your hands shortly Doug!

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

#13

Re: Another factor which influences.....

Jamie Donaldson

>... our preferences as to U or V flutes is which we first learned to use. I started with the U of Sorby and prefer it today for all my bowl gouges. I believe it evacuates shavings better, takes the wing shapes that I prefer, and feel most comfortable and confident in using. When we were tool poor and wanting to get the turning done we learned to work with what we had already paid for and were content. Now there are so many options we feel deprived if we don't have a variety of options, whether we really need them or not.

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

#14

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>The flute shape determines what the basic grind will be, a large radius at the bottom of the flute will produce a rounded nose while a small radius will produce a more pointed grind. I still like Jerry Glaser's flute concept, the small nose radius is easy to control because it is smaller. The straight wings shear the wood when roughing almost like a block plane.

From the pictures I thought the Ellsworth was more parabolic (oval) then it is.

The Crown was a surprise too, why would the flute shape change with a larger size gouge. Flute shapes need to be proportional to each other when the diameter changes.

I was joking with that question, yes Gordon can and does own a lot of tools. BTW - he is a outstanding woodturner that doesn't post many pictures of his work. I scares me to borrow a tool to look at, he doesn't keep the tools just nice they are perfect, with great care they are wraped and cutting edges covered. We should all be this good with our tools.

Breaks over, back to the grinder.

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

#15

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

Gordon Seto

>I will start a new thread on why I own so many tools tonight.

I want to turn my wasteful purchasing into something positive.

I hope we can have more inputs on what differentiates between one tool from the other is more than the steel.

Gordon

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

#16

Re: what are the lower numbers? shaft diameter?

Gordon Seto

>Ed,

You are correct. They are shaft diameters.

Gordon

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

#17

Re: My 2 P&N gouges are distinctly.....

Jamie Donaldson

>... V flutes rather than the U flutes in your sample?

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

#18

Re: My 2 P&N gouges are distinctly.....

Steven Kubien

>Jamie, aren't there P&N "bowl" gouges and "supa" gouges? Could be that you've got one type and Gordon's got another? Just an idea.

Steve Kubien

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

#19

Re: I bought them about 3 yrs. ago, so.....

Jamie Donaldson

>..... I don't recall anything other than bowl gouges were what I ordered by mail in order to try them out. I sold the larger gouge, and kept the 3/8" for my students to grind away.

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

#20

Re: I bought them about 3 yrs. ago, so.....

John Jordan

>As Doug said, the proportion of the flute is important. The flute shape does not matter for a "side grind" in profile. The V-flute and the U-flute work pretty much the same, but as Doug pointed out, the radius on the end of the gouge is equal to the radius in the bottom of the flute. The V-shape yields a smaller, tighter tip which I prefer as it works into a corner or detail a little better. But it's really not that big a deal.

The jig setup does not vary because of the flute shape when grinding a side grind, for example. What does change is the movement one must make to follow the shape of the flute. If one follows the shape of the flute, the profile of the side grind will be the same regardless of the flute shape. This means a flat sided flute as in a V-shape simply needs to be placed flat against the wheel, and a pronounced U-shaped needs to be swung in an arc along the side.

I cover some of this very subject in the AAW Sharpening video.

Some gouge trivia: Jerry Glaser's earlier bowl gouges were more U-shaped. He reasoned that since many turners (pre-sharpening jigs) had trouble sharpening a gouge into a side grind, if he made the flute v-shaped, the the turner need only put each side of the gouge flat against the wheel, and then round the tip a bit. :-) I don't think it really helped that much, but it did make that gouge have that nice little tip that I like so much.

John

Some

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

#21

Re: I bought them about 3 yrs. ago, so.....

John Jordan

>And I should have added that anyone looking for rhyme or reasonto the flute shape of most gouges, and why they are sometimes different in different size gouges from the same company, good luck with that. I've been doing this a long time and have seen Thousands of gouges (student's). They are all over the place from most of the companies, many of which have no woodturners at all on their staff. If the milling cutter's not set deep enough, or too deep, they are not likely to scrap that whole batch, and the person running the machine may or may not care. One WELL known company that sells expensive powdered metal gouges, used to send me batches of gouges that the flute was milled/ground in at an angle-impossible to sharpen/shape properly.

Doug doesn't have this problem BTW. And his gouges are nice! :-)

John

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

#22

OK, I gotta ask...

James McClure

>What did you do with the messed up gouges?

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shape

#23

Re: OK, I gotta ask...

John Jordan

>Sold you one? :-)

John