>Here is a Ambrosia Maple Finial Box, 2" wide and 2 1/2" tall. It has a very nice suction "pop" when it's opened. Sealed with lacquer and polished. This box was a lot of fun to make. It is quite different than other boxes since it has an "in fitting" lid. You can't make a tapered flange and use a burnish mark to "sneak" up on the fit with these boxes. With these you have to get out the calipers.
>Nice round box, Greg, and perfect fit on the lid. Grain match looks perfect. For me, the "finial" doesn't quite work. I think it's just too big and the shape doesn't seem to compliment the rest of the box.
>Looking at the photo, the first thing that popped into my head was - OK - a Before and After set of pictures. But that couldn't be - the shape or dimesntions would have to change because some wood would have to be removed to separate the lid from the box, Then I went back and read the accompanying text.
REALLY nice fit.
I took the image over to PhotoShop to try and find the Lid To Box fit line and at 5x magnification I THINK I can see it. But it's not the invisible line that impresses me - it's the continuity of the spalting and grain acrossed the joint. Because the spalting is at an angle to the joint line, and because some wood at the joint has to be lost when parting the lid from the box, the grain acrossed the joint should be offset. And at this scale it should be noticable - and not just at 5x magnification.
The slightly diagonal spalting catches the eye first, but the vertical area with the medullary rays pull the eye to it - then back to the spalting. Great visual interest.
How tricky was it to do the top of the finial - with punky wood out at the edge? Turning from sound wood to punky wood often can tear up the soft wood. Were you able to turn that or was the shaping done with the "120" gouge?
Anyway to sand the pinch in the neck of the finial a little smoother? I know it's a tight space but it's dullness, compared with the finish on the rest of the piece did catch my eye.
Doing really nice small pieces well is not a trivial thing. You can hide imperfections in a large piece - there's so much surface area to look at so the viewer's mid range vision is being used. But with smaller pieces, the viewer has to get really close when viewing the piece - and typically picks it up to for a much closer look - using their "macro" vision - the range where EVERY detail can be seen. Because of the size of the piece, almost half of it will be seen simultaneously in "detail mode". And it's not only the detailed vision of the eye that kicks in - but also the details part of the brain that examines things closely, rather than merely taking in the big picture.
>I think it works WAY better than the original. I didn't have a problem with the shape of the original lid, but I like this one too. It's very "circle on circle"...
>Nah. I like it better the first way. Put it back on the lathe and use the negative gouge. Just kiddig. Acutally, I like the first one, but the second, I will admit is better. Great job.
>I'm with you - the new top of the finial goes well with the boxes shape, mirroring it. It also eliminated the light colored punky wood on the earlier version of the finial.
Though it was taking a risk to re-turn the top of the finial - the possibility of blowing a pretty nice piece was there - the results clearly make taking the risk worth it.
Version One was a pretty nice little finialed box. Version Two is a pretty nice, understated, elegant little finialed box.
"It also eliminated the light colored punky wood on the earlier version of the finial."
Charlie, there "was no" and "is no" punky wood on this box. It's ambrosia Maple and it's very solid. There's various colors of "solid wood" that comes from the Ambrosia effects and there's a little light reflection. Ambrosia maple doesn't mean punky or spalted-there is none of either. There "was no" and "is no" punky wood on this box.
>"Anyway to sand the pinch in the neck of the finial a little smoother? I know it's a tight space but it's dullness, compared with the finish on the rest of the piece did catch my eye."
Everything is sanded the same and finished the same at the same time on the outside. There is no dull area. There's some areas that the light hit well and others that didn't, and on the first version there's an area that the finial shadowed from the light, the neck.