Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Which Grinding Wheels?

Posts

Which Grinding Wheels?

#1

Which Grinding Wheels?

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

>I have an 8" 1725 grinder that came with a white 60 grit and 120 grit wheels the 120 is to fine. I replaced it with 3X 100 grit from Hartville tools. It is to soft and grooves very easy. What Wheels are most used by experienced turners on this board?

Thanks in advance,

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

Re: Which Grinding Wheels?

#3

Norton SG

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I recently switched to the Norton SG wheels. I really like the 80 grit wheel and wish I'd gotten two of them instead of a 46 and 80. It cuts fast and doesn't groove. These wheels are expensive, and IMHO worth every penny (and then some). I wish I had switched earlier.

(I bought them from Craft Supplies.)

Re: Which Grinding Wheels?

#4

Not all wheels are created equal

Greg Haugen

>Norton 3X/SG wheels: There are two versions on the market, "I" and "K" grades. "I" is too soft for turning tools and it's also the older version that first came out so a lot of suppliers still have them. That's what you got from Hartville. Then there is a "K" grade which is made for HSS turning tools. Some places have these now and it's usually listed this is the "harder" 3X wheel. Wood Central sponsor and supporter Sharpeningsupplies.com has both and they are clearly listed. 3X wheels have the same "SG" (seeded gel) material (ceramic) as the $100 premium "SG" wheels. The 3X wheels have a 30% mixture of the ceramic and the Premium wheels have a 50% mix. I don't think the difference is noticeable at all. Other turners that have used both of the wheels also agree. For the money, a set of two 3X wheels for the price of one of the premium version is the way I'd go. If you have your heart set on spending $200, buy the two 3X wheels for $100 then call Doug Thompson and buy a new Thompson Gouge. :-))

There are many wheels available in many grits. For sharpening, I've heard everything from 60 to 120 grit being used and roughing 26 to 80 grit. Yes, 26 grit. That must be like taking the gouge and throwing it across a dirt road.

120, some say it's a bit too fine, others like it. I've found it depends on grinding technique. 120 wheels need a light tough/pressure. Too much pressure and they'll burn the steel, for HSS tools that doesn't matter. You may get a for "snickers" from your turning buddies that your gouges are black, and they're not Thompson gouges. The other wheels will accept a little more pressure since they can remove steel faster.

I use 120 and 60 grit white wheels. When it comes time to change, I may look at Norton 3X or stay with the "tried and true" white wheels.

Hope this helps.

Greg Haugen

Re: Which Grinding Wheels?

#5

Re: Not all wheels are created equal

Gordon Seto

>I met Doug Thompson last Sunday. I commented on the 24 grit 10" wheel that JoHannes Michelsen used in his sharpening video on You Tube. Doug said from what he has tried, there is nothing beats the efficiency of 8" 46 grit Norton "K" wheel dressed with a star dresser. The surface from diamond dresser is too fine for his purpose, shaping lots of tools. I believe he may be using up more grinding wheels than we do on toilet tissue rolls.

Normally when we shape our turning tool, it has a rough shape already. Doug shapes his tools from square end; there is more steel to remove. We may not need ours to be as aggressive.

Doug said he will be very busy stockpiling the inventory to take to the AAW Richmond Symposium; I don't think he would have time to visit any forum now.

Re: Which Grinding Wheels?

#6

Re: Which Grinding Wheels?

Charles B. Watson

>I'm a firm believer in the Norton 3X and SG wheels. The K bond in a 3X would be my overall choice based upon quality and price.

Re: Which Grinding Wheels?

#7

Re: Which Grinding Wheels?

James McClure

>I also like the Norton 3X wheels. I think I got some of the softer ones because they do tend to groove and round over on the edges. I just have to dress them a little more frequently.

Re: Which Grinding Wheels?

#8

Re: Not all wheels are created equal

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Gordon, the all important call came in from the company who does the heat treatment... the tools are ready! I'll have 12 days to clean, sharpen and pack the inventory for the symposium.

Gordon is right the Norton 3X 46 grit dressed with a star wheel is more agressive than a 24 grit wheel and it runs cool. At $45 the 3X wheel is a very good value... over the next 12 days I'll go through 4 wheels and "many" hours of grinding. You think this is easy... after 2 hours of grinding your hand starts to tingle. My record is 5-1/2 hours straight with no breaks.

Re: Which Grinding Wheels?

#9

Re: Dang Doug- wearing out 4 wheels.......

Jamie Donaldson

>....in 12 days boggles my mind!! How many Baldor grinders would you wear out in a year???

Re: Which Grinding Wheels?

#10

Re: Which Grinding Wheels?

robo hippy

>I use CBN (cubic boric nitride) wheels. They are made for grinding steel. They are custom made. You get 3/16 of CBN bonded to an aluminum wheel, and can get any grit you want. I know 3M is making them, and if you have any metal grinding places near by, they can get or maybe make them for you. The down side is that an 8 by 1 inch wheel is about $300. My 80 grit wheel is almost 4 years old, and has worn about 1/16 off the wheel. I had a finer wheel (320), but it wore out too fast. I have a 150 on now. You don't have to spin balance them, or true them up. You do have to clean them off by using an aluminum oxide stick. When they do need to be dressed, I take them back to the shop. I am lucky that they are made here in town.

robo hippy

Re: Which Grinding Wheels?

#11

Re: Not all wheels are created equal

Gordon Seto

>I hope I can save someone's frustration by buying the wrong wheels and returning them. I emailed Jason of Hartville Tool last night and got a straight reply.

The Norton 3X wheels that Hartville carrying currently are "I" hardness wheels. Norton only makes "K" 3X in 46 and 80 grits. Hartville may start to carry the "K" wheels this summer. They may be several dollars more than the "I" wheels.

Gordon

Re: Which Grinding Wheels?

#12

Re: Norton SG

robert davis

>ditto sg

Re: Which Grinding Wheels?

#13

Yep and hope I have enough

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>A detail gouge for example is tough on the wheel, then do 50 detail gouges from scratch. That's more grinding then most do in months or for some a year. It's the 'from scratch' that kills the wheel.

Re: Which Grinding Wheels?

#14

Re: Yep and hope I have enough

Jerry from Lapel In.

>If I was you I would look into getting a wire machine or finding someone to do them for me. It would cut that hardened steel like a hot knife in butter. Just a thought.

Re: Which Grinding Wheels?

#15

Re: Yep and hope I have enough

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Jerry, that would work very well. I was thinking the corners could be knocked off before they are hardened... It's a simple problem with a tough solution.

Re: Which Grinding Wheels?

#16

Re: Yep and hope I have enough

Jerry from Lapel In.

>You can program the wire machine to put your complete profile or any shape you want and cutting time would be same.