Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Endgrain tearout on the inside of bowls

Posts

Endgrain tearout on the inside of bowls

#1

Endgrain tearout on the inside of bowls

wilbur

>I'm actually getting better at minimizing the amount of endgrain tearout I get on the inside of a bowl. Taking the time to resharpen my gouge and trying to take very light cuts is helping a lot. But I still wind up using 80 grit sandpaper more than I would like.

What I'd like to know is how far I should push this. Is it possible to finish off the inside of a bowl with a gouge without any endgrain tearout?

If it matters, I've been practicing on kiln dried 8/4 cherry cutoffs.

Re: Endgrain tearout on the inside of bowls

#2

Steven Antonucci

Possibly, yes. Hard? Ubetcha

steve antonucci

>But you already know that...

Sharp is essential, but so is pacing. One of the things I have to consciously watch is how fast I cut. I rough with a bowl gouge and tend to take 1/2" cuts as fast as I can move through the wood. When you make the final cuts, you need to start slowing the tool down so that you A) don't get tearout B) don't create tearout that you can't remove with one last cut...

A good way to practice is to practice. As you start roughing out and getting an interior profile, take a finish cut half way through. Stop the lathe and check the finish. Rouh some more. Repeat.

Do this until you don't need to do it anymore. Then, do it some more so you don't lose this skill...

Steven

Re: Endgrain tearout on the inside of bowls

#3

Re: Endgrain tearout on the inside of bowls

Greg Haugen

>Wilbur,

It is possible. What are you using, as far as gouge/gouge grind and scraper or not scraper? If you could post a picture of your bowl shape would help also. For most of my bowls I use two different grinds on two different gouges. For closed form/calabash bowls I use 3-4. The grinds range from 40 degrees swept back to a extremely stubby 60 degree grind. The heals of the the grind are also relieved to shorten the bevel. All bevels are 1/8" or less. A long bevel's heal can rub on the wood and do more damage than expected. Sometimes there may be a small spot of tearout left, not often. These times I can sand it out or I apply some oil to the spot and recut it with a sharpened gouge. The oil lubricates the cut so it's better.

I don't not care for scrapers and bowls. Some do like them though too.

Any of Mike Mahoney's and/or Stuart Batty's DVD's on Bowl turning are incredible and well worth it!!

Hope that helps.

Re: Endgrain tearout on the inside of bowls

#4

Re: Endgrain tearout on the inside of bowls

Cyril Griesbach

>Wilbur, it certainly is possible to finish the inside of your bowls without tear out. Just how possible is subject to the species of wood and the shape of your bowl just to name two considerations.

While I'm often able to start sanding with 180 or even 220 sometimes, I most often follow the sanding techniques of Vince Welch and start with 80 and go through the grits to 400. With this process I normally can be assured that I haven't left any unseen tool marks unsanded, the sanding process is consistant and the time it takes remains minimal.

As for dealing with the tearout, there are about as many ways as there are turners. Paste wax, mineral oil, finishing oil if you use one in the end, can be applied to the tearout to stifen up the unsupported fibers prior to the finishing cuts with a sharp tool.

I hope this provides some help and hopefuly others will chime in as well.

Re: Endgrain tearout on the inside of bowls

#5

Re: Endgrain tearout on the inside of bowls

john lucas

>Wilbur I would have to see you turn to tell you what you might be doing wrong. Of course it could be the wood, some woods in certain states of deterioration are simply very hard to not get tearout.

I find that the sharpness of the tool, how big a bite you take and not forcing the tool into the cut are the 3 biggest things, other than grain direction.

Sometimes the grain can be squirly and you end up cutting against the grain on 2 sections of the bowl. On those I will try cutting in the opposite direction. Usually on this problems one direction will produce less tearout than the other. I use a pull cut when cutting from foot to lip on this type.

Using a 40 degree stewart batty grind and as little forward pressure as I can will give me a finish that I can start with 220 most of the time.

Re: Endgrain tearout on the inside of bowls

#6

Clarifications, and another question (lathe speed)

wilbur

>Thanks for all the suggestions!

To answer some of the questions and comments:

I have Doug Thompson's V-shape 1/2" bowl gouge. The grind that I use is somewhat between a basic bowl gouge and the Ellsworth profile, with a 45� angle. That is, it has some sweep back, but not as much as I've seen others use.

I use a scraper occasionally, but I would guess that I am using 90% gouge, 10% scraper, and I am finishing up with the gouge.

For sanding, I've been using Norton 3X, working from 80 up to 400 grit, no skipping. It seems like I spend 90% of the time on the 80 grit, and then I move very quickly through the rest of the grits. I stop at 150 to check my progress.

For my bowls, I do find that the areas that I have tearout are on two spots, diametrically opposed to each other on the inside of the bowl, and it seems like those are the areas where I'm cutting unsupported grain due to the orientation of the grain and the angle of my tool.

My question: to further minimize the endgrain tearout, besides light cuts and sharp tools, is it better to go at a low lathe speed or to speed it up as fast as possible, all other things being equal?

Re: Endgrain tearout on the inside of bowls

#7

Re: Clarifications, and another question (lathe sp

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Speed: I think that most beginning turners turn at speeds that are too low for best results. For a 7 or 8 inch bowl I suggest a speed of around 1500 RPM. You'll get smoother cuts and better control.

Rather than the 80 grit tool I suggest that you learn to shear scrape before sanding.

Wally

Re: Endgrain tearout on the inside of bowls

#8

Shear Scraping....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I probably should explain shear scraping. Properly done, shear scraping should get rid of all of the tearout problem.

The are dedicated tools available for shear scraping but I do most of mine with a bowl gouge. This is done with the gouge over on it's side so that the flute is facing the wood. Scraping is done with the bottom cutting edge while the top cutting edge is quite close to the wood. The tool handle can be level for a more aggressive cut or it can be down a bit for a smoother cut. On the inside or outside of a bowl, cutting should be a little above center. Take very light cuts. It helps to apply some finishing oil or some wax to the wood.

Caution...allowing the top cutting edge to get too far from the wood will result in an unsupported cutting edge instead of a scraping edge, and this often means a major catch.

You'll find shear scraping will be a big help on both the inside and outside of a bowl in preparing the wood for sanding. You can shear scrape with any gouge, bowl or spindle.

Wally

Re: Endgrain tearout on the inside of bowls

#9

Re: Endgrain tearout on the inside of bowls

John K Jordan

>If I have a particularly problematic piece of wood I sometimes paint it with Mylands sanding sealer then recut after it dries, perhaps with a shear scraper. This soaks in a tends to hold the fibers together.

I find a small hand-held cabinet scraper also works wonders with soft wood such as eastern red cedar when I get some that is prone to tearout.

JKJ

Re: Endgrain tearout on the inside of bowls

#10

Re: Clarifications, and another question (lathe sp

john lucas

>I will agree with Wally. A faster speed means you are less likely to force the tool through the cut. I know it doesn't feel like you are pushing the tool too fast but lighten up the pressure you put on the tool and let it cut on it's own rate. The faster speed makes this easier to do.

Try applying some paste wax and then make a final pass or two. A lot of times you've actually created the tear out earlier. Then you sharpen the tool and make a pass but you haven't really removed enough wood to eliminate all the tearout. Look at it closely and take a second pass or so. I'm not sure what the paste wax actually does, maybe lubricate the tool or soften the wood but it usually helps.

Then follow this with a shear scrape like Wally describes. Worse case scenario use a hand held cabinet scraper with the lathe turned off. You can work on just area that has tearout. You'll have to feather the edges out to keep from creating a big crater but this will not follow the hard and soft wood like sandpaper which leaves it lumpy.

Re: Endgrain tearout on the inside of bowls

#11

Re: Here is a scraper that I made....

Jamie Donaldson

>...for shear scraping the interior of bowls. It is based on a Sorby Multi-tip tool that they have now priced way too high, and mine is made from a piece of 3/4" cold rolled steel and a shaper blade I found on a sale table- 3 for $5! The round shaft allows the tool to be rolled up on the side and make a nice draw/shear cut inside a bowl with ease. Works like a champ when the bowl gouge can't do the job in a confined area.


img

Re: Endgrain tearout on the inside of bowls

#12

Re: Endgrain tearout on the inside of bowls

robo hippy

>I have found that dry wood tends to get end grain tear out more than wet woods. This end grain tear out is what you have. On half of the bowl you are cutting down hill, and don't get tear out. On the other half, you are cutting up hill against the grain and here is where you get the tear out. Softer woods tend to rip deeper than harder woods. As others have said, sharp tools, and very fine cuts for your last touch ups. I am a big fan of shear scraping. A negative rake scraper works fine, but most of the time I just use a big heavy bowl scraper. Grind a fresh burr first. I rotate it about 45 degrees, and make a pull cut from the bottom up towards the rim. Again, taking only the lightest of cuts. These are not for stock removal, they are for clean up. This usually takes several passes. Take care near the rim, even to the point of cleaning up the rim before you turn out the rest of the inside of the bowl. It gets wobbly up there, and expecially with wet wood, can move after wood is removed. If this is not working, then you need to lubricate the wood. You can use water, oil, wax, sanding sealer, etc. Apply some, let it sit for a bit, then cut it off, taking only light cuts. Cabinet card scrapers will work, but I like the bowl scrapers better.

robo hippy