>These are just my impressions and I don't do the chemical ebonizing very often. First, you are limited in the woods you can use. The wood needs enough tannic acid to work. I found it to be somewhat inconsistent in that some woods only turned brown and some didn't turn black evenly. I prefer to use dyes such as shoe dye and analine dye.
1. How do you set up the reaction.
Just disolve steen wool in vineger. It takes several days to a week or more.
2. How long does it take
It reacts with the wood almost immediately so you do see what it will do. Sometimes multiple coats work better to darken it.
3. How thick of wood can I stain.
I assume you mean how deep does it penetrate. It doesn't. At least not more than a few thousandths. If your talking about how thick a piece of wood, well it's just applying stain, any size.
4. Will it sand off (how deep is the stain)
See the above statement. You can only sand it very lightly with 400 grit or finer. Any agressive sanding and you will sand through it.
5. Will it stand the test of time.
This I don't know. It's pretty darn permanent but I don't know how light fast it is. I think it's as good as any stain but I don't have any longevity tests.
6. Any adverse reactions to finishes or bleeding to surrounding woods.
I haven't had any problems with finishing but it will blead into surrounding areas.
These are just my impressions with limited use. Hope it helps.
>John- My sweetie the chemist says that a pad of steel wool in 1/2 cup of white vinegar will dissolve/react as much as it is going to in a couple hours. Mine sat around for a week before I got around to trying it, so have no personally observed data about faster reaction time.
Suggest to filter it through a coffee filter before use.
>I suspect that my steel wool had oil on it which might have made it take longer. I only did it once and tried it on a bunch of different wood species. It seemed to take forever to disolve enough to work but when it finally did it would change the wood as soon as the brush hit it.
I remember cherry, Oak and Ash all worked well. I think Walnut was in that mix but I really don't remember. It turned some woods a brown color but it's been about 3 or 4 years now and I don't remember which woods.
After playing with it a little I decided I liked being able to change the appearance of the black by using analine dye and adding red or blue to it. When I want just a plain black I use Shoe dye.
I made a batch last week. An oil-free steel wool pad in 3 cups of white vinegar. It took about 3 days for the vinegar to completely react with the steel wool, and there was excess steel wool. Filtering the solution through several layers of paper towel will remove the back sludge and leave a very pale green solution of iron(II) acetate. Air will cause the iron acetate to further oxidize to an insoluble reddish brown iron(III) acetate and iron oxide.
The darkening reaction takes a minute or two with iron(II) acetate because the iron has to oxidize to iron(III) to react with the tannin in the wood.
The solution doesn't penetrate any further than the water does - very shallow on side grain, fairly deeply into end grain.
The color depends on the types of tannin present in the wood and the natural color of the wood. Oak turns a blue-black. Walnut, butternut, ash, and cherry give a black to very dark green-black. I haven't tested any other woods.
The color is rather permanent -- ever try to remove iron stains caused by a rusty nail in oak?
The solution will follow the grain so it will "bleed" beyond where you apply it. Once the darkening reaction has taken place, you will not see further bleeding. The stain will not be lifted by water or common solvents and will not bleed into a finish.
>Interesting that oak worked. Will try that. Maybe also try adding a bit of black Rit fabric dye to the mix. Since the white vinegar is mostly water, the Rit should dissolve ok.