Concept Confrimation or Complete The Piece *LINK*
charlie belden
>I seldom KNOW, when I turn the lathe on, where "we" (the chunk of wood, the centers or chuck, the turning tool(s) and I) are going. Sometimes there's a general direction to head for AND sometimes there's a Wild Hare Idea and a vague notion of how "we" can make it.
It's the Wild Hare Idea piece that prompted the subject line for this post.
Wild Hare Ideas pop in my head from time to time
- How Can I Get ACTUAL Movement In This Next Piece? (piano wire connecting elements, a ball and socket joint to allow for articulation, apparent instability of the shape)
- What If I Don't Want Single Axis Symetry? (three sided boxes, twisted magic wands, an impossible stack of balls)
- What If I Turned This Then Sliced It Up, Glued The Parts Back Together At Odd Angles (slice and twist)
And when I go THAT route I find that once I've got the idea executed - I lose interest - Been There, Got The T-Shirt - and seldom actually finish the piece - I mean really FINISH the piece. By that I mean spending two or three times the amount of time it took to verify the concept in order refine the piece, to sand out all the tool marks and scratches, fine tune details and do a really nice finish.
If you've seen Greame Priddle's work - the ones with all the carving and shaping and sanding and grinding and . . . you'll understand what I'm talking about. He's got hours and hours and hours and hours and hours of time invested in each one of those pieces - and he has found the specific tools and techniques to do what he does. And finding the tools and techniques took him years to arrive at.
I don't have the patience, or probably the attention span, to spend two, three or four days on one piece. Hell, sometimes making a piece is spread over a week or two, an hour here, half hour there, maybe a two hour endurance run. Nothing I've ever turned has taken more that a couple of hours to do, three hours max.
Now don't get me wrong - I admire folks who can go all the way to a flawless finished piece. I'm in awe of Malcom Tibbetts work - and his ability to take what must've started out as a Really Wild Hare Idea and refine it to the amazing degree that he has.
I guess I'm a just a Close Enough turner who, on occassion, will take a piece farther than "That Idea Worked. NEXT!"
So how about you? Can YOU stop anywhere along the path to It's Perfect? If not, how do you stay motivated - and more importantly - what tells you to STOP before you go all the way to Perfect?
charlie belden
Example of Malcom Tibbets Wild Hare Idea



