Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Concept Confrimation or Complete The Piece *LINK*

Posts

Concept Confrimation or Complete The Piece *LINK*

#1

Concept Confrimation or Complete The Piece *LINK*

charlie belden

>I seldom KNOW, when I turn the lathe on, where "we" (the chunk of wood, the centers or chuck, the turning tool(s) and I) are going. Sometimes there's a general direction to head for AND sometimes there's a Wild Hare Idea and a vague notion of how "we" can make it.

It's the Wild Hare Idea piece that prompted the subject line for this post.

Wild Hare Ideas pop in my head from time to time

- How Can I Get ACTUAL Movement In This Next Piece? (piano wire connecting elements, a ball and socket joint to allow for articulation, apparent instability of the shape)

- What If I Don't Want Single Axis Symetry? (three sided boxes, twisted magic wands, an impossible stack of balls)

- What If I Turned This Then Sliced It Up, Glued The Parts Back Together At Odd Angles (slice and twist)

And when I go THAT route I find that once I've got the idea executed - I lose interest - Been There, Got The T-Shirt - and seldom actually finish the piece - I mean really FINISH the piece. By that I mean spending two or three times the amount of time it took to verify the concept in order refine the piece, to sand out all the tool marks and scratches, fine tune details and do a really nice finish.

If you've seen Greame Priddle's work - the ones with all the carving and shaping and sanding and grinding and . . . you'll understand what I'm talking about. He's got hours and hours and hours and hours and hours of time invested in each one of those pieces - and he has found the specific tools and techniques to do what he does. And finding the tools and techniques took him years to arrive at.

I don't have the patience, or probably the attention span, to spend two, three or four days on one piece. Hell, sometimes making a piece is spread over a week or two, an hour here, half hour there, maybe a two hour endurance run. Nothing I've ever turned has taken more that a couple of hours to do, three hours max.

Now don't get me wrong - I admire folks who can go all the way to a flawless finished piece. I'm in awe of Malcom Tibbetts work - and his ability to take what must've started out as a Really Wild Hare Idea and refine it to the amazing degree that he has.

I guess I'm a just a Close Enough turner who, on occassion, will take a piece farther than "That Idea Worked. NEXT!"

So how about you? Can YOU stop anywhere along the path to It's Perfect? If not, how do you stay motivated - and more importantly - what tells you to STOP before you go all the way to Perfect?

charlie belden


Example of Malcom Tibbets Wild Hare Idea

Re: Concept Confrimation or Complete The Piece *LINK*

#2

Re: Concept Confrimation or Complete The Piece

john lucas

>Great post. I'm always frustrated from 2 things. One is how much time I can spend on a piece developing the piece or technique vs will I ever be able to sell it. Fortunately I have a full time job so the getting a specific dollar amount isn't a big deal but it is necessary to get that income to pay the bills or at least support the hobby.

The second thing that frustrates me is not getting to spend the time refining the piece. By that I mean, after I've made the first one or occasionally 2 or 3 I would like to be able to follow up and take this process further. Usually when I develope an idea my mind is filled with all of the other directions this idea can go. I think the pros call it a series. I seldom can justify the time to develop a true series based on an idea.

I'm trying to justify the time spent really fine tuning a piece. I don't have galleries around here that can sell work that took me 20 hours to complete. My Cardiac Lamp is a good example. I had a great time working on it and spent a lot of time. Possibly in the right market it would sell for an amount that pays for that much time. It did make it into the Turned for Use show so in my mind that paid me for my time right there.

So basically what I'm saying is I truely understand where you are coming from with this post. If you want to take work to the top levels you have to spend the time to do every detail correctly. That's why pieces like Jacques Vessery/Bonnie Klein colarboration bring so much money. They have taken an idea and spent the time to do it perfectly.

Re: Concept Confrimation or Complete The Piece *LINK*

#3

Re: Concept Confrimation or Complete The Piece

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I always have a form in mind when I start turning a piece. If it's a form that's a bit different, I'll draw sketches. Once in a while a flaw in the wood or whatever, will change my mind during turning, expecially when turning burls.

When I get going on a piece that I like, really pretty wood or a variation on a regular form, I may be out in my shop at 11 PM. working on the finishing touches. Most of my enhancements are done in the evening. Pyrography, piercing, whatever. I can sit down while I'm doing that.

Many years ago I made myself a promise...I will never, ever, say "that's good enough". Instead, say "that's a good as I can do". Only then is the piece finished.

Wally

Re: Concept Confrimation or Complete The Piece *LINK*

#4

Steven Antonucci

You can't think in terms of $$$/hr

steve antonucci

>If you do, you'd see that we'd be working for peanuts. From wood selection and prep, to actually costing out even the simplest items, woodturning is not something that yields itself to high margins and great income.

Instead, you need to view it as each project must be self-actualized. If you can't stand looking at your work because you cut corners to make it economical or fit some time constraint, then you should be doing something else with your time. If you happen to recover some costs because of the sale of a piece or two, then good for you.

Not saying that someone couldn't make a living turning, just that most of us shouldn't consider the amount of time it takes to do something in a hobby...

Steven

Re: Concept Confrimation or Complete The Piece *LINK*

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: Concept Confrimation or Complete The Piece

Keith Tompkins

>HI Charlie, I think it's important to have a vision of what you intend to make.....that way, it's easy to know when it's done. I usually work on a concept, making several models to ensure the idea is sound. Then, I intend to turn the best piece I ever did. Many of my best pieces were those I thought may be beyond my abilities, so I push myself a bit extra.

I think in the end, the time spent on a piece is irrelevant, it' all in the results. It's important to follow through; not just for the discipline, but finished pieces often inspire new pieces as well. I need to be excited about my work...if not, I'll simply toss a piece or put it aside, and work on something else that I just can't wait to complete.

I had a student once tell me "I turned a thousand bowls last year!" after I had "critiqued" his work at his request. In my opinion, he would have been further ahead if he had just completed ONE piece to the best of his ability, instead of hundreds of mediocre pieces.

Re: Concept Confrimation or Complete The Piece *LINK*

#6

Re: Concept Confrimation or Complete The Piece

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>For me, one of the most intriguing things about turning that I am discovering, is the way I get inspired and how easy it seems to be to expand on an idea. I have been having such fun discovering what interests me and then figuring out how I am going to apply the ideas that I have in my head to the wood. When I first started turning, I just wanted to turn bowls. I approached the wood with this goal. Well, I achieved this and continued to turn them, but eventually found myself bored with "just turning bowls".

I have now turned to studying the concept of surface enhancement and off-center turning, two techniques that I have found interest me. My recent post of a dyed and limed off-center bowl is my first, best interpretation of these two concepts. I feel I took this piece to completion, but it is not the end.

I have already found that this is going to lead me down a path. I'm sure that that path is going to have a lot of tributaries entering it and there will be more influences in my future.

Complete those pieces. They may start you on an amazing journey.

keithz

Re: Concept Confrimation or Complete The Piece *LINK*

#7

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Concept Confrimation or Complete The Piece

Jesper, Denmark

>Charlie, you are management talent! Go far enough to prove the idea and then let the someone better suited to to tedium continue and finish the work.

My attention span is about like yours, so I emphathise with you. Unfortunately, I do not have any coolies to go from the proven idea to finished product state. Fortunately, with turning, I don't need to as this is an egoistic hobby - not for sale or admiration by others.

Work is another question, there the tedium of f. ex. accountuing drives me upu and up the wall till one day I will fall down.

Re: Concept Confrimation or Complete The Piece *LINK*

#8

Jesper, Denmark

P.S........

Jesper, Denmark

>I need to add that I have a great admiration for those very talented people, who also go to 100% completion of their ideas, so the rest of us can enjoy their work.

It just ain't me.

Re: Concept Confrimation or Complete The Piece *LINK*

#9

It depends...

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Some people are inclined to pursue ideas to completion, others aren't.

Some ideas were worth pursuing, some aren't - at least not right now.

I've done many one-shot projects - made one piece and then moved on to something more interesting. Sometimes these projects resurface later. I made a my first plate/platter back in 2003, made my second one last fall.

Sometimes a project really sparks my interest enough to pursue to completion. I first played with multi-center/multi-axis turnings two years ago and I worked on it intermittently since then. I've finally reached a point where I'm satisfied with the shape/form and technique and it is time to move on. (One of these days I'll take a picture of "Bubba and the Twisted Sisters III", but don't hold your breath waiting. I completed the pieces two months ago and still haven't taken a picture.)

As a hobby turner, I have the freedom to pursue what interests me. Try this, try that... until I hit something that I really want to pursue to completion.

Re: Concept Confrimation or Complete The Piece *LINK*

#10

Re: Concept Confrimation or Complete The Piece

charlie belden

>R.O.I. (Return On Investment), The Vision Thing, Stay The Course, Oh- Look Over THERE!

If you take a hard look at turning, or any other branch of woodwroking, it's like actors - some make a LOT of money doing it - but damned few - probably well fewer than 0.001%. Yes, there are a precious few who make a decent living, and even fewer who make a really good living turning wood. But like the "entertainment industry", it's not the "artists" who make the Big Bucks - it's the Studios and everyone else who benefit the most. In the case of woodworking it's the tool manufacturers and the sellers of the tools, equiptment and supplies that make far more than most woodworkers driving the process.

So I don't come at a turning thinking in terms of ROI.

And the Vision Thing - I'm seeing things through Tri-Focals - and the ones with the lines not the "blended lenses". While I can visualize - and draw - in 2-D pretty well - having been doing that since I was two or three - and with furniture that's basically flat surfaces I can visualize and draw "3-D", turning doesn't normally involve faces and edges and ends. I could draw one of Graeme Priddle's pieces or one of Jimmy Clewes "chinese boxes - if I had it in my hand (which I actually had the opportunity to do with one of Graeme's pieces and can do with one of Clewes chinese boxes since I won his demo piece in a raffle).

BUT - to sketch out the basic shape and then flesh out the major details - well that's probably not in my bag of tricks. I CAN "sketch" in actual 3-D, but it can be pretty time consuming and tedious. I've done jewelry making. Fabricating (start with sheet stock, wires and solder and cut out, assemble and solder) was just too slow and inflexible. Lost wax cast pieces were what I did - and additative rather than subtractive (keep adding stuff 'til yu have an elephant instead of cutting away everything that doesn't look like an elephant).. Pretty quick for making the object - in wax. I could see what I had - in real 3-D and at actual size. I need only imagineinvision it in silver or gold, or bronze. The actual casting in metal and the finishing took more time - but most of the ideas that got to metal, let alone finishing were Keepers - AND sold. And IF an idea turned out to be a Dead End I could at least reuse the wax in it - and I hadn't wasted time - and gold or silver - on it.

Now wood, on the other hand, takes time to sketch in. And it's all a Subtractive Process - a lapse in concentration can turn that very last finishing cut into an AH S*!T! cut - with No UNDO key. Oh - and unlike wax or metal - it's not homogeneous. That wonderful figure in the wood. which makes it such an interesting material for a finished piece, can be a double edged sword - cutting both ways - or more accurately - tearing out in one direction - unless you have, and use the right tool, sharpened just the right way, and used with skill and technique.

Perhaps if I had a stash of wood on hand - in plenty of sizes and colors and grains - and all dried and ready to work - I could search through it and find the perfect wood, with the perfect working characteristics for an idea I've come up with. Alas, while I have that for "flat work", stock in turning sizes are much harder to come by, and even harder to come by dried and ready to turn to completion. (OK - so "green turners" can find whatever they need - pretty much when they need it) I've got a driveway full of Future Turning Stock (read logettes, split logettes, chunks of trees, "blanks" in the making) - but little of it is ready to turn "dry".

So maybe the availability of the right material is a needed part of The Vision Thing. Maybe not. I DO know that trying to bring a Vision to Reality - in the wrong wood - can be an exercise in frustration, if not futility.

"Life's too short to spend time turning crappy wood." is sage advice. And it would be a wonderful world if every turner had the perfect wood in the right size(s) for every piece she or he would like to turn. But we live in an imperfect world.

To Staying the Course - there should ALWAYS be a feedback loop along the way - is this course worth continuing to pursue?. Repeatedly spitting in the wind WILL NOT get your face any drier. Developing "Know When To Holde 'Em - And - Know When To Fold 'Em" has to be developed - if one intends to do more than a few pieces in a lifetime. He Who Fights And Runs Away - LIVES To Fight Another Day has a different connotation than Cut And Run - though both can have the same end result. Self Discipline is a valuable trait - continuing to try and dig oneself out of a hole is not.

Then there's HEY - look over THERE! If you keep changing directions - and do that long enough - you end up back where you started - ankle or knee deep in shavings -and typically nothing to show for the time and effort.

So there's a balancing act each must find. I'm still looking.

Have you found your balance and if so, what works for you?

charlie belden