Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

hollowing tools

Posts

hollowing tools

#1

hollowing tools

Andrew Lunn

>Hey everyone. I'm completely new to this board and have a question I'm hoping you can help with regarding hollowing tools. My father in law has a birthday coming up, and he has gotten into turning. He seems to really enjoy turning bowls, and I think he would really enjoy turning boxes, and deeper vessels like vases even. So I was thinking of getting him a hollowing tool so that he could hollow out a vessel that has an opening narrower than its body. Do you guys have any suggestions? Any of these tools that particularly stand out? I would greatly appreciate any suggestions, as I don't do that much turning, and turn spindles when I do. Thanks!

Andrew

Re: hollowing tools

#2

Re: hollowing tools *LINK*

Cyril Griesbach

>Andrew,

Here is just one of many possible options.


John Jordan Hollowing tools

Re: hollowing tools

#3

Re: hollowing tools

Andrew Lunn

>Hi Cyril,

Thanks for the link. Are these tools that you like personally? I came across a number of hollowing tools at http://www.woodturnerscatalog.com/store/Turning_Tools___Hollowing_Tools

I just didn't have enough background to make an intelligent decision. The ones you linked to look nice as well.

Oh, and in the way of proper introductions, I should say that I'm not new to Wood Central, just this board; I normally read and occasionally post over on the Hand Tool board.

Thanks again for your help.

Re: hollowing tools

#4

Steven Antonucci

Make them

steve antonucci

>Anyone hanging out on the hand tool forum probably has the required skills to make what you need to hollow. I just had a gaggle of people in my shop, and the consensus was that anyone can make tools once they see the light.

If you look at the tool in it's basic element, it is nothing more than a metal rod with a cutting edge held at the end of it. You can buy cold rolled at HD for about $6 and make a bunch of tools, or order O1 from Enco and make them prettier. If you turn, making handles won't be that hard to do.

Here is a set that I made. A similar set in a catalog was $119+shipping. These cost me 15 minutes and about $6, but only because I bought the wood for the handles (1.25 ea...)

Steven


img

Re: hollowing tools

#5

agree with Cyril and Steve

john lucas

>I make many of my own tools and have tried out a lot of others. For small vessels I like to make my own using the method Steve describes. I buy w-1 drill rod from enco because it's water hardening and easy to work with.

I like the John Jordan tools because they are simple, efficient and work well. Replacement tips are easy to get and to sharpen. They were designed by John who makes his living turning hollow vessels and has for many many years. I use his on larger work because I don't have the equipment to make tools with shanks larger than 1/2" and it's difficult for me to make the 1/2" tools. The curves John put on the tools are just right for 90 percent or more of the vessels out there.

Re: hollowing tools

#6

Re: hollowing tools

Cyril Griesbach

>Andrew,

I bought a set of Jordan tools when he demoed here in Wisconsin in April but I've not had much time to get that familiar with them.

However, Steve is quite correct in that making them is not that difficult and I have made some myself in our tool making sessions at the turning club. I also have a set of David Ellsworth's tools and the cutting tips on them come out straight and at a 45 degree angle from the shaft...no bending of the shaft. Most hollowing cutters are just tool steel cutting bits available from Enco and similar suppliers. They are cut to length and the cutting edge profile ground on a bench grinder.

Re: hollowing tools

#7

Re: Make them

Andrew Lunn

>Hi guys, thanks for the suggestions. Making them would not be out of the question, although I'm not sure I have the time to make ones nice enough to be given as the "big" gift that numerous people chipped in on. I'm already busy making saws in my spare time. How are those HSS cutters attached to the ends of the tools, generally speaking, with tangs that enter the rod and that are secured with set screws? What kind of relief angle do you give the cutting edges on the cutters? Wouldn't making the cutters from O-1 or W-1 make them prone to overheating? I don't know much about how vigorously these tools get applied to the work, mind you.

Thanks again for all of your input.

Re: hollowing tools

#8

Re: hollowing tools

Andrew Lunn

>Thanks again Cyril. How do you find the W-1 holds up?

Re: hollowing tools

#9

Steven Antonucci

Depends on the size and style

steve antonucci

>Ellsworth style hollowers are rods with cutters inset straight and at a 45 degree angle. He glues them in. On larger bars, I tap a set screw in the top.

On smaller rods, I use O1 and just bend the rod in a bench vise after grinding the half round. I then heat treat with a MAPP torch. Quick and easy- a set takes less than 30 minutes with the handles if I am in the zone...

Steven

Re: hollowing tools

#10

Re: Make them

john lucas

>Andrew You can make the shaft of the tool out of cold roll steel. You don't need steel that can be hardened for this. The John Jordan tools have a HSS metal cutting bit inserted in the end.

There are a couple of ways to do this. Drill a round hole just big enough for the square cutter and then use CA glue to hold it in place, or drill and tap a hole for a set screw. I've done both. the set screw fill up with wood dust so put it on the bottom. It makes it easier to sharpen the cutter because you can remove it from the bar. On the CA glue cutters I just sharpen with it in the bar. I use 3/16 square hss cutters. They come about 3" long. I cut them by making a small notch with the dremel and cutoff wheel and then snap them in two in a vise.

To sharpen the tool I grind them very similar to a bowl gouge with wings but I leave the top flat or will occasionally relieve it a little but I don't think you need to. To sharpen I round over the edges of my grinding wheel. The I put the left side of the cutter on the right side of the wheel and drag it back to shape the left side of the tool. Then I pull it across the wheel to sharpen the tip and then continue on to the left side of the stone to sharpen the right side of the tool.

John Jordan sells a little tool holder that lets you sharpen them very accurately.

Regarding your question on 0-1 or W-1 being damaged by heat. You can take the hardness out of them on the grinder but probably not when cutting wood. They need to get to about 400 degrees to cause much loss of hardness. I have made some tools from the drill rod that I didn't harden at all. They work fine just need sharpening more.

Re: hollowing tools

#11

Re: Make them

Andrew Lunn

>John, thank you very much for the detailed response. Those 3/16" cutters that you use, where do you get those? The HSS I see at the places where I buy materials is all in rod form.

Also, do these tools operate with more of a scraping action, or a cutting action? The bits I've seen that go in the ends of the tools look like they'd be scrapers, but I don't see why you couldn't shear the wood instead of scrape it. But then I don't know much about vessel turning either. :)

Thanks for the help.

Re: hollowing tools

#12

Thank you Steve!

Andrew Lunn

>

Re: hollowing tools

#13

Steven Antonucci

You use both

steve antonucci

>As a hollow turner (primarily), most people will cut through the entry hole using a tool with a scraping action to remove lots of wood quickly, then shear scrape with a teardrop tool to clean up the millions of little ridges inside.

Again, it is nothing more than a rod with a flat ground on it and a set screw to hold the cutter. They take a little more effort to make than the Ellsworth style tools, but not much. They do require a much larger entry hole, so I only use them on "big pieces".

Steven

Re: hollowing tools

#14

Lyle Jamieson

Re: hollowing tools

Lyle Jamieson

>Hi Andrew,

My advice is dont make a purchase for another turner. With that said I would recommend my system, of course. www.lylejamieson.com. I would highly recommend that the turner himself or herself USE a boring bar system before they buy it. There are too many options out there. Some work easy, some dont work very well. There are people in every club all accross the country that have all the respectable systems, and they would be happy to give anybody a test try.

When I use the word systems, even that can be confusing. There are boring bars, there are handles, there are back rest support systems, there are laser measuring devices for them, many of which are interchangable. Two main categories would be if he wants hand held blind hollowing or supported systems with a laser capability. Many people recommend the tool they have, because they have not explored other options or they are trying to justify the first purchase they made even though there may be a better way to hollow...or in my case an easier way to hollow. Its all about the fun. I would not purchase a boring bar for another person without his serious input. I would be afraid to saddle that person with a system he would not enjoy. There are many different options, different strokes for different folks. Please dont hesitate to call me if I can be of any assistance in comparing models with you. Lyle

Re: hollowing tools

#15

Re: hollowing tools

Andrew Lunn

>Hi Lyle, thank you very much for you input. I appreciate it very much. Nice sculptures and tools by the way. What kind of carving tools do you use? I do some carving also.

Regarding the turning tools, your point is well taken. I had given this quite a bit of thought before I even posted a question here, simply because I know how that can go. I would be loathe to buy a tool like that for most people. But knowing my father in law actually helps quite a bit--it's hard to explain, but I have a pretty good sense of how he works and what sorts of tools he would use and wouldn't use. For instance, the laser tools, I honestly just don't think he would use something like that. He works on a homemade lathe that was built by one of his inlaws and just really enjoys turning in a very fundamental and visceral sort of way. I just don't see anything too high tech like that really appealing to him very much. So what I truly think is that he would be thrilled with nice tools that work well; he's a pretty crafty guy and I bet he would be happy with a variety of different tools. But in any case I think it would be wise to not buy something that cannot be returned.

While the idea of making these tools appeals to me, because making tools is in fact something I do, in this case I think we will probably buy something, because it is a gift from so many different people, and not just me.

I really thank everyone for their input on this thread. Everyone has been very generous with their turning knowledge. I have definitely learned some things. While I might not make these tools for this gift, I may well make some down the road. My own turning tools are extremely simple and homemade, for turning tool handles. But I would like to start incorporating split turnings and things like that into my woodwork.

Anyway, thanks again.

Andrew

Re: hollowing tools

#16

Lyle Jamieson

Re: hollowing tools

Lyle Jamieson

>Thanks for the note about my sculptures. I use a wide variety of tools, all rotary tools. Starts with the lathe, elect. chain saw, arbortech, alumacut die grinder burs, fordom, and a wide variety of disk and drum sanders. One of my favorite tools is my radial arm saw. No, I dont have a saw in it but I pull the motor all the way out and position a 36 grit drum sander in the arbor and use is as a shaper.

One rule I have is that one element must be stationary. While the wood is thick enough I can clamp it on the bench or vise. When it gets too thin to clamp down I take the sculpture to a stationary tool. The only time I have the piece in one hand and the tool in the other is when I do the last 600 grit sanding. Almost everything else can be done with some kind of tool.

The laser is the low tech method. A 10 your old kid can do hollow forms with my tools. It makes hollowing fun instead of hard work especially for older turners. Lyle