Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Cracked bowl question

Posts

Cracked bowl question

#1

Cracked bowl question

Ron McKinley

>I roughed out a piece of Magnolia about a month ago to 1" thickness all around (approx. 10" across and 5" deep). Then coated the end-grain, inside and out, with sealer and put in a loosely sealed paper bag. After 3 weeks I noticed two cracks in the bottom. Yesterday I noticed the cracks had gone all the way through the piece in a few places.

Question: Should I patch the cracks with CA glue and coffee grounds/sanding dust now or wait until it's dry enough to finish turn? I can't tell if the cracks will develop enough to actually split the bowl apart. If that happens I suppose it will become firewood. Thanks.......Ron

Re: Cracked bowl question

#2

Re: Cracked bowl question

Jerry Hall

>My (limited!) experience is that the cracking will often continue, but it is no big deal to add coffee filler later in the new opening. Maybe doing it now would stabilize the crack somewhat, probably not. If it keeps on cracking your surfaces are likely to be offset. Maybe you will have enough thickness to blend them in, maybe not. If I like the bowl, and it is natural edge, I think filling cracks and blending the two surfaces across the coffee filler looks nice. It's a matter of taste. I have made walnut biscuits and used a plate joiner to visually tie the cracks together across the coffee grounds, making no pretense that the crack is there. It's a fun look too. You can even open up the crack with a Dremel to make a statement. I could dig up a picture but you get the idea. I run into this all the time with my Madrone pieces and am learning to make lemonade out of cracks so to (mis)speak.

Re: Cracked bowl question

#3

Aage Rendalen

Added question: is Titebond better?

Aage Rendalen

>Given the poor tensile strength of superglue, is Titebond a better choice? I suppose that with hairline cracks, superglue is the only possible choice but with wider cracks, what experience do you all have with alternative glues?

Re: Cracked bowl question

#4

Re: Cracked bowl question

Al Neighbors

>Ron, they are likely to continue cracking until it's dry enough to turn...

If it were mine, I'd wait until I decided to turn it. Then, I'd use coffee grounds and epoxy, instead of CA. Unless you have the specific kind that remains pliable your CA will get brittle and will not be kind to your bowl if it moves some more after filling. The epoxy I use is the 2-ton type sold at Wallyworld, in the double syringe. It will have a little more flexibility that CA.

Don't give up on the possibility of just lacing the crack with leather lace or baling wire. That makes it art, and it'll sell. :)

Re: Cracked bowl question

#5

Re: Added question: is Titebond better?

Al Neighbors

>Aage, I'd be hesitant to use the titebond if the bowl was to be used, because repeated washings will loosen the titebond. But I suppose it would be fine if it's not going to be a utility bowl.

I've never tried to mix coffee grounds with titebond, so I can't speak to that end...

Re: Cracked bowl question

#6

Re: Added question: is Titebond better?

Jerry Hall

>I believe Tightbond would be tough to mix with coffee grounds, and its color would detract from the filling. There are flexible CA glues but I have never tried them. My approach is to use thin CA to tie the coffee grounds together and then do a final pass with medium thick so I have a full filling for smooth sanding unless I want the texture of the grounds to be a finish feature. I would go with CA or Epoxy better if you have the patience to mix the stuff, spoon it in and wait for it to dry. CA is a much neater job I think.

Re: Cracked bowl question

#7

Re: Titebond or Gorilla glue

Ron McKinley

>I don't think Titebond will work on wet wood but I've never tried it. As for lacing the crack, these cracks started in the base and are about 2" long now. If they come all the way up to the rim then lacing would work.

The reason I thought of CA is that works on wet wood pretty good but I don't know how it will react if the wood keeps moving.

What about Gorilla glue? I don't really like that stuff because of all the cleanup necessary but in this case I can turn it away. Anyone ever tried Gorilla on something like this? Thanks.....Ron

Re: Cracked bowl question

#8

Re: Titebond or Gorilla glue

john lucas

>Gorilla glue won't fill a crack. It will turn to foam.

Re: Cracked bowl question

#9

Steven Antonucci

Cracked bowls are for experimenting

steve antonucci

>I'd toss it aside and use it for experimenting. As you know, wood with cracks can fly apart with little warning, so be careful if it goes back on the lathe.

Life is too short to turn "cracky" wood...

Steven

Re: Cracked bowl question

#10

Re: Titebond or Gorilla glue

Ron McKinley

>Even if packed with coffee grounds or other filler? .......Ron

Re: Cracked bowl question

#11

Re: Cracked bowls are for experimenting

Ron McKinley

>Cracky and Crappy is about the same but the Scots in me just won't let me give up! (GRIN) Thanks for your input......Ron

Re: Cracked bowl question

#12

Maple bowl healed itself!

Mike Brazeau

>I had a 12" hard maple bowl I roughed out in January crack longitudinally with the grain right along the tennon about two weeks after starting to dry. The wood was pretty much fresh cut when roughed out. It had been wrapped in several sheets of newspaper. I transferred it to a plastic grocery bag with the opening loosely closed. The crack gradually came back together and now I can barely see it, but will wick in some CA to secure the joint. Sometimes it pays not to give up!

Re: Cracked bowl question

#13

Re: Titebond or Gorilla glue

john lucas

>Ron I'm not sure about the packed with coffee grounds but it takes very little room for it to turn to foam. It is not a gap filling glue at all. I would use epoxy or CA. I use epoxy on anything that it will penetrate and CA if the crack is too small for the epoxy.

Personally I haven't found anything that Gorilla glue will do that another glue won't do equal or better with an easier to clean up mess.

Re: Cracked bowl question

#14

Re: Cracked bowl question

Peter Hyde

>You mean to say you guys have wood with no cracks? Wow! I always leave it to the last minute and give all cracks a shot of thin ca. During the turning any ca stain will be removed then final sanding is done wet with tung oil. The slurry fills any open cracks nicely and when left to dry for a few days it sets up. A quick buff and then use any finish you want. Another easy one is to fill the cracks before turning with a mix of hide glue and sanding flour (you do keep it don't you?) and then sand. Hide glue is flexible and sands off really clean without gumming up the paper.

The cracks in this cherry were filled with wet sanding slurry


img