Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Powered Respirators Question.

Posts

Powered Respirators Question.

#1

Powered Respirators Question.

Robert R. Clough - Tthorncraft

>Not being a turner (I'd be dangerous with a lathe) I seldom come here. However, it was suggested on the general board that I post the following as you people tend to use powered respirators. Oh yes, I was told of another brand - Bradwest.

I have Emphysema and Asthma. I am on various breathing medications, taking Pulmonary Rehab "forever" - and it works. I shall probably go on Oxy for heavy work (digging post holes, chain sawing, snow shoveling etc.) Now, I must get some form of powered respirator for the shop. I have recently tried a device that fit over the nose - it had a fan. Not enough air for me. I used to have a Trend face shield but it died several years ago and was not replaced.

I have checked out the new Triton and Trend devices. Both appear to work and articles indicate each works as described. The Triton appears to be bulkier and perhaps less easy to use (Matt Berger of FWW says it made him look like an escapee from a HAZMAT crew). The Trend appears similar to the shield I had several years ago. I remember it being relatively easy to use even with glasses (all masks are a nuisance - but breathing IS necessary).

Now, have any of you used either of these? If so, what results did you have? How easy are they to use? Is the air flow very good? E-mail if you prefer.

Re: Powered Respirators Question.

#2

Re: Powered Respirators Question.

Rick Allen

>I have the new TP (Trend Pro). There are several issues with the TP.

Everything sits on top of your head. For me that makes the device top heavy. I had the RA (Racal Airmate) which is similar to the older Trend. All the "stuff" is on the front. I found that low front load arrangement easier to wear.

The TP is harder to put on than the RA. I guess because the head is sealed instead of just the face.

The TP is noisy. I find the noise distracting. I thought I would get used to the noise but that hasn't happened.

The TP has terrific visibility. The shield is closer to my face than the RA which ends up giving a good view while still permitting glasses to be worn.

The TP has great air flow. It feels like twice as much air flow as the RA.

The TP seams "cleaner" than the RA. Between the increased air flow and the more secure seal as well as the large filters the TP feel like more and cleaner air is available.

I like the idea of the motor filters and such being located off the head. But I haven't used that type of power respirator so there are likely issues with that style. I suspect that having two "things" to deal with is an issue.

Between the RA and the TP I would like the RA. The RA with more air flow would be a real winner.

Re: Powered Respirators Question.

#3

Re: Powered Respirators Question.

Gordon Seto

>I have the Triton and BreatheEasy from 3M. The air flow from Triton is adequate, but not as strong as 3M. The Triton battery is built-in the blower unit. You can't have a spare battery charged ready for exchange. In hot, humid day, I do appreciate the extra cool air over the face from the 3M. With 3M, you can also get filters for organic matters, which may be useful if you are spraying solvent based finishes.

Gordon

Re: Powered Respirators Question.

#4

Re: Powered Respirators Question.

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Robert, I have been using what is now called the Airstream for about 11 years now. It is made by 3M. Mine is old enough that it was the AH-5 made by Racal. 3M bought Racal out and continued to manufacture the unit. Everything except the battery is contained in the helmet, and it is very well balanced. I have worn it for hours at a time without discomfort. It also gives a good flow of air, enough so that my glasses will not fog up in humid weather. It ain't cheap, but it beats not being able to breathe. You can see the various options at the link below. If you have specific questions, I would be glad to try and answer them.

Bill

Re: Powered Respirators Question.

#5

Re: Powered Respirators Question.

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Well, I'll try the link again. If it doesn't work, go to www.airwareamerica.com.

Re: Powered Respirators Question.

#6

Re: Powered Respirators Question.

Fog Tanner

>I have used a Powervisor, but have used an Airstream for several years now. I have allergies to several woods which I turn and am sensitive to a number of others. I cannot turn Cedar without the Airstream, if I do I will have a sinus headache for three days.

I find it comfortable to wear, it is balanced with the motor in the back. I wear the battery on a belt, so there is no weight on the helmet from that. I wear glasses and have no problems with them fogging up any time of the year. In the summer, I like the cool breeze over the face.

I have the AS400 which has a higher speed fan than the AS200. The battery is good for over 12 hours, that is the longest I have used it so far. I have the "smart charger" which will recharge the battery and then switch to a trickle. I keep it on trickle until I need it, so it is always charged.

These days I don't turn the lathe on with wearing it. It is a lot like body armor with the hard helmet and visor. I got mine from Airware America, along with spare filters. 3M raises the price every Feburary so it is best to buy one before then.

Good luck in your search,

Fog