Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

"Multi-Axis Equation - Revised" for John K. Jordon *LINK*

Posts

"Multi-Axis Equation - Revised" for John K. Jordon *LINK*

#1

"Multi-Axis Equation - Revised" for John K. Jordon *LINK*

charlie belden

>The following will probably only be of interest to John K. Jordon and maybe one other curious person so if you're not a Details Person and the word "math" makes you drowsy and "geometry" and "trig" put you in a coma - find another message to read.

In a previous thread Peter Hyde initiated with the question "What's the difference between Multi-Axes (sic), Multi-Centre (sic) and Off Centre (sic)?" Peter Hyde provided a link to one of the web pages I did on turning a "3 Sided Box" that had some equations for getting the biggest 3 Sided Box from a square blank. (you with me so far?)

John found what he believed were several errors in those equations and their derivation and asked for clarifaction. Turns out he was right - sloppy work on my part - though some were basically typos.

So, as promised, I went back over that page, corrected the typos, and redid most of the page, checking everything more thoroughly as I redid that page and illustrations. Also cleaned up an earlier page that used those equations.

The link below is to the corrected page of illustrations and "math" and if you back up two pages the "table and equations" has been corrected as well.

Thanks John for the thorough review and comments.


Corrected illustrations and equations

Re: "Multi-Axis Equation - Revised" for John K. Jordon *LINK*

#2

Re: "Multi-Axis Equation - Revised" for John K. Jo

John K Jordan

>The page in the link is still the old page, or at least it is for me. Perhaps a cache is not yet updated.

JKJ

Re: "Multi-Axis Equation - Revised" for John K. Jordon *LINK*

#3

Re: "Multi-Axis Equation - Revised" for John K. Jo

charlie belden

>It's there - honest. You're probably getting the old page from your browser's cache. Hit "reload" or "refresh" to ignore the cached version of the page and download the current one.

Re: "Multi-Axis Equation - Revised" for John K. Jordon *LINK*

#4

Re: "Multi-Axis Equation - Revised" for John K. Jo

John K Jordan

>I can see it now. I didn't go through it carefully, but it appears the page is improved with comments. (BTW, there is no need to explain that typo - it was very minor)

When I get time, I want to look at this a little closer. It seems on casual inspection (and verified with a quick CAD drawing) that the given shape will not fit precisely into a square as shown, i.e., AC must be less than S/2 to allow the long axis, HJ, to fit within S. To fit entirely within the square and avoid cutting off the tip at H, perhaps the derivation of 'd' needs to be based on S=HJ rather than S=AE. I suspect it may be necessary to do the chord geometry to be exact.

Of course, either way it is of little importance when working with actual wood on a real lathe! (Who would or could measure to four decimal places on a 2" turning square.) But where math is concerned, it is nice to know if what you are putting out there is exact or an approximation.

JKJ