Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Koa lidded jar...

Posts

Koa lidded jar...

#1

Mike Stafford

Koa lidded jar...

Mike Stafford

>David Chung sent me this piece of koa that I have worried over for quite some time trying to figure out how best to use. It was too big for one of my normal boxes and that would have resulted in too much waste to suit me. And it was not quite large enough to get two boxes.

So I came up with this form. Initially the lid was a snug fit and I almost lost the whole thing when I picked it up by the lid and it popped out. I managed to save the piece by catching it with the instep of my foot. I changed the fit and now it is an easy to remove lid.

At 4" tall and 3 3/4" in diameter it has an ebony Mun knob. The photo does not capture the black and gray stripes in the knob. Several folks have recommended if I do another to fatten the knob to make it shaped more like the body of the jar. Others suggested some small beads near the bottom of the knob.

Your comments appreciated....


img

Re: Koa lidded jar...

#2

Re: Koa lidded jar...

Duane C.Leach

>Just because you can isn't a good enough reason to add coves beads and such. Most of the time less is more. It looks great the way it is.

Duane

Re: Koa lidded jar...

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: Koa lidded jar...

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Mike, I'm with Duane on this one....too many times turners add details for no real reason, and they end up detracting. For example, scored lines around the form would have ruined it. Adding details to the knob without carrying the theme throughout the piece would not have worked as well. Your form and finish look superb, but I find the way the lid sits upon the form to be a bit distracting from the overall effect. It may be just me, but I find that lids that appear to merely sit upon a form , rather than being an integral part of the design, come off as almost an afterthought. Still, a lovely piece.

Re: Koa lidded jar...

#4

Re: Koa lidded jar...

john lucas

>Mike that's a very nice box. Really clean and great shape.

Re: Koa lidded jar...

#5

Steven Antonucci

My observation.

steve antonucci

>I like all three elements, and any two together.

I think that the vessel and the lid go together, but the scale and shape of the knob are "underwhelming".

I think the lid and the knob go together, but the abruptness of the two compete with the flowing line of the box.

A bead or something to connect the knob to the other two might be a good try. You could mock it up in MDF to see if it helps.

Steven

Re: Koa lidded jar...

#6

Re: Koa lidded jar...

Danny Wells

>Hey Mike, don't you just hate those challenges: too big for your normal size work and not big enough to make two....I know the feeling.

It's a beautiful box as is. The curve on the bottom of the box is exceptionally well done.

I would say a definite no to the beads for the same reasons mentioned earlier.

The only thing I might would try next time would be a slight concave curve on the sides of the knob. I think it's the straight sides on the knob that catch the eye. And maybe a little more curve and slope on the lid from the knob to the lip of the lid...so that the curve of the top of the lid flows more into the body of the box.

Just my two cents. What does a turkey call maker know. :-)