Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Quicker handling skew?

Posts

Quicker handling skew?

#1

Keith Tompkins

Quicker handling skew?

Keith Tompkins

>I finally broke down and bought a few new turning tools, including a new 1" skew chisel. It handles much differently than my old skews, although the grind angles are almost identical. It is grabby and prone to catches at the slightest input. I think I've figured out the problem...my old skews have square edges, which I eased, while the new skew has a rounded edge. This seemingly minor difference has changed the cutting geometry; as shown in the image. If I were to rotate my old skew from the point where it sits on the toolrest (A) in a complete circle, you can see the difference from the new tool, which rests on point B. That would explain the difference in the way the new tool handles....any one else experience this?


img

Re: Quicker handling skew?

#2

Re: Quicker handling skew?

john lucas

>Keith I have an Oval skew that I've use for years. When I bought the new Thompson skew it has a rounded bottom edge like you describe. There is definitely a difference in how the two handle even though the fulcrum point is a lot closer than the two that you describe. I've like the Thompson skew better now that I've learned the differences. It's thicker and just feels nicer. It also holds an edge a lot longer.

Re: Quicker handling skew?

#3

Steven Antonucci

It takes some getting used to...

steve antonucci

>I rounded the bottom of my skew after seeing ALan Lacer at Totally Turning last year. At first, I hated it, but after getting used to it, I don't thing I'd go back.

Can't put steel back on the tool, so you might just want to give it a shot :-)

Steven

Re: Quicker handling skew?

#4

Re: Quicker handling skew?

John K Jordan

>I have several skew configurations. I discovered I get used to the one I've been using for a while and when I switch to one with different angles, grind, or edges, it feels unnatural for a while. Use that one for a while and it feels great. I think I'd be better off to grind and radius them all the same.

JKJ

Re: Quicker handling skew?

#5

Re: Quicker handling skew?

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Not only will this skew handle nicer, it will be much easier to sharpen than the oval skew.

Re: Quicker handling skew?

#6

Re: Quicker handling skew?

Fog Tanner

>Keith, I have a number of skews of both the square edge and rounded edge variety. When doing a lot of spindle work I will switch from one to the other as they get dull. I don't really notice any difference when rolling beads when I switch. I tend to watch the edge and where I want it to go. The handle movement seems to take care of itself. I know that there is some difference in the movement, but I would have to go out and do it to see what exactly it is.

What I find more of a change for me is going from a radiused profile, which I use, to a straight profile. I was giving a class yesterday at out annual Retreat on making endgrain bowls. I was using a skew for the demo, assuming that everyone would use a gouge to make theirs. Turns out all but one wanted to try a skew for roughing and finishing. I was jumping from one to the next and they all had some variation of bevel angles and straight profiles. At that point, the rounded edges were of secondary concern.

Re: Quicker handling skew?

#7

Mike Stafford

What good is an oval skew?

Mike Stafford

>I tried using one and found it unwieldy to use and difficult to sharpen. Of course that does not mean much coming from someone who reaches for a skew as a last resort. For me it is a specialty tool that I only use in certain situations because I have no skills with it. I know, I need to practice, practice, practice....

Re: Quicker handling skew?

#8

Re: What good is an oval skew?

john lucas

>Mike my first skew and the one I have used the most is an oval skew. Since I learned to sharpen by hand it wasn't any harder to sharpen than other skews. The only time the oval skew is hard to sharpen is if you use a flat tool rest or other similar device. Then it's hard to hold it flat.

The idea behind an oval skew was that the fulcrum point for rolling a bead is directly under the cutting edge and therefore the edge doesn't have to move as far when rotating the tool over. THis supposedly made it easier to keep the bevel on the wood. A flat skew with slightly knocked off corners has the fulcrum off center. OK sounds good in theory. In actual use the difference between an oval skew, flat skew or flat skew with rounded bottom, is more feel and what you learn to use.

Re: Quicker handling skew?

#9

Re: What good is an oval skew?

Fog Tanner

>Its OK for planing cuts, I was using one yesterday for that. I won't own one, but was helping someone and that is all he had. I don't care for them in a situation where you are asking a lot of the tool and it could flex. I never found an advantage in using them for rolling beads, which is what they were sold for.

The skew is a tool that just takes a lot of practice and can be very unforgiving. Even after almost 40 years, Raffan still practices. But, it is also a lot of fun when you want to make shavings in a hurry. And it gets the cleanest cut across the endgrain of any tool in your tool box. The key to a good start is to understand why you get a catch. Raffan's Turning Wood has a good explanation of what happens and why. It also helps to turn the lathe over by hand while using the tool with the other hand.

Another usefull learning aid is a light pull drive or a friction drive. This will let the piece stop when you get a catch, instead of a spiral runback. You can then see what you did wrong and correct it. That will take away a lot of the fear, and at the same time you get lots of practice and can make enough light pulls to pay for the drive (was $18.00 at C.S.).

Re: Quicker handling skew?

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: What good is an oval skew?

Keith Tompkins

>HI Mike, The skew chisels I'm referring to are the straight-sided variety; only the edge that contacts the toolrest has been rounded on one, while the other retains its square-edge profile.

I've used the oval skews as well without much fuss, but I much prefer the traditional shape. I use the skew both long-point down, and long-point up, with just about any portion of the cutting edge being utilized. Some cuts require just the very tip cutting (traditional bead technique)others I rub the bevel and use the whole edge. The long point will reach where nothing else will, and is indispensible for fine finial work.

I posted this before, but the image shows one of my long-point down techniques being used to turn a sphere. Notice the tool will reach all the way around the sphere with the tool staying on one plane. The angle of the skew provides a shearing cut, the bevel is alway riding on the turning. and the cut happens right on center of the turning. An easy cut to make.

My problem occurred with my new rounded-edge skew when attempting the traditional technique to cut a bead, with the long-point up and just the very tip cutting. Similar to driving a sports car compared to my old pickup truck....very quick!

The skew is definitely worth the effort.


img

Re: Quicker handling skew?

#11

paint can opener? :)

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>

Re: Quicker handling skew?

#12

Re: paint can opener? :)

Fog Tanner

>Same answer I gave someone this past weekend when they asked about their oval skew. The only problem they had was it needed to be reground to catch the lip of the lid a little better. but once we did that, you can hook it under the lip and roll it to the left and the lip popped right off. Great for opening a can of Waterlox...

Re: Quicker handling skew?

#13

Re: paint can opener? :)

Russ Fairfield

>A screwdriver is a better tool for opening a can, and it can also be ground into a number of useful turning tools.