Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

pommeling

Posts

pommeling

#1

pommeling

Bill Sams

>HI all,

What is the technique needed to avoid spliting out the corners of a blank when creating a pommel on a turned newel??

I have read my books, and tried various widths of skew chisels taking light cuts with the toe, twisting the skew slightly each way creating a "v", but there seems at least on one corner I still split out.

The blank is a 4x4x47, the lower 16" is square, then the 1/4" tapered pommel, then the rest is turned.

Thanks for any thoughts you might have.

Bill

Re: pommeling

#2

Re: pommeling

john lucas

>Bill Sneak up on it. By that I mean start about 1/2" or more away and practice the cut. As you get closer you should have the feel of how the skew is working and what angle to hold the handle to get square corners.

I use the toe of skew and most of the time I arc the tool into the cut by lifting the handle so the toe starts the cut and then continue to lift and push the tool in as it get deeper. You do have to make a relief cut so there is room for the skew to continue so I use the toe in the same manner to make a V clearing away wood and then go back to the square cut again carefully aiming the bevel to create a flat corner on the pommel.

The other technique I use for woods that tend to tearout is to lift the handle very high and start with the toe of the skew and then pull the handle back down so the skew goes in at a really extreme angle.

With the first cut the wood is passing the skew cutting edge at roughly 90 degrees and the angle is reduced as you go toward the middle of the wood. With the second cut the wood is passing the cutting edge almost parallel to the edge so the cut is really clean, almost polished. I use this cut to finish the bottom of goblets and it's not even necesary to sand.

You can do the pommel with a spindle gouge as well. Again I sneak up on the exact line of cut by starting a short distance away and gradually learn how the tool cuts and where the handle has to be in order to get the bevel aimed right down the pencil line.

You can try using tape around the edge and this might help if the wood splits easily or your cutting technique is not perfect but it won't stop corners from chipping if your cuts aren't right.

Re: pommeling

#3

Re: pommeling

Barry Irby

>I agree with all of John's suggestions. It can be done. One of our club members is a master of the skew and has earned his living for years turning posts and pickets or balusters with pommels. If you come to Richmond for the symposium, check out Doug Campbell. If he does not demo it, he can explain it.

Now, for the cheating. Not being good at it, I cheated. I taped the post with some strapping tape. Cut a nick in at each corner with a thin saw and then made the turned part smaller than the square part. When all of that failed, I ran the post through the planer and took about a 1/16" off each flat side and that cleaned up most of it. Then put a 1/8" radius on the corner and got the rest of it. Cheat where you must.

Wonder if you could glue some thin wood on each side and then plane it off later?

Re: pommeling

#4

Re: pommeling.... use a bowl gouge

Ruth Niles

>I usually use the skew just as John suggested but the bowl gouge works very well, too. Also starting about 1/2" away from where you want the pommel is good advice.

Re: pommeling

#5

Re: pommeling-Detail and Bowl gouges

Greg Haugen

>I have been one of the biggest advocates for skews. They have been my "go to" tools for most of my work. As of late, that's changing. My "go to" tools now are my gouges. My preferred tool for pommels is either my Thompson detail gouge or a 1/2" bowl gouge with a 45 degree grind swept back. I usually take a parting tool and cut in about a 1/4" way from the final position for the pommel. I don't always cut to the point where I'm hitting "round" I'm just cutting some of the "corners" back for clearance. If you want, you could remove some of the corner material in the area that will become a round profile anyways but it's not necessary. The parting cut will create a little clearance for the gouge. After that it's a simple "arching" cutting motion with the gouge working my way back to the final position. There, it's done. There's a few principles involved here. For example, if you took a flat piece of metal or plastic and applied a force it would deflect. That's a skew. Now if you took this same piece of material and rolled it like a gouge and applied the same force the effects would be dramatically less. That's your gouge. I don't buy into the fact that the skew is the best tool, I do however think the sharp angle is the best angle for the job. I've found the best combination is the sharp angle with the heft and stability of a gouge.

Also to "tune" your pommels, make a very slight "striking" mark on the corners in a waste area with the lathe on. Stop the lathe and see if you're hitting all four corners the same, if your not, adjust it. Sometime when your only chipping one corner the piece could be off. It's alot harder to hit one corner in a full revolution without vibration compared to hitting four in a shorter space. That split second of one corner being cut can destroy it.

I do alot, ALOT of pommels. One of my "bread and butter" items are my doorstops and they each have a pommel. By using the gouges I'm making better pommels and its faster.

Hope that helps,

Greg Haugen

www.greghaugenwoodturning.com

Re: pommeling

#6

Re: pommeling-Detail and Bowl gouges

john lucas

>Greg I wish we could be side by side cutting with our tools and talking about what's happening because I'm having trouble following what your doing. I do agree a spindle gouge is a good tool to use for this especially the Thompson detail gouge, however the way the wood is going past the cutting edge is the roughly the same when I use the handle up action with the skew. Terry Scott uses the skew to cut large flowing wings on his bowls and says that it produces less vibration than the spindle gouge for the same cut. Anyway it's one of those things that we can't share very well in words.

I would be leary of using the parting tool on a square edge. It's too easy to get one of the edges to pop off. It is good for getting the clearance. Starting with the hand saw is a good technique but you still have to clean up the saw marks with a skew, spindle, or bowl gouge so I just skip that step and go right to the skew. Sanding a sawn endgrain edge is a royal pain which is why it's good to use a cutting tool of some kind.

The easiest to learn this is to put a square scrap piece on the lathe and just start making bigger and deeper V cuts working to make one edge of the V perpendicular to the work. Slow down, let the tool do the work and don't force it to cut and you shouldn't have any problems. In this application starting the cut is easier with the skew than the spindle gouge. I think the bowl gouge is the easiest tool to start the cut but it's more difficult to make the shoulder perfectly square and you have to be really careful finishing the cut next to the round part.

Re: pommeling

#7

Re: pommeling-Detail and Bowl gouges

Greg Haugen

>I completely agree on some things. My main point is there is more than one way to skin a cat, or cut a pommel. :-)) Skews have been one of my favorite and best tools. My ability with the skew is not an issue. I used to avoid any project that I couldn't use a skew on. I learned the bowl gouge technique from an excellent spindle turning friend of mine, Brian Simmons, as well as Stuart Batty. Often times I'll start by making "v" cuts (just start rolling to a center point from both sides- after about two cuts concentrating on one side, the pommel) with the gouge and just work my way to the final spot. Pretty much anymore the pommels have been about a 2-3 cut process and I'm done.

I've never had an issue with the parting tool. The clearance cut could be done with a skew and v cuts but I would prefer to switch to a gouge for the rest or I've just done it with the gouge as well.

I agree skews can do the job but they're not the only thing that can. The best tool to use is the one you prefer.

Greg

Re: pommeling

#8

Re: Ruth beat me to it, but......

Jamie Donaldson

>...the bowl gouge is my tool of choice here. It also helps to put a layer of masking tape on the corners before cutting- helps reduce chip-out on the trailing edges where chipping is potentially the worst.

Re: pommeling

#9

Re: pommeling-Detail and Bowl gouges

john lucas

>Greg I certainly agree there are many ways to do the same job. I can remember when the skew was such a hard thing to use and now it's my go to tool. Of course I'm spending lots more quality time with the Thompson detail gouge. It is especially good for turning pommels because you can't the tool rest close to the work. The Thompson detail gouge is so thick you can really hang it over the tool rest and not get vibration.

That's probably what also makes the bowl gouge a good tool. The less severe cutting edge makes it easier to start the cut and the tool is thick enough you won't get the vibration. I rotate the flute as I cut the pommel so the bottom lip of the bowl gouge will hit the round part of the turning at the finish of the cut. That will eliminate the catch.

Re: pommeling

#10

Re: pommeling

Bill Sams

>Thanks for everyone's insights and techniques.

I have tried to start 1/2" away, even further etc, for trial and error, and got reasonable results.

I also have tried using a parting tool after cutting the "v" with the skew to widen the kerf, but in fact that seemed to make the skew move more erratically "jump".

I have not tried the gouges, but will.

Practice, practice,..... Thanks again everyone.

Re: pommeling

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: pommeling

Keith Tompkins

>Sam, is your skew razor sharp?