Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Denied

Posts

Denied

#1

Denied

Raymond Overman in SC

>I received a letter from a local gallery today denying my entry into their show. It's the first gallery show that I've entered pieces to be juried and it's brought up a few questions.

First, how many of you enter juried gallery shows? What experience and advantage have you seen with entering them as opposed to just presenting work to galleries without the contest? For those of you who enter these type shows, how much of a jury fee are you willing to pay? This one had a $30 entry fee (two pieces)with a $5 each for extra pieces. I entered two pieces.

Looking back I see that it's a money maker for them since they had 92 entrants with 206 pieces and a $1k prize plus they'll receive 40% on sales.

Don't get me wrong, I don't have a negative feeling toward the gallery or the process. I knew what I was getting into and had an idea about who I would be competing against and 30 out of 206 isn't the greatest of odds with the talent that was probably presented. I'm just wondering how this process works overall and would rather not pay out of pocket for the experience ya'll can probably provide.

Just for reference, here are the pieces I entered.


and




img

Re: Denied

#2

and...

Raymond Overman in SC

>and


img

Re: Denied

#3

Re: Denied

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>While not a gallery show, I did recently apply to the American Craft Exposition. It is one of the hardest shows to get into in the country. Naturally, I knew my odds were slim and indeed I too was rejected.

I too am not upset about the process or results but part of the problem is that jury processes rarely provide feedback so that you know the basic reason for rejection. So that leaves you guessing.

I believe that both galleries and the shows like the one I tried for want a variety of work. So they might only create a slot or two for wood turning. So really, you are not competing for a place in the entire gallery show but actually competing for just the one or two slots they allocated for turning. So, if several other turners juried for the show, the odds may have been slimmer than you think.

Tom

Re: Denied

#4

Steven Antonucci

Why do you think you were "denied"?

steve antonucci

>Rejection is hard. Some people take it personally. Some look at it as character building. Either way, you still need to know "why" you were rejected to have a better chance next time.

If it were me, I'd contact them, and in a very professional manner, ask them to provide feedback as to why you didn't make it. They may not give it, but at least you asked for it. They may give it, and it may not be what you want to hear. Either way, you need to listen, absorb, and decide if you are willing to take criticism to make changes and get in next year. If you aren't willing to compromise your work, you need to find a show that looks for it.

This is the choice that we all need to make when we put ourselves "out there" for public opinion. I was recently juried into one show, and rejected from another. Can't please all of the people all of the time.

Steven

Re: Denied

#5

Re: Denied

Rick Davenport

>A few months ago I got some good advice from a gallery owner about the jury process:

"Don't expect much and you won't be disappointed."

You never know what criteria a jury uses and knowing after the fact doesn't help because the jury will be made up of different people next year.

I have found that selling "art" is a lot like hitting a baseball.

If you can get 3 out of 10 people to even look at your stuff it's a success.

Personally Ray, I think your stuff deserves to be in any show I've ever attended.

Too bad I'm not a juror, eh?

R

Re: Denied

#6

Re: Denied *LINK*

Keith Newton, LR, Arkansas------WebKitFormBoundary

>Ray, There is a lot that I like about your work, but it looks like you finish has a rough texture, and could benefit from some rubbing out. Maybe it is just the photo giving that appearance, but if that is the way it looks to me, maybe that is the impression that the juror got as well.

But on the other hand, I could not start to know by what aesthetic the jurors use. I submitted the piece in the link to a juried show, and was rejected. To add insult to that, the juror chose a work, which was only a sewing machine bobbin wrapped with hair, and with the hair threaded through a needle. That was given a pedestal and about 200 sq ft. of space. I regret that I am such a shallow individual that I could not appreciate the artistic value in that expression, even without the rejection. Maybe someday I will grow into a more complete person when I find higher enlightenment. ;-)


http://www.woodcentral.com/shots/shot728.shtml

Re: Denied

#7

Denied - But a lesson learned

Fog Tanner

>I lost interest in those when one of the judges was giving the reason for picking a particular piece. It was an average bowl, while well executed was not out of the ordinary and much like any other salad bowl. One of the judges was an "artist" (allegedly) in pottery, and was questioned about what set that piece apart from others which were truly more artistic pieces, Expecting some glowing answer about form and flowing lines which reached to the heavens, how the shape provided an inviting view of what lay within and the feeling of welcome - that you were drawn in to explore what lay beyond the rim....Instead, the only reason that could be given was some dribble about the wood speaking to her. I pretty much quit listening at that point as I find it difficult to deal with people that talk to inanimate objects, like office furniture, lumps of clay, and dead pieces of wood....

Your piece looks well executed and most interesting, I cannot see why you were excluded - unless it just wasn't talkative on that day. But, at least your lesson only cost you $30, but for $30 I would still expect some explanation if it is to be a learning experience.

The best juried show for me is the one where the judge pays me. It is more gratifying to me to have someone value a piece enough to buy it. That opinion to me is more valuable becuase they have found some joy in it and are wanting to take the piece and care for it. Or they think enough of it to give as a gift, with the intent of bringing happiness to someone else. 100 other "judges" may pass it by, but then that one will find something about the work that they embrace. It becomes an exchange of life, you each exchange a part of your life with the other. They give you money which is a result of their time on a job, and you give them something which you spent part of your life in creating. This is far greater meaning than a few words about some conversation with a dead piece of wood....

Fog

Re: Denied

#8

Re: Denied

Molly Winton

>Keith, your example is exactly why you should NEVER take a juror's rejection personally. I have to admit I'm also a little artistically dense, because I don't see the artistic value and depth of a bobbin wound with hair either, especially in comparison to your desk. Go figure. We, as artists, never know what is in the mind of a juror(s). We don't know what vision they have for their show/exhibit, and we have no idea how long they have to visually assess a digital or slide submission (10 seconds, 30 seconds, 2 minutes??).

I usually figure it's worth a shot, and at best is a crap shoot. I'm happy if my piece gets accepted, and move on if it doesn't. No harm, no foul.

Re: Denied

#9

Re: Denied

jim miles- Charlotte

>Raymond:

Been turned down for some of the best shows in the country.

( and got in a few )

A few conclusions:

Most jurors know little about wood or turning

Their selection is not on the quality or difficulty of the turning.

The more "artsy" it is the most they like it

As someone mentioned, they probably see dozens of images in a short time and it all looks the same to them

Different always attracts more attention

Don't consider the rejection an evaluation of your work, but instead it did'nt fit the pre-conceived criteria of what they wanted to display in the gallery Good luck, keep trying.

Re: Denied

#10

Re: Denied

Barry Elder

>Raymond, there are probably a thousand rejections for every acceptance. That's the way it is.

Keith, it looks to my inexperienced eye like the judge that rejected your beautiful piece of useful furniture had in their mind that they were looking for an "artsy" piece of "whimsy". It's all a shot in the dark with an unloaded weapon!

Re: Denied

#11

Re: Denied

Raymond Overman in SC

>First off, thank you for replying to my post and giving your opinions about the jury process and why some pieces are accepted and some are not. I appreciate the feedback.

However, I'm well aware that if only 30 pieces could be selected for this particular show, and 206 pieces are submitted, then 176 pieces had to be eliminated. That's pretty easy to accept. I understand that the juror could not select every piece and that the selection process was objective based on his criteria alone. My pieces didn't fit his criteria. I'm OK with that and I was not looking for a boost to my self esteem, a critique on my ability, or whether the selected pieces were good enough with my original post. The pieces are what they are, and currently, I'm happy with them as representative of my work.

What I was looking for was some ideas about how other people perceive juried competitions/shows like this and what are they willing to pay for the experience? Do you enter or avoid these type events? Is $30 a reasonable amount to expect for a jury fee when submitting two pieces? Do you submit to the show again and again if you are rejected the first time?

Re: Denied

#12

Re: Denied

Thom Sayles

>This was an interesting thread to read but is everyone responding here just ignoring the elephant in the room? I looked at the pieces, hard, and I don't like them. But how can I tell the artist in a kind way why I don't like them so that he receives comments that can get him to look at them with new eyes and possibly improve his skills? So here goes....

Like one person says the finish looks flat or quickly applied. Perhaps more sanding and experimenting with other finishes would help.

The forms are not pleasing to my eye. I prefer upright orientations. The attachments seem stuck on and not integrated into the piece (finials that is). Maybe set the finials into a recess.

The leg designs do not match the style of the main body. Try different shapes and see what it looks like.

The suggestions are made to help spur new ideas and are not meant to hurt. Perhaps this is not the place for helpful hints and I hope they are taken in the spirit of help rather than criticism.

Re: Denied

#13

Re: Denied

Raymond Overman in SC

>Thom,

I get it. I read that the finish wasn't up to Keith's standards earlier and obviously the pieces weren't up to the juror's standards or I would have been accepted. I've read your post three times now and will take the points you made into account but I didn't ask for a critique, I didn't ask why it wasn't accepted and I didn't ask whether you liked them or not.

I don't think anyone stepped around telling me they didn't like the pieces or that the finish wasn't up to their standards. They did tell me those things and I appreciate the suggestions.

Elephant in the room or not, what hasn't been said is the answer to the questions in my first and second post. How do you qualify your submittal to galleries when it comes to juried shows and entry fees? How much are you willing to pay for a critique when you can obviously get them for free here? Are you willing to submit to the same show over and over again with new pieces even if you're rejected?

Sorry if this sounds a little brash but I thought I made it clear that I accepted that the pieces weren't selected and that the whys were something that I was looking at. It's fine if you add your critique. I can take the criticism but please look at the questions too.

Re: Denied

#14

Steven Antonucci

Some more thoughts-

steve antonucci

>I saw the elephant too, but wanted to try to offer constructive advice.

So to try to answer your question(s):

For someone to be able to get better, we need to have an objective outlet on the work we produce. We all know other turners who can provide an opinion/critique/attaboy from time to time. I think that the value of a juried show is simple: it's marketing.

When you truly wish to present yourself for sale through your work, the value of your work will greatly increase as your resume progresses. Assume that if you had a name that was well known, you could be juried in anywhere with almost anything. Names draw attendence to the show. So the jury must balance between name/unknown (or no unknowns will submit), wood vs non wood, etc.

Every show that you get juried into builds this resume. If you get into enough of them, it will stop being "hard" to get accepted. It has very little to do with quality, since lots of stuff that gets into juried shows seems to be "average".

Think of it as a "certification". In my world, people who are certified make more money than people who aren't. They may be smarter, or they may not be very good at all. Having the certification means $$$ in their pocket. So does being accepted into a juried show.

If I was serious about the work, and I thought the show understood "wood", I'd reapply. Go and see what made it in, and if you think it makes no sense, find another show.

Or just be happy in producing stuff that you enjoy making.

Hope that answers at least some of your original question.

Steven

Re: Denied

#15

Re: Denied

john lucas

>Raymond I'll describe how some of the photo shows come about and maybe that will answer at least part of your question. some of the shows are there purely for the money making. They charge $15 to $25 for submissions and give away enough money to make it sound good but in reality they make their money on the submission fees and that's all the show is about, not promoting photographers. I'm not saying all the wood shows do that or even all photo shows but it does happen a lot. Not all shows are of the caliber that kevin Wallace or Terry Martin put on.

so then you have to ask yourself, will this show give me enough publicity if I get in to be worth the entry fee. Forget the possibility of winning a prize even though that does exist, it's like playing the lottery. I sort of look at it, can I afford to throw away that fee. Kind of like when you go to a Casino. You decide up front how much money to throw away and then it doesn't bother you when it's gone. If so then I'll enter. If I get in then it might pay off

I read the submission criteria very closely to make sure my piece at least stands a chance and then I decide if I can afford their fee. Now I'm talking about juried exhibitions here not craft fairs. Craft fair entries are totally different.

As far as honest critic's. We don't really get them here. You have to have someone from outside the media look at the work and compare it to other work of other media. I got seriously shot down once by a well known juror when I had a piece in a multimedia show. When I got home and looked at it closer he was right, or at least partly right. What opened up my eyes was that even if he was wrong it was his opinion, he looked at from a standpoint of does this piece work, not from man I did a good job hiding the joinery or the finish is great, etc.

Re: Denied

#16

Re: Denied

Rick Davenport

>Thom, you hit the nail right on the head.

"The forms are not pleasing to my eye. I prefer upright orientations."

You, and everyone else on this planet, has his/her own set of preferences and biases.

Therefore there is no such thing as an objective opinion on art in any medium.

Therefore one should never take criticism personally.

The only really important critique is your own and possibly the person who is willing to shell out money for your work.

Back to the subject of the thread:

I paid $12 to enter my piece in the Edmonds Arts Festival juried competition.

A whole lot of people attend this show every year, it is a relatively prestigious Art event, it's in my home town and I want to get my name out there in the local art community.

In other words it was a no-brainer for me.

I had no expectations because I had no idea what the jurors were looking for.

My only disappointment if I had not been accepted was that thousands of people wouldn't have walked by a piece I made.

R

Re: Denied

#17

Re: Denied

Russ Fairfield

>There is some truth in everything that everyone has said about juried shows. I have been on both sides of the issue, and can offer some insight from the "other side". Juried shows can be a "crapshoot" but there are a few things you can do to improve your odds.

The photo is the most important part of your application. The photo has to "speak" to the juror. With no more than a few seconds to look at each photo, they become a blurr. Your photo has to be one of those that makes the juror pause. If they pause, you have made the cut. It's that simple.

Don't expect a lot from asking why you were rejected. "It spoke to me" is an artistic way of saying that I had looked at 2000 slides that night, this was one of those that jumped out at me from a sea of photographs that all looked alike, and I don't have the slightest idea why I chose this one.

It is not unusual to discover later that the work is not up to the same quality as shown in the photo, or that the work is much better than the photo.

Every show has its own "character", or you can call it style or theme. Visit a show before you enter, and try to make your entry fit into that character. Enter this one again next year. You already know what not to enter, and that is valuable knowledge. Visit the show, spend some time there, see what styles of work were accepted, and make something that better fits the "character" of the exhibit nexr year.

Look at the name (or names) of the jurors. Often it is the same committee from the sponsoring group. Sometimes it is an outside artist. It is unusual for an unknown juror to be making the selection. These people have a "name< and they have their own medium, style, and preferrences. Do a little research, and play to your audience. Show them something they like to see.

We do this all the time, often subconsiously. We make stuff that will be noticed or liked by whoever is doing the commentary on the Instant Gallery, whether it be at our local club or the AAW Symposium. Do the same thing for the show.

It helps to make your work known by the jury pool. Join the local art guild. Enter in as many of the shows as possible. We always say that the jury doesn't know our names, but they can recognize a familiar piece of art, and that helps. You will also become acquainted with the jurors, and that also helps.

Re: Denied

#18

Keith Tompkins

Re: Denied

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Raymond, I'll give my two cents.....An established show will have a following, and many of the same artists will apply to it each year. Many of the artists are already associated with the gallery hosting the show, and their work is a known commodity. That gives them a leg up on the competition. For you to compete, your images will need to stand out from the crowd, and the pieces represented must stand out as well. When your image is flashed before the jurors, the response from the jurors must be an immediate, unanimous "YES!" These people see lots of work from artists in all fields, and it takes a lot to impress them. Think of a championship boxing match....if you don't knock the champion out, no matter how well you do....you lose.

Chose your shows well, investigate as well as you can. Attend as many such shows as possible; and analyse your work in comparison to the pieces featured in the show. Make an honest assesment, and be willing to improve in weak areas....If you are unsure, ask a known turner (or other well-versed artist) for an honest evaluation of your work. BTW, don't forget the AAW instant gallery, esp. at the national level. A critique can lead to big things.

I think the juried shows are crucial if you intend to pursue a turning career....establishing an identity for yourself is critical.

You will get rejections, that's an unavoidable part of the game. However, when you receive your first acceptance, the joy will erase all the disappointments. Each acceptance will help build your confidence, and will lead to bigger and better things. Eventually, you may be invited to participate in exhibitions...IMO, these are the better shows, and may result in having your work published, speaking engagements, etc.

Personally, I have entered many competitions and juried shows, and they have all been helpful. My work has been published in several magazines; almost all the result of my participation in a show. Still, the rejections are hard to swallow.

Imagine you are invited to show your work in an art museum exhibit...what work would you produce for that special show? I suggest taking that approach to every show you enter.

`

Re: Denied

#19

Re: Denied

Thom Sayles

>Oops, I went back and reread the orginal questions asked and I see that they pertained to why rejection to juried shows happens and others experiences with this event. I looked at the pictures and critiqued the pieces. I apologize.

I have been juried for sales events but not for shows. I have brought turned objects to AAW chapter meetings for show and tell. I watch WOW critiques. Often I feel that no constructive and well meant criticism is given that would spur growth in the turner. Just smiles and pats on the back. Yes that is needed and nice to receive but I guess I feel that I want something that will make me a better turner. Often I feel that a helpful suggestion would spark me to new heights. I know I would be initially hurt but if done right I could reflect and maybe incorporate new things in my work.

I missed the boat on the question and will read more carefully before I shoot the messenger.