Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

OT-Outdoor Wood Boiler

Posts

OT-Outdoor Wood Boiler

#1

OT-Outdoor Wood Boiler

George Van

>Are there any WC'ers presently using an outdoor wood boiler? I am in the consideration/shopping process as an addition to my propane/hydronic heating system for the shop and home. Any advice will be welcomed.

Re: OT-Outdoor Wood Boiler

#2

Re: OT-Outdoor Wood Boiler

Kenneth Riedel

>I have a friend who had the same system you are describing for heating both his house and shop with hydronic heat. He recently sold the unit because of his age, since it is hard to handle large pieces of wood. Putting in several large pieces of wood at nighttime would keep both his house and shop warm until morning without refueling. The system worked very well for him, here in Michigan.

I have a wood burning stove, and personally, I find it hard to throw pieces of wood in the fire when I could make something nice on the lathe with them.

Re: OT-Outdoor Wood Boiler

#3

Re: OT-Outdoor Wood Boiler

Brent English

>In my other life I consult in energy efficiency and renewable energy. Hands-down probably the best system for residential and shop scale outdoor wood boilers is sold by a company named Greenwood:

http://www.greenwoodfurnace.com/x1_GreenwoodInquiry.php

All the outdoor wood boilers work, but most are smokey and ineffecient (regardless of their advertising). This company's design is the most efficient with the least amount of emissions.

Disclaimer: I am NOT affliated with the company in any way.

Re: OT-Outdoor Wood Boiler

#4

Re: OT-Outdoor Wood Boiler

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>George, we have heated our 200 year old stone farmhouse for the past three winters with a Heatmor outdoor wood furnace. I have the tubing run to the shop, but do not have it installed yet.

We looked at a number of different styles and settled on the Heatmor for several reasons. First, it has a forced draft, which allows it to come up to heat faster. That also makes two other things possible. One is the removal of ash from below the firebox. That is a lot faster and easier than having to rake the live coals to one side and shovel the ash out while standing in front of the open door. Second, with the addition of a coal grate, we can burn coal if we need or want to. Finally, the design of the Heatmor, with the grate and an "open" bottom means that there is no fire continually sitting on a stainless steel bottom. The bottom of the unit is the cast iron grate surrounded by sand.

It is a lot of work. Some people warned me that I would be spending a lot of time cutting wood and feeding the furnace. They were right. Of course, I already knew that, and I was not surprised. I call it "exercise". It is exercise of a very rewarding kind. Not only do I get to spend time out in the fresh air, I get to save (and I am not exaggerating here) close to $200/week in fuel oil costs. That is how much fuel a drafty old stone house requires to maintain a modest 64� during the day and 58� overnight.

When the furnace is loaded properly, there is very little smoke. Damped down, there is a very wispy trickle of smoke from the stack. Burning full blast with the right mix of wood (size, amount, dampness, etc) there is virtually no smoke at all, just heat vapor coming from the stack. It is a little smoky when first loaded for a burn cycle, but that is not bad at all, usually no worse than most peoples' wood stoves. Achieving the proper load is not really that difficult, but it does take a little practice and experience.

Big stuff burns best, and I save the big stuff for overnight. A fully loaded stove will keep the house warm for a good 12 hours in very cold weather. In warmer weather it can go as long as 16 hours. During the day, since I work here at home, I burn the smaller stuff, and load the stove with smaller loads more frequently, say every three or four hours, depending on what I am burning and the current temperature. It only gets smoky if I put too much small stuff in at one time. Then it burns too fast, and sends a lot of smoke right up the stack. Not only is that annoying to anyone downwind, it is wasteful, since burning the smoke itself gives you a lot of your heat energy. Sending it up the stack is just like throwing money or work away.

These units get a bad rap from a lot of people because of the people who buy them and think they are a magic bullet to their heating woes. They aren't interested in the work to feed the stove, or the time it takes to maintain it. They don't take the time to process their wood properly, mix it right, or keep the stove in proper order. Actually, maintaining the stove does not take a lot of work at all, and cutting the wood for it involves less work than for a conventional wood stove, since it does not have to be cut nearly as small. I can stick pieces up to 36" long into my furnace, and anything that will fit through the 18" x 20" door.

I have two neighbors, people who live within two or three miles of me, who have these stoves. One guy has a Central Boiler unit. I did not care for that design as it will not burn coal, has a natural draft, and the life is probably going to be shorter from the fire sitting on steel. He also has to shovel the ash out the front door. But, he maintains it and loads it properly, and his smoke is no worse than mine. Then there is the other guy. He was shut down by the township for burning carpet scraps to heat his house! There is also a guy about 10 miles from me who does absolutely nothing to maintain his unit, and all the neighbors hate it. Every time it kicks on, huge clouds of smoke come billowing out, sink down to ground level, and spread out for the neighbors to breathe.

But used properly, I think they are one of the best alternatives to oil, gas, or electric heat. Ours will also burn coal. It does not burn it well, but it will do it, and it is nice to have a couple tons of coal in reserve in case snow or ice keeps me from getting to my reserve woodpile. When I write it does not do it well, I mean it is a lot more work. When I am burning wood, I need to shake the ashes about once a month. Burning coal, I shake the ashes two to three times a day! And there is a lot more work in keeping it burning properly. We have it pumped through our regular oil burner as well. If I am out of town, sick, injured, or whatever, all we have to do is move a couple of switches and we are heating with oil. We use this option with the big storms. Instead of slogging out to the furnace (which is over 100' from the house) in a nor'easter, when the fire gets low, we switch to oil. When the storm is over, we shovel out, restart the fire, and shut the oil burner down again.

The system uses less than 10 amps of electrical current for the furnace, the pump, and the oil burner. I put all those circuits on a switchbox for generator, so if the power goes out, we can continue to heat the house. We got to use that feature this year in one of the bad ice storms. As long as I have gasoline for the generator, we can stay warm. The unit also heats my domestic hot water. We get more water faster and hotter than with the oil burner. If oil continues to climb (and it probably will) I may go to burning it year round and keeping a tank of oil for emergency only, the same way I do the coal. It will burn any wood that can fit in the door. Some burns better than others, but it all burns. If you get a chimney fire, so what? It is all outside, and will usually burn itself out harmlessly. At the very least, the house is protected. All the dirt and mess associated with tracking snow and ice and log chips into the house is a thing of the past as well.

I have tried to be as complete as possible. If you have any other questions I might have missed, let me know and I will try to answer them for you.

Bill

Re: OT-Outdoor Wood Boiler

#5

Re: OT-Outdoor Wood Boiler

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Kenneth, I often say that if people could see what I was throwing into the furnace, they would be at the house with torches and pitchforks! But then, they don't see the private stock turning wood either!

Bill

Re: OT-Outdoor Wood Boiler

#6

Re: OT-Outdoor Wood Boiler

John K Jordan

>A high-end woodworking shop near here uses one to heat water which circulates in the concrete flooring. He said it keeps the large shop (150'x60' I think) comfortable around 70F all winter with very little effort and almost no smoke. There is no wood splitting involved - he feeds it large log sections. He installed it outside under a shed roof.

Sorry, I don't know the brand but if you want I can check the next time I'm out that way.

JKJ

Re: OT-Outdoor Wood Boiler

#7

Re: OT-Outdoor Wood Boiler

George Van

>Thanks for taking the time to respond. I have been marking trees for next winters harvest before the leaves come out and the job gets a lot more difficult.

Ken, I have the same feelings but when the wood warms the house and I have over 40 full cords of wood in backup the feeling is lessening. The good stuff is for turning or shipping to the mill. I do wonder if I will want to do this when I am in my 70�s but I have a ways to go.

Brent, I have Greenwood's literature, i like the low water storage and the stated efficiency. I wish they were closer to Wisconsin for freight.

Bill, I think you covered all the bases. I am used to the work. We presently heat the house with wood and the shop with propane. Both the house and shop have hydronic in floor systems so the outdoor boilers seem a good choice for saving some dollars. I like your idea of a backup power supply. I will group my electrical also so I can do the same.

John, that is encouraging, if they can heat a shop that size and be happy my needs should be simple.