Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Favorite hollowing tool for small stuff?

Posts

Favorite hollowing tool for small stuff?

#1

Favorite hollowing tool for small stuff?

Kris Lasure

>Good morning fellas,

I'm still fairly new to the world of turning (you guys weren't kidding about the addiction!) and I'm looking for my first hollowing tool. Mainly for small things like boxes, goblets and so forth.

I've looked at the Termite, Sorby tools, and Hunter, but I'd like to see what you guys and gals are using for such things. I'm not looking for a hollowing rig as I'm only using the Jet mini at this time.

kl

Re: Favorite hollowing tool for small stuff?

#2

Steven Antonucci

How small and how deep?

steve antonucci

>I turn lots and lots of hollowforms (ask my wife...)

I make tools for hollowing from tool steel I get from Enco. Costs about $2-3 depending upon the thickness, and I can get 4-6 tools from it.

If you are at all handy, you can easily make a hook tool from the same stock with a MAPP torch, a vise, and a hammer. Hook tools cut very cleanly, and my homemade attempts have been very successful.

All depends on what I am cutting and such, but I use mostly shop made tools except gouges...

Steven

Re: Favorite hollowing tool for small stuff?

#3

Re: How small and how deep?

Kris Lasure

>I was given a turning lesson from a staff member from MASW and he used a homemade hook tool like you describe. Although I don't remember what size stock he used. If you wouldn't mind sharing what you use and possibly a picture, I'd be very interested in that.

Thanks Steve

Re: Favorite hollowing tool for small stuff?

#5

Steven Antonucci

I have a "multi-use" boring bar...

steve antonucci

>I started out with an Ellsworth style boring bar. It was a piece of 5/8" cold rolled from Home Depot. David CA glues his cutters, but I decided to tap a set screw into mine in case I needed to remove the cutter.

Last year, I watched Andre Martel cut with a hook tool, and decided to give one a try. At $40 a pop, I figured it would be worth the shot to try to make one first from some scrap before I went nuts and bought one. Here's what I did:

The hole in my boring bar is set up for a 1/4" cutter, so I took a 1/4" O1 cut-off I had laying round. Holding it in vise grips, I heat the end to a bright orange glow with a MAPP torch (1-2 min.). With the biggest hammer you own, flatten about 3/4" inch to 1/16"-1/8" thick. Cool it with lots of water.

I use a belt sander to flatten the two sides of the hammered area. Use an old belt. Don't worry about bluing the steel, since it's going back under the torch. I also grind the primary bevel on the INSIDE or righthand side of the flat. Cool with water again.

If you have a metal vise (also my anvil), hold the bit in the vise. Reheat the flat to glowing. Using the vise grips, bend a hook of your liking. Mine are U to C shaped. With the metal still glowing, remove from vise with vise grips and quench in oil to harden. I use mineral oil in a metal container because it's clear and I can see the hook. Do this outside, and let the oil cool if you are making "lots" of these or you risk a fire. One hook won't be a problem.

When it is sufficiently cool, I clean off the scale with a little brass brush and sharpen with a Dremel and a cone shaped stone. I hone with a diamond file inside and out. The things cut like mad in end grain.

I've attached a picture of the first one I made. I've made a few since, and each one gets a little better...

Steven


img

Re: Favorite hollowing tool for small stuff?

#6

Steven Antonucci

P.S. the second hole in the boring bar

steve antonucci

>is for mounting a cutter at 45 degrees...

Saves having to have a straight bar and a 45 degree bar...

Steven

P.S. I have also put a hook in at 45 degrees and it works surprisingly well inside of a hollowform...


img

Re: Favorite hollowing tool for small stuff?

#7

Re: I have a "multi-use" boring bar...

Bob Macgregor

>Steve,

Do you think the butt (smooth) end of a regular quarter-inch drill bit could be used to make these hooks?

BOB

Re: Favorite hollowing tool for small stuff?

#8

Steven Antonucci

I'd probably use the flute

steve antonucci

>If you have an old bit laying around, I'd try the fluted side. Snap it off to length in the vise, and then fire up the torch to heat the remaining flute. I assume that heating it will soften the metal again, but you might want to try "smahing" the heated end in the vise to see if it deforms. I'd hate to find out that it was still brittle by hitting a 1200+ degree glowing bit and having it shatter...

It shouldn't be a problem, but better safe than sorry...

Steven

Re: Favorite hollowing tool for small stuff?

#9

Re: Favorite hollowing tool for small stuff?

john lucas

>Kris It's fairly easy to make your own using drill rod. I'll be glad to describe how. I think I might even have an article on my computer at home but I'm not sure. I know I have one on heat treating.

Most turners started out using a round nose scraper to hollow boxes and goblets. It works fine. I grind about an inch down the left side to make it more user friendly for boxes and goblets.

I hollowed boxes for years with my spindle gouge or bowl gouge. I point the flute to the left and cut with the bottom edge going from the center out toward the edge. This is my most used hollowing tool for open vessels like goblets and boxes.

I'm rapidly becoming a fan of the Hunter tools for endgrain hollowing. You can get one with a handle or you do as Steve suggested and get the #1 cutter mounted on a 1/4" round bar and then mount this on a boring bar. They cut really well, hold an edge forever and if it gets dull just rotate the cutter a few degrees. I prefer the #4 for boxes and goblets. I mounted the tool in a wooden handle but you can buy it already mounted from Woodcraft.

Re: Favorite hollowing tool for small stuff?

#10

Re: Favorite hollowing tool for small stuff?

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>I like the Kelton mini hollowers for small hollow forms. I have been doing a lot of small lidded hollow forms lately and the Kelton's are great.

keithz

Re: Favorite hollowing tool for small stuff?

#11

Re: Favorite hollowing tool for small stuff?

robo hippy

>I don't think you can beat the Monster Hollowing system for ease of use and laser pointer. For smaller more open forms, I use the Eliminator. It is similar to the Hunter with the carbide discs, but the tool shaft is half round, with two 45 degree bevels on the bar. This keeps the cutter at a 45 degree angle which is best for cuts, as when held flat, they get grabby. The Super cut is also nice, and the cutters can be resharpened. The small Kelton cutters will do well also. If you can afford it, really, the Eliminator bars in the Monster Hollowing set up.

Robust hippy

Re: Favorite hollowing tool for small stuff?

#12

hollowing things with wide mouths

John K Jordan

>Kris,

I have the Termite, Sorby, and the Hunter tools. For hollowing end grain things with a wide mouth (boxes, goblets, etc), my favorite hands down is unconventional - a spear point scraper I made from an old flat scraper. It's made like a sharply pointed flat-bottom boat. Unlike some spear point scrapers with rounded bottoms, the flat bottom makes it very stable against the tool rest.

This thing hollows faster than anything I've ever tried! I often don't even bore a center hole, although that is good for judging depth. However, while I use it to remove the bulk of the material, a spear point scraper is not good for getting deep into a straight sided box and it's not at all good for creating a smooth surface.

I generally follow the spear point with another scraper, or lately, the Hunter tool. The Termite is nice but clogs up easily and is more prone to catches. The Hunter cuts just as quick or quicker, can't clog, and seems more forgiving to me. (I have not yet had a catch.)

For flat-sided boxes, my favorite finishing hollowing tool is a (Sorby?) box scraper, sometimes supported by a special box tool rest I got from Best Wood Tools. This little rest has a flat bar that reaches deep inside the box. For rounded boxes and goblets, I usually go with a scraper with a curve on the left side only. I use the box scraper or flat scraper to clean up a flat bottom.

I see you got several responses which assumed you wanted to make hollow FORMS, as opposed to hollowing boxes and goblets. Hollowing through a very small opening is an entirely different animal, requiring one of the small point hollowing systems mentioned.

JKJ

Re: Favorite hollowing tool for small stuff?

#13

Mike Stafford

Re: Favorite hollowing tool for small stuff?

Mike Stafford

>Like John, I use a spindle gouge or detail gouge with a shortened bevel for most of my rough hollowing. For those items where the sides are undercut severely I rough it out to approximate depth with the gouge and finish shaping with the Hunter tools using the swan neck and the straight versions for final shaping and finish cuts.

The Hunter leaves such a smooth surface that if my tool control is good I can start sanding at 220 or better. On really dense woods the Hunter will leave a near polished surface.

Re: Favorite hollowing tool for small stuff?

#14

This is why I like hanging out at WC...

Kris Lasure

>A lot of great advise! As you said John, I was looking for more hollowing of goblets and boxes at this time. But I know it won't be long and I'll be looking to do hollow forms. For now I guess I will start small and use my spindle gouge and go from there and keep working on my skills.

Thanks again for all the info. It's refreshing to come to a forum with such great knowledge and experience to learn from. I usually just lurk around the turning forum, but I'll chime in every now and then.

kl

Re: Favorite hollowing tool for small stuff?

#15

Picture?

wilbur

>Do you have a picture of your spear point scraper?