Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Filling up a crack

Posts

Filling up a crack

#1

Filling up a crack

Ilya Zavorin

>This is actually a follow-up to the thread "Need advice on finish" that I started a couple of days ago. Thanks to everyone for their advice. It turned out, however, that CA glue did not penetrate as much as I thought it did, so I was able to sand away its stains. Everything was going great and it was time to reverse-chuck the bowl and finish the bottom. I applied just a bit too much pressure with the tail stock and - BAM! - the bowl cracked on one side. The crack (actually two) went almost all the way to the bottom and to one side. Bummer! Following Bill Neddow's advice, I will try to recover from my mistake. I want to fill the crack with something dark to contrast with the rest of the bowl. Someone had suggested coffee grinds + epoxy. I've never used epoxy, the only glue I've used for my turnings was CA. My 1st question is: Why grinds + epoxy and not grinds + epoxy? My 2nd question: Can you recommend any other suitable fillers? Thanks much.


img

Re: Filling up a crack

#2

Re: Filling up a crack

Ron McKinley

>Not sure what your first question is: "Why grinds + epoxy and not grinds + epoxy?"

Coffee grounds, used and dry, mixed with epoxy makes an excellent filler and can look like part of the grain. Another suggestion is Inlace. That's a colored expoxy-like substance that comes in a number of colors and textures. Post a picture of your results.....Ron

Re: Filling up a crack

#3

Re: Filling up a crack

GaryG in MD

>Ilya,

Looking on the bright side, I'm guessing that this crack would eventually have opened up anyway -- you just speeded it up a bit.

Many people use coffee grounds with CA. It works well. You can do it in several layers -- don't necessarily have to do it all at once. Per your previous answers, use a sealer coat over the wood first to keep the CA from wicking into the surface area around the crack.

There are many other possibilities for fillers, including saw dust, key filings, colored chalk, ground rock (turquoise), dyed epoxy, etc. It can be black or dark, or pick your color. Sometimes red or burgundy looks good too. These materials, and more, have all been discussed on WC at great length by many people in the past. Just look in the Archives.

You could also use this crack as an excuse to try some carving.

...Gary

Re: Filling up a crack

#4

Re: Filling up a crack

Ilya Zavorin

>Sorry, I mean "not grinds + CA"

Re: Filling up a crack

#5

Re: Filling up a crack

Ilya Zavorin

>Thanks Gary.

Re: Filling up a crack

#6

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Filling up a crack

Jesper, Denmark

>I do not want to burst your bubble, but this was doomed from the beginning. A bowl with the pith in the middle has to crack as the wood dries - there is no other way.

The big question now is whether it is done drying and shrinking? If not, any repair by filling out the crack will also fail.

Epoxy with some filler will be good - graphite makes a nice black. Maybe you need to let it sit in a warm place for some time and occasionally weigh it to make sure it has done drying before dioing anything.

Re: Filling up a crack

#7

Re: Filling up a crack

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>For big voids or cracks I use West System epoxy plus a filler. I really like West System as it has some flexibility and does not require any special measuring; you just push. I buy the small size as it will last me for years. Usually the filler is finely ground coffee. Depending upon how dark I want the fill I sometimes add the black pigment West System sells. Sometimes I will use the brass left overs from key making (yes I know they all are not brass but the brass predominates in the appearance).

Re: Filling up a crack

#8

Steven Antonucci

Agree.

steve antonucci

>Placing the pith in the middle is a challenge for sure. Most convention wisdom dictates that the pith needs to be removed to stabilize the overall form.

I understand your desire to "save" this, but having "saved" lots of work in my early days, I'm going to suggest something different. Rather than spend a bunch of time trying to make it look like something you meant to do, save the failure as an experimental piece. If you want to try burning, texturing, whatever, you've got a nice clean palette for experimenting.

Filling a void is one thing. Filling an accident is another. They always look like you filled an accident. I wouldn't spend a lot of time trying to recover this.

My 2 cents.

Steven

Re: Filling up a crack

#9

Agree, too

Bill Howatt

>While I am one of those people who feel that doing "fixes" is a good idea so you have an aresenal of rehearsed tools when you really want to save something so you could proceed on that basis. IMO, this piece will not look good when fixed and the nature of the cracks is that they may never really stabilize. I would use it for finishing, decorating and any other experiments.

The reason that you virtually never see pieces like this is for the very reason you found out the hard way - pith is always a problem. I have made goblets from not totally dry wood with the pith on the bottom but it is less likely to crack if the piece is turned in that orientation. Less, but certainly not never and it is out-of-sight.

Bill

Re: Filling up a crack

#10

Re: Filling up a crack

Allen Neighbors

>Ilya, I have a suggestion. Since some of the others have given you their ideas, as to fillers, and a chance for some other enhancements, I want to just add this little tidbit.

Since that bowl will probably continue to crack (with the pith in the side)... if it were mine: I'd drill a series of 5/64" holes, about 5/16" apart along both sides of the crack. Then I would lace it with baling wire, starting at the bottom of the crack, working out to the top of the bowl, and just twist the ends of the wire together with about 5 twists and bend the twisted end over. Don't pass out on me now. Baling wire will ultimately rust. And bowls repaired in this manner are selling like hotcakes right now. There will be a lot of questioning looks when people see it, and maybe some questions, but just tell them, "...yes. I wouldn't try using it for soup." It'll bring as much or more than an intact bowl.

Re: Filling up a crack

#11

Re: Filling up a crack

jared

>I have used some fine copper wire that I think I got at walmart. I just drilled a series of opposing holes on each side of the crack and the laced it up like a shoe. People think that it looks great and I like it too. Jared

Re: Filling up a crack

#12

not necessarily...

GaryG in MD

>Jesper,

I've seen a lot of nice "double bullseye" bowls and made one myself. They are not "doomed". It's just a matter of how you do it. I'll start a new thread on this later.

...Gary

Re: Filling up a crack

#13

i use model cement and ebony dust

robert davis

>

Re: Filling up a crack

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: Filling up a crack

Keith Tompkins

>ILya, This type of turning is flirting with disaster....the crack has weakened the turning to the point that it is ready to explode. I suggest using only sound pieces of wood, especially for newer turners.

If I lose a piece, I don't try to save it. The time spent could be used to make a newer, better piece, in my opinion.

Re: Filling up a crack

#15

Dick Hines

Re: Filling up a crack

Dick Hines

>If it was mine I would toss it in the burn bin. Even if you can get the crack filled with something I think it will look kind of strange.

Why don't you just turn another bowl the same shape ,which is good, but make sure the pith is not in the blank. And it will be good practic which we all can use.

I go along with Keith. You are going to spend a lot if time working on this one and still have a bowl with a chrack in the side.

Re: Filling up a crack

#16

Re: Filling up a crack

Ilya Zavorin

>Allen,

Thank you for the suggestion. I must admit, it is an unusual one. Which is great. Now I just want to understand it better. First, since I've never heard of baling wire, where do you get it? I checked Lowes and HDepot, but they don't seem to have it, at least "baling wire" search produced nothing. Second, when I thread the bowl, do I try to bring the two sides of the crack closer? It seems that I shouldn't since the wood might break. Is this correct? Also, do you happen to have any pictures of such a "threaded" bowl? I did a quick Google image search but found nothing. Thanks much.

Re: Filling up a crack

#17

Re: Filling up a crack

Gary in Zirconia,NC

>Baling wire was used to hold bales of hay together. About 50 years ago or so binder twine replaced it, so it may be difficult to find now. Any wire will work for your porpose that is small enough to bend well and large enough to look good. I am of the other opinion and would rather fill the crack. You must do what you like best, not me or anyone else.

Re: Filling up a crack

#18

Brad Vietje

Re: not necessarily...

Brad Vietje

>I will side with Gary -- with conditions.

To keep the pith in the wall of a bowl, you usually have to take additional precautions. There is no single rule that applies equally to all wood species -- some will crack much more often than others. Usually, you will want to make the walls very thin, so the pith will warp outward, and not crack. Otherwise, there are other techniques like partial turning and boiling before drying the wood, etc... A few beautiful examples are some of the bowls by Bert Marsh, and other turners.

However, the basic question about filling cracks started by telling us that the wood cracked from too much pressure applied when the bowl was reversed. I'd agree that this bowl was probably going to crack anyway, and that the cracks result from too much pressure, but not pressure applied by the turner, from pressures internal to the wood structure.

Now its time to apply creativity to end up with an attractive piece...

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT