Re: Sanding with PSA Vs Velcro disks questions
Greg Haugen
>Barry, this is a very good posting and it will be interesting to read the feedback. I have both of these options. IF, and only IF, you had a mandrel for each grit, in my opinion, would the PSA disks be worth it. With the exception that you're sanding enough to completely use up a disk in one use. Below are a few links that I've found for sanding disks. Depending if the PSA discs come in a "roll" or individual discs, if it's a roll they usually don't have a "protective" sheet on the adhesive and there is usually a few discs that will get dusty, etc. that turn into "hand sanding" discs. Also if there's a catch or for some reason the disc comes off during use, chances are it will be too dusty to stick again.
If your H&L mandrels are wearing out and your "melting" the hooks you're doing one of two things. The lathe is too fast or the drill is too fast. Slow it down. Speed is not a friend while sanding. Also you can make "extra" velcro pads easily and they're cheap. I've gone to Wal Mart in the craft section and bought the Industrial strenth velcro that's 2" wide (often it's black). I peel the paper off of the back, since it has an adhesive, and (if you're using a 2" mandrel) stick the Hook side together. If you're using a 3" pad you have to make a criss cross pattern with the to sides before stick them together to get the required 3" diameter. Then cut or stamp (a sharpened hole saw hammered through it) out the pads. For a $3-$4 you can make a dozen or more 2" or 6-8 or more 3" pads. Simply put these pads on the mandrel before attaching the discs. The pads will take the abuse, not the mandrel. Adds an extra layer of protection for the mandrel.
When it comes down to it, I prefer H&L. Shop around and you can get discs for basically the same price as PSA discs. Both will do the job though. It's personal preference.
http://www.supergrit.com/products/products_discs.asp They have alot of choices, excellent, prices and fast shipment. Both PSA and H&L discs and mandrels.
http://www.thesandingglove.com/ They carry multiple products and Bruce is a pleasure to do business with.
http://www.woodworkingshop.com/ This Klingspor's Woodworking Shop, top notch products and service.
Hope this helps,
Greg Haugen