Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Sanding with PSA Vs Velcro disks questions

Posts

Sanding with PSA Vs Velcro disks questions

#1

Sanding with PSA Vs Velcro disks questions

Barry Irby

>I was thinking of making or buying about six or eight sanding mandrels so that I could have a mandrel for each grit and then changing the mandrel in the drill rather than constantly changing the disk on the mandrel.

It seems to me that it is the Velcro that wears out. The little hooks wear off or fail from heat. The Velcro sandpaper is more expensive, but allows for you to swap it out often and use it until it wears out.

So, if you had a specific mandrel for each grit, you could use it until the paper wore out and then swap to fresh paper.

Also seems PSA paper would be easier to cut into disks if you wanted to make your own.

Is there some reason not to use PSA paper? Does it not work as well for some reason?

Re: Sanding with PSA Vs Velcro disks questions

#2

Re: Sanding with PSA Vs Velcro disks questions

Greg Haugen

>Barry, this is a very good posting and it will be interesting to read the feedback. I have both of these options. IF, and only IF, you had a mandrel for each grit, in my opinion, would the PSA disks be worth it. With the exception that you're sanding enough to completely use up a disk in one use. Below are a few links that I've found for sanding disks. Depending if the PSA discs come in a "roll" or individual discs, if it's a roll they usually don't have a "protective" sheet on the adhesive and there is usually a few discs that will get dusty, etc. that turn into "hand sanding" discs. Also if there's a catch or for some reason the disc comes off during use, chances are it will be too dusty to stick again.

If your H&L mandrels are wearing out and your "melting" the hooks you're doing one of two things. The lathe is too fast or the drill is too fast. Slow it down. Speed is not a friend while sanding. Also you can make "extra" velcro pads easily and they're cheap. I've gone to Wal Mart in the craft section and bought the Industrial strenth velcro that's 2" wide (often it's black). I peel the paper off of the back, since it has an adhesive, and (if you're using a 2" mandrel) stick the Hook side together. If you're using a 3" pad you have to make a criss cross pattern with the to sides before stick them together to get the required 3" diameter. Then cut or stamp (a sharpened hole saw hammered through it) out the pads. For a $3-$4 you can make a dozen or more 2" or 6-8 or more 3" pads. Simply put these pads on the mandrel before attaching the discs. The pads will take the abuse, not the mandrel. Adds an extra layer of protection for the mandrel.

When it comes down to it, I prefer H&L. Shop around and you can get discs for basically the same price as PSA discs. Both will do the job though. It's personal preference.

http://www.supergrit.com/products/products_discs.asp They have alot of choices, excellent, prices and fast shipment. Both PSA and H&L discs and mandrels.

http://www.thesandingglove.com/ They carry multiple products and Bruce is a pleasure to do business with.

http://www.woodworkingshop.com/ This Klingspor's Woodworking Shop, top notch products and service.

Hope this helps,

Greg Haugen

Re: Sanding with PSA Vs Velcro disks questions

#3

Ric Taylor

Re: Sanding with PSA Vs Velcro disks questions

Ric Taylor

>I've seen similar posts saying the velcro wears out or the hooks melt and wear out or the mandrel wears out. I don't understand any of those problems.

I've been using the same 2" sanding mandrel for about 8 years with no problems. When I bought it, I also bought a spare because I had heard of these problems, but I've never used the spare. There are never any issues with the velcro. The foam pad has tried to seperate a couple of times, but a few drops of CA fixed it just fine.

It has been exposed to lots various solvents and finishes, and it just keeps on doing its job.

I don't use the stick-on disks because the adhesive tends to pick up dust and chips, making them unusable when the sanding surface is still good. The hook 'n loop type are the only ones I use.

Ric

Re: Sanding with PSA Vs Velcro disks questions

#4

Steven Antonucci

Velcro 100%

steve antonucci

>If you are using your paper long enough to wear out the "fuzz", then you need to change habits. The pads are disposable.

As for the hooks, I've had sanding mandrels for years that still haven't worn out. The adhesive that holds them on the foam backing has given out, and I just use a little hot glue to reattach.

I can't imagine having all of those mandrels laying around? Switching mandrels would be a lot more work than pulling off a pad (and throwing it away when you are done with it). PSA disks are messy, and gum up the substrate after a few changes. I'll never use them again...

Steven

Re: Sanding with PSA Vs Velcro disks questions

#5

Re: Sanding with PSA Vs Velcro disks questions

robo hippy

>I have been using the hook and loop forever it seems. Recently, I have been thinking about the PSA (pressure sensitive adhesive) discs, specifically the purple ones that 3M makes because of durability. Mike Mahoney recomends them. The main reason that I don't use them now is because once you take them off the pad, they seem to be dust magnets, and won't stick back on the pad again. Of course, the shop is never dust proof. This is not a problem with some discs as you use them once, and they are done. With some of the newer abrasives, the discs can be good for a couple of bowls. I do use an interface pad, one that goes between the mandril and the disc. If I was to switch to the PSA discs, then I would need an interface pad for each grit. This wouldn't be too much of a hastle, so instead of changing out the disc each time, I would be changing out the pads. I wouldn't want to have to change out the mandril each time, too slow.

robo hippy

Re: Sanding with PSA Vs Velcro disks questions

#6

Re: Sanding with PSA Vs Velcro disks questions

George Van

>Barry, I use a mandrel for each grit for my Velcro backed paper. I believe I got the idea from Russ. I have used the disks heavily for three years and they are still good. I find it convenient not to have to change paper and search for it again later. I believe it may save the Velcro. I cannot argue which is faster but it seems very quick to me. I store the mandrels on a board with holes drilled in it, the shafts are stuck in the holes in grit order so they are organized and accessible easily.

I have not used PSA. Roloc are the other disks I use in a high speed grinder.

Re: Sanding with PSA Vs Velcro disks questions

#7

PSA Discs

Greg Haugen

>Robo,

Bruce Hoover, thesandingglove.com, sells those discs at a better price than the "usual suspects" suppliers (CS, Packard). I do believe he also has "conversion" pads so you could stick a velcro pad to the mandrel and then a PSA disc to that pad. They're rather cheap too I think. Mike's recommendation carries alot of weight with me. He's an incredible turner and nice guy. I still choose the H&L simply because I don't do the turning that Mike does anymore. But if you're interested in it check out Bruce's catalog. You may find a solution to use what you have with the PSA discs.

Hope it helps,

Greg H.

Re: Sanding with PSA Vs Velcro disks questions

#8

Re:I reorganized my sanding materials.....

Jamie Donaldson

>....last year because they were all over the workbench! I use mostly H&L now and save a lot of time and material cost with separate mandrels for each grit. Vince Welch has an intermediate pad that is easily replaced on each mandrel when/if the H&Ls wear down, and much less expensive than replacing the whole mandrel.


img

Re: Sanding with PSA Vs Velcro disks questions

#9

Re:I reorganized my sanding materials.....

gary s clarke

>Jamie, does Vince have a web site?

Re: Sanding with PSA Vs Velcro disks questions

#10

Thanks and.....

Barry Irby

>I was thinking I would buy mandrels that have hex shafts with the groove around them for the quick change snap coupler. Put the snap coupler in my drill and use that to change the mandrels quickly.

This seems to me to be a good set up. Have the mandrels sitting up in order of grit and organized. Whether you used PSA or Velcro, this would give the mandrel time to cool between grits. Even the the Velcro I use now has some tendency to collect dust and debris. I spend a certain amount of time picking the crap out of the fuzz before applying the disks. I try to stick the disks back into the drawer in my sanding cabinet, but is is one of the laws of physics that any errant particles will fly to those disks and permanently bind to the Velcro.

My mandrels are worn because I have been using them a long time, maybe three or four years and there have been times I got heavy handed with them. The universe has a way of getting even for heavy handedness.

Re: Sanding with PSA Vs Velcro disks questions

#11

Re:I reorganized my sanding materials.....

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>www.vinceswoodnwonders.com

Re: Sanding with PSA Vs Velcro disks questions

#12

Re:I reorganized my sanding materials.....

Bill Crommett

>I buy the H&L in rolls from Klingspoor. I do not round them of, but use a square piece which gives the same result as a flap edged disk.

Re: Sanding with PSA Vs Velcro disks questions

#13

Re: Thanks and.....

bowlman

>I have used the Snappy Quick Change collet in a dedicated angle head drill for some 20 years now. This solves the "takes too long to change to a new mandrel" problem. Like Jamies D. I use Vince's disks. I got some tilt front storage bins from Vince to organize the various grits and sizes. I won't say I love sanding, but I do love the results. I view it as another part of the turning addiction.

Re: Sanding with PSA Vs Velcro disks questions

#14

Re: Sanding with PSA Vs Velcro disks questions

Russ Fairfield

>I think the answer to your question on why or why not to use PSA paper will depend on how much heat you are generating while sanding. The heat relates to how fast you spin the disc, how fast you spin the wood, how much pressure you use, how long you run the disc without letting it cool down, and the ambient temperatuire in your shop.

I started using dedicated mandrels for each grit because repeated replacement of the sanding discs was wearing out the velcro and damaging the flannel on the back of the disc; and because it was a lot faster to change grits that way. It had nothing to do with heat or anything else.

I tried using PSA discs, but went back to Velcro because they are more flexible than the PSA discs, they stay on the mandrel better, they are less sensitive to heat, and they are easier to change.

You may have a different experience with the PSA discs.

Re: Sanding with PSA Vs Velcro disks questions

#15

Re: Sanding with PSA Vs Velcro disks questions

Steve Worcester

>You can easily replace the velcro for a lot less than buying a new mandrel for each grit. As Russ stated, heat is your enemy here.

What I would recommend is to use velcro without any backing and use solvent based contact cement to glue it on. The self adhesive velcro is less flexible and doesn't take the heat real well.

here is a small article on how to replace the velcro

http://www.turningwood.com/howtoo.htm

The PSA disks that Bruce sells are 3M ceramics. A good product, just more expensive than most care to spend for sandpaper. That and the issue with PSA in a dusty workshop. But he does sell the coinversion pads for PSA to hook and loop.

Steve Worcester

www.turningwood.com