Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Help With Threading

Posts

Help With Threading

#1

Help With Threading

Ron McKinley

>I asked a friend of mine if he could build a threading machine and he did and now I have it to try out. I sent him everything I could find including Jean Michel's and Al Crandall's machines. He did a great job. Problem is, neither of us knows how to use it!

Questions: Do you make a box with a friction fit lid and go from there?

Do you thread the inside of the lid first, then the tenon on the base?

Which side of the lid/base should the cutter be on? The near side (operator side)or the far side?

How thick should the tenon on the base be to start? I tried to thread one but got the tenon too thin to start so that didn't work.

How do you keep the same depth for the inside threads (lid) and the tenon on the base?

I notice that the cutter cuts really sharp threads. Should these be blunted a little with sandpaper?

Anything else I should know?

Thanks.......Ron


img

Re: Help With Threading

#2

Re: Help With Threading - ? 4 Al Crandel

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>Hmmm.... watching with interest, but the answer to the first question is "no".

Wish I had the proper terminology here. What is the 'peak' of the thread called, and what is the 'valley' of the thread called?

But I'll go with what I have...

The diameter of the peaks of the male threads should equal the diameter of the valleys of the female threads, or nearly so. If both diameters were the same, they wouldn't 'thread' on each other. It would be like having a nut too large for the bolt.

Re: Help With Threading

#3

Re: Help With Threading

john lucas

>Ron This will have to be brief because I have to get to work early today. First we need to know the size threads you are cutting. On my machine it is 16 threads per inch so the threads are .035" deep. That means you make your male tenon and then cut the threads. Then you make the female portion .035 smaller than the finished male theads. Cut this .035" deep and you should have threads that fit.

I talked to Vic from Bestwoodtools this weekend and he says that technically you need to go .005" deeper to make them fit but I've found this hasn't been necessary. In theory 2 threads the same size won't fit but there must be some slop or flex when machining wood because I haven't had a problem.

OK now your going to ask how to you determine this depth. With the Baxter threader you simply move the dial .035". With the homemade jig you have to determine the number of threads per inch on you crank handle and then move the handle far enough for the threads per inch calculation.

I touch the threads very lightly with 600 grit and then wax them. I noticed that Nick Cook left them just as the were. If you don't cut to the full depth the threads won't be pointed. You would need to adjust the opposite thread depth for this if you decide to go that route.

Do you cut male or female first. I don't think it matters. I've tried both. In fact I've cut the male first, then the female and then cut male threads on the leftover wood to hold the female threaded lid to further turn it seperatly from the box.

Which side of the opening do you cut the threads doesn't matter unless you don't have enough movement in your jig.

One other consideration is the box size. As the box gets bigger you can have wood movement problems with small threads so you might need to make larger threads and make the fit looser to allow for this. That is the biggest advantage of the Baxter threader. You can actually change the threadsize. Of course that adds another $119 dollars to the expense of the jig but that's what you get when you want the ultimate in quality and convenience.

Re: Help With Threading

#4

KIS

Ron in Drums PA

>I cut threads on the tenon first then measure the final dimension and then cut the motise.

If I'm using a threader that is16tpi I will subtract 1/16" from the tenon's dimension.

In other words, if my tenon measures 2", I will make the mortise 1-15/16".

Since I use a 20tpi threader it would figure that I would make the mortise 1-19/20", but since 1/16" is easier to read, and since .01" is really not that important, I still use 1/16".

I use the same method when tapping holes in metal, if I need 3/8"x12tpi, I will drill a hole that is 1/12" smaller than 3/8". Since I have all the fractional, lettered, numbered and decimal drills, it not hard to find the right drill bit.

Re: Help With Threading

#5

books

John K Jordan

>Ron,

If you like books, I have two that cover threaded boxes that I found useful:

"Turning Boxes" by Richard Raffan, and

"Making Screw Threads in Wood", by Fred Holder

JKJ

Re: Help With Threading

#6

Thanks to all

Ron McKinley

>Whew! Lot more to this than I thought!

I've got Raffan's book but not Fred Holder's. Back to the drawing board.......Ron

Re: Help With Threading

#7

Re: KIS

Stuart Johnson

>It seems to me cutting the mortise thread first is the better option. If you cut it first you can adjust the tenon to fit. If you cut the tenon first and then cut the mortise you don't have any option to adjust if you cut it too large. At least when doing flat work I chop the mortise and then fit the tenon.

Re: Help With Threading

#8

Re: KIS

Ron in Drums PA

>It's all in the way you feel most comfortable.

When I make boxes I make the tenon first then fit the lid with the mortise. I can get the lid to fit on the base on the second or third try. When the planets are all aligned I even get a good fit on the first try. I saw no reason to change when I started chasing threads.

Reducing the size of the mortise by 1/16" makes a tight fit. I can always sneak up to the size if needed by removing more wood with the thread chaser.

Re: Help With Threading

#9

Re: KIS

john lucas

>Ron The way you do it with the BAxter threader is to crank the cutter in until it just touches the work. Then dial in the .035". I don't see why you couldn't do exactly the same thing with your crank handle. It might take a little experimenting to see how many turns or parts of a turn to use but it would always be the same so once you figured it out it would be a simple solution.

Re: Help With Threading

#10

Re: Help With Threading *LINK*

Scott Blundell

>You might try this link from DIY network. Dave Hout did one and does a fair job of explaining the steps and required measurements for a good fit. He even explains how to match grain after you get the 2 pieces screwed together.


Dave Hout Threaded Box

Re: Help With Threading

#11

Re: KIS

Ron in Drums PA

>When you dial in .035 you are removing that much from just one side.

.035 + .035 = .07

1/16" = .0625

Sorry to have wasted your time and my time. It won't happen again.

Re: Help With Threading

#12

Re: Help With Threading *LINK*

Fred Holder

>Ron,

My book, "Making Screw Threads in Wood" will answer all of your questions. If you wish to contact me with specific questions, I'll try to answer them for you.


More Woodturning Website

Re: Help With Threading

#13

Re: Help With Threads (all I know about it, long)

Al Crandall -NW of Indy-

>Questions: Do you make a box with a friction fit lid and go from there?

No, you make the hole in the "nut" one thread pitch smaller than the "bolt". My jig uses 8 threads per inch pitch so I turn an interference fit of 1/8" between the two pieces. If your jig uses 16 tpi or 20 tpi, then you would use 1/16 or 1/20 inch smaller hole than bolt.

Do you thread the inside of the lid first, then the tenon on the base?

I thread mostly urns so there is a huge difference between the mass of the urn and the mass of the lid. I choose to cut the lid threads first so that I'm fussing with a smaller piece as I try to mate those freshly cut threads with the partially cut threads of the urn.

Which side of the lid/base should the cutter be on? The near side (operator side)or the far side?

It depends upon the design of your jig. My jig won't let me put the cutter on the back side of the jig centerline. All cutting is done on the front half of the jig. I can cut male threads in excess of 7" diameter. Female threads are limited on the small side by the cutter diameter, and on the large side by the male plug which gazinta it.

How thick should the tenon on the base be to start? I tried to thread one but got the tenon too thin to start so that didn't work.

Decide first how many threads you want when done, multiply by the thread pitch of your jig, add at least half the thickness of your cutter. This is minimum tenon length.

How do you keep the same depth for the inside threads (lid) and the tenon on the base?

First of all, the male threads can be on either the lid or the box, and so it follows that the female threads can also be on either the lid or the box. I cut female threads into the opening of my urns and put the "tenon" on the lid. This maximizes the volume of the urn while not compromizing the shape I want. As for keeping the same depth, it is not a critical dimension. It's wood after all. Start with the proper relationship between the male and female pieces, cut the first set of threads so that they don't quite make a sharp thread on the surface you started with, and then cut the second piece. Make multiple cuts until things fit like you want them to fit. Take a close look at any thread around you. The little flat on the exposed edge of the thread is there so that it can't get down into the sharp corner of the thread it mates to. No difference on male or female.

I notice that the cutter cuts really sharp threads. Should these be blunted a little with sandpaper?

I just covered this above. Don't cut your threads so deep that the top of the thread is sharp. Leave a little flat.

Anything else I should know?

God yes! You have to chamfer the leading edge of the male and the opening of the female threads before you take the pieces off the lathe and head to the threading jig. How much chamfer? More than the depth of the threads you will cut. What angle chamfer? More than the 30* which is on one side of your thread cutter. Why the chamfer? Because without it, there will be an area next to the spot where the jig completes the first full rotation (the first full thread) which has a lump of wood with a flat on it much wider than any of the flats you are leaving on top of the thread points. It will neither allow a properly formed male thread to pass by it, nor will it start into a properly formed female thread. If the female thread is going to fit all the way against a shoulder at the back end of the male, you will need to undercut the male at the shoulder and chamfer it like the leading edge was chamfered. Same reason as already given. There can be no flat on the top of the male threads which is wider than any place else on the threads. If the female threads are blind, there must be one full thread more than on the male, or else you will have the same condition at the back end which I just covered with the male threads which chased against a shoulder. Again the fix is an undercut and chamfer. This is another reason I choose to cut the female threads in the body of the urns. This way they are not blind or limited in depth and any length tenon on the lid will screw into them. It is also easy to go back and trim for grain alignment. Design critera will most often dictate where the male and female cuts are made.

If your threads fit nicely together, but bind up before fully engaged, you have a problem at the back end of either the male or female. You probably didn't undercut deep enough or the chamfer at the back end was the wrong angle and didn't remove enough wood. If the first time the pieces go together the fit is sloppy, then you probably left a lump of wood at the beginning of the cut which has a wider flat on top than the rest of the threads, or else you cut the second set of threads too aggressively and went past the thread depth you wanted. Sneak up on the proper fit when cutting the second set of threads in a mating pair.

Re: Help With Threading

#14

Re: Help With Threads (all I know about it, long)

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>Thanks, Al. Glad you popped in and I apologize for mangling the spelling of your name.

Naturally I copied your response and filed it in my notebook.

Re: Help With Threading

#15

Re: Help With Threads (all I know about it, long)

Ron McKinley

>Thanks Al. I'm trying to digest all that. At first I thought we had used the wrong rod with a pitch of 1" x 8tpi on the rod so it would conveniently mate with a 1" x 8tpi chuck but you say that's what you use.

Tomorrow I'm going to give it another go and see if I can get it to work. Thanks so much.....Ron

Re: Help With Threading

#16

Re: Help With Threading

Ron McKinley

>Thanks Fred. I'm one of your subscribers and enjoy it very much.....Ron