Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Tenon failure

Posts

Tenon failure

#1

Steven Antonucci

Tenon failure

steve antonucci

>I've had this burl laying on the woodpile for a while. Tonight, I fired up the chainsaw and processed it into a bunch of small pieces and one large one. I was going for a Southwestern shape, and I saw a small soft spot on the outside. I figured that it would either turn out, or I'd have a hole. The whole time I was shaping the outside, I noticed a slight wobble that wouldn't go away.

I had a good surface despite the wobble, and had just started hollowing when I had a minor catch. The next thing I see is my pot jammed between the toolresat and the ways.

Tenon failure.

Now, this tenon was at least 5" across, and it sheared in a split second. Why? Because dirt has no strength at all in shear. The entire thing was marginally still wood, and I was surprised that I had gotten that far without the thing failing. I stuck an awl clear through it.

So tomorrow, next day, whenever, I'll bandsaw this into 4-6 smaller blocks and wax them for some day. Life it too short to turn crappy wood :-)

Steven


img

Re: Tenon failure

#2

Steven Antonucci

tenon close up 

steve antonucci

>


img

Re: Tenon failure

#3

Steven Antonucci

top of the pot 

steve antonucci

>


img

Re: Tenon failure

#4

Re: top of the pot

Barry Turner

>I've glued those failed tenons back on with Titebond...........

Re: Tenon failure

#5

Steven Antonucci

No amount of glue would save this one

steve antonucci

>The tenon is made of dirt. The hole on the outside was soft, and it was dirt after that. I turned it down 2" after the photo with 2 "cuts"- and there was nothing but cherry colored dirt on the ways.

I really thought about it, but this one is now 4 smaller forms in the next day or so...

Steven

Re: Tenon failure

#6

make some art

John K Jordan

>Drill it out, embed rebar to hold the pieces together and let it stick out the top and bottom, spray it with something, and call it art.

JKJ

Re: Tenon failure

#7

Steven Antonucci

That would be, um, creative... :-)

steve antonucci

>I wonder if the other burl will be the same type of disappointment. I'm going to get about 6 little pieces out of this one, but I really had my heart set on the one bigger one...

Maybe the other burl will have a rebar embedded in it and I can design around it?

Steven

Re: Tenon failure

#8

Dick Hines

Re: That would be, um, creative... :-)

Dick Hines

>I have had this happen before. I try not to turn the piece down to finished thichness until I have hollowed out the inside. Just leave the bottom a tad thick and coat with thin CA. Then after you have hollowed out the piece turn the bottom to finial shape.

I have had good luck doing this." Most of the time"