Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

OT: Diesel in a gas engine

Posts

OT: Diesel in a gas engine

#1

Steven Antonucci

OT: Diesel in a gas engine

steve antonucci

>My MIL was unfortunate enough to get the "new kid" at the gas station, who pumped about 5 G of Diesel into her tank before the light when on. She tried to start the car, it sputter and shook like you'd expect, and died. It was towed to a local mechanic, and he drained the tank and supposedly "took apart the engine and cleaned it" ( I suspect he may have siphoned out the diesel and just filled the tank with gas.)

I've told her that the car will be fine, but has anyone else ever had this issue? Long term effects from 15 seconds worth of diesel? One mechanic is trying to get her fro a new engine, the other one is telling her the catalytic converter is shot, and another one is telling her to replace the whole car. It's a 10 year old Honda with 30K miles...

Trying to talk some common sense into her...

Steven

Re: OT: Diesel in a gas engine

#2

Direct experience...

Peter Teubel

>My mother goes to Florida every winter and stays with my sister, who has a RAV4. Same thing happened to her. She ended up with a FULL tank of diesel. They simply drained the tank, replaced all the filters, gave it a major tune-up (including fuel injector cleaning). Runs as good as before. No issues whatsoever. And that was 30k miles ago.

Now, if it was reversed (gasoline in a diesel engine), you'd probably have catastrophic engine failure (i.e. holes in the piston, bent/broken connecting rods, etc).

Re: OT: Diesel in a gas engine

#3

JL

Re: OT: Old Diesel versus "New" Diesel...

JL

>Older formulations of diesel would definitely do a number on the catalytic converter due to the sulfur content. Newer formulations (such as what's in the gas stations now) do not have the high sulfur content.

As far as "damaging" the engine? Not very likely. The engine "choked" off before any damage could take place. The mechanics are trying to scam her.

Diesel and gasoline are both petroleum byproducts. The only real difference is the number of carbons in the molecules (and the additives). She may want to "flush" the engine (and the gas tank) out with a tank or two of premium. She also may want a new fuel filter.

My $0.02.

Re: OT: Diesel in a gas engine

#4

Re: OT: Diesel in a gas engine

Stuart Johnson

>Steve, I don't understand what there is that needs to all the mechanical work and certainly not a new engine. It seems to me all that should be required is draining the diesel and refilling the tank. The spark plugs are probably fouled but they are easy to clean. I don't know about the catalytic converter if it were me I would run a couple of tanks of gas through it and if all runs well not worry about it. The next time it is due for a state inspection they will catch it if it does need a new one. I also wouldn't let the garage sell me an original factor one for two to three times the price of after market brands.

I really don't have anything to base it on but I think it might run rough for a bit (one tank) until the fuel injectors are cleaned but after that it should be fine.

Re: OT: Diesel in a gas engine

#5

Re: Direct experience...

Stuart Johnson

>Now, if it was reversed (gasoline in a diesel engine), you'd probably have catastrophic engine failure (i.e. holes in the piston, bent/broken connecting rods, etc).

We had a diesel VW Rabbit and my wife got a tank of gas one time. We always tried to drive on the top half of the tank so it wasn't a full tank but all it did was sputter and buck but she did make it home. I was traveling but the neighbor had a small garage. He took it to the shop and drained the tank and refilled with diesel and all was okay. The Rabbit was ugly, held together with duct tape and nylon rope, smoked and was loud but you couldn't kill it with a scud rocket.

Re: OT: Diesel in a gas engine

#6

Denis Putland

Re: OT: Diesel in a gas engine

Denis Putland

>Diesel will not harm a gas engine, if fact a little shot of diesel will some times help loosen up a bit of carbon etc. and improve the performance. It just will not run very well on a heavy mix of diesel:::)))

I am a farmer and on many occasions I will give a tank of gas to my friend or neighbor in return for a favor.

On more then one occasion they have mistaken my instructions and filled up from the diesel tank. The smoking engine of course told the tale and of course required the draining of the tank and refilling with absolutely no harm to the engines or system.

Denis

Denis

Re: OT: Diesel in a gas engine

#7

Re: OT: Diesel in a gas engine

Norm Smith

>Same thing happened to me. I went back to the garage, they drained the tank and refilled it with gas. Never had a problem after.

norm

Re: OT: Diesel in a gas engine

#8

Re: Aside from cleaning the injectors....

Jamie Donaldson

>... and fuel system filters, I would be most concerned about the catalytic converter and O2 sensors. If the car has to be tested for emissions there could be a residual effect, and 02 sensors on a 10 yr. old car are not as sensative as the current balanced systems that are so highly computer controlled.

Re: OT: Diesel in a gas engine

#9

Speaking of diesel Rabbits...

Peter Teubel

>My nephew used to work at a garage part time. Someone there decided to use starting fluid (ether) to get a balky Rabbit diesel running.

Not good...

He has the piston with the bent connecting rod on his desk to this day as a reminder of what NOT to do.

Re: OT: Diesel in a gas engine

#10

Steven Antonucci

Thanks all! I'll have my wife point my MIL here..

steve antonucci

>Should ease her mind.

Steven

Re: OT: Diesel in a gas engine

#11

I once saw...

Steven Kubien

>...a punk, hot-shot screaming into the station in the 911 Mom and Dad bought him. He was about 17 or 18. Set a land-speed record pulling up to the pump, and promptly put diesel in the tank. He went and paid for it, started the engine, revved it good and loud like teenagers will do (especially when their girlfriend is in the front seat), peeled out of the pumps and didn't make it to the road before it died, loudly. I would feel bad if it was my MIL, wife etc but for this guy, I could only laugh.

Steve, I know this is of little value to you or your MIL, but it still brings a dark smile to my face.

Good luck

Steve Kubien

Re: OT: Diesel in a gas engine

#12

Re: OT: Diesel in a gas engine

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

>Back in the 50's my friends would put 2 gals of gas and 2 gallons of kerosene in the tank to save money. Smoked like hell and ran sluggish but it ran. Of course they had old Ford Model A 4 cylinder cars. They would run with only 2 spark plugs also. If she wants too get rid of a 10 year old Honda with only 30 K on it, contact me first.

Re: OT: Diesel in a gas engine

#13

Steven Antonucci

Little old lady only driven on Sundays :-)

steve antonucci

>There would be a line out the door for the car. I'd bet it's never been over 50MPH, unless her only son, my BIL drove it. Then, it's been over 100 for sure (he's a cop...)

Garage kept, meticulous inside and out... I've parked it for her a few times, and I can't imagine driving in the position she drives in. If I were any more upright and closer to the winshield, I'd be sitting on the hood.

I'll reiterate to her this weekend to leave well enough alone.

Thanks

Steven

Re: OT: Diesel in a gas engine

#14

Steven Antonucci

Something about that makes me wish I had seen it

steve antonucci

>too...

Every kids first car should be at least as old as they are, and have fewer horsepower than their weight. Oh, yeah, and dents too. Rust spots optional.

A car payment shouldn't come until after your first accident, and after you graduate and are paying your own bills. An it should never look like a mortgage.

Steve

Re: OT: Diesel in a gas engine

#15

Theoretically it should be impossible

GolfSteve in Calgary

>Theoretically it should be impossible to put diesel in a gasoline engine at a proper service station.

Up here the diesel pump nozzle is a larger diameter than the gasoline pump nozzle. The car manufacturers put a limit the size of the hole on the gas tank inlet so that a diesel nozzle won't fit.

The reverse problem (gasoline in a diesel tank) is more likely because either nozzle will fit into the fuel fill line on a diesel powered vehicle.

Sorry I can't help you with your question...just made me wonder how the kid got the diesel into the tank - "When trying to make something fool-proof, never undestimate the ingenuity of complete fools."

Re: OT: Diesel in a gas engine

#16

Jesper, Denmark

Re: OT: Diesel in a gas engine

Jesper, Denmark

>This should be no big deal, once you replace the diesel in the tank with gasoline.

The other way - gasoline in a modern diesel engine - could spell disater. The highpressure diesel injector pump would get destroyed by the gas, as it relies on the lubricity od�f the diesel oil to live.

Re: OT: Diesel in a gas engine

#17

Steven Antonucci

Ah, yes, it's that way here too

steve antonucci

>I wasn't there, and so my information comes somewhat 3rd or 4th handed, but I heard that he spent a lot of time trying to figure it out (and tried to convince my MIL that there was somethign wrong with her gas tank) before giving in and cupping his hands around the nozzle.

It was his first day on the job, and if the owner is smart, his last as well...

Steven