Bowl turning and reaction wood
Aage Rendalen
>I picked up a load of hemlock today. Several trunk pieces (17-20" diameter)have a ratio of almost 2:1 between reaction wood and normal growth.
How would you deal with it, to slab cut it for bowls?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Bowl turning and reaction wood
Aage Rendalen
>I picked up a load of hemlock today. Several trunk pieces (17-20" diameter)have a ratio of almost 2:1 between reaction wood and normal growth.
How would you deal with it, to slab cut it for bowls?
I'd cut down the pith 1/3 and 2/3
steve antonucci
>Each side would be relatively even in tension, and I think you'll get somewhat predictable results. I cut a walnut like that and it worked out ok...
Steven
extreme reaction
John K Jordan
>I turned a piece of white oak that had the most extreme reaction wood I've seen. I just used the bottom part, about 1/2 of a piece similar to that in the picture.
BTW, I counted almost 100 rings in this limb (which had grown horizontally for 40 feet or so). The rings above the pith are pretty close together!
JKJ
Steve I'm confused
Ed Larson
>based on John's picture below would one cut be horizontal thru the pith and the other also horizontal thru the lower half below the pith?? Set my thinking straight.
Re: Steve I'm confused
John K Jordan
>>...set my thinking straight
Ed, I'm not Steve but in the case of the piece Aage described, I would cut out the pith horizontally and use both the larger section below and perhaps the smaller section above. The reaction wood in the picture I posted was pretty unusual, but you could use the entire lower section for a tall "face-grain" vessel or, since there is so much wood, make two horizontal cuts as you mentioned, enough for two conventional bowls.
At least that's my thinking, but the only thing straight about me is my, ah, "social" orientation.
JKJ
That's what I meant exactly
steve antonucci
>Since everything above the pith is in tension (all the same tension, more or less) and everything below the pith is in compression, what ever happens will happen throughout the piece relatively uniformly.
Honestly, it's wood like this that keeps me turning. The not knowing is so much more exciting that the knowing...
Steven
P.S. I would only cut it through the pith
steve antonucci
>I wouldn't make the second cut on the lower section (unless the first experiments were complete failures). Tall, deep with lots of horizontal grain...
John-
40' of that limb, you say? How much did you keep?
Steven
Re: P.S. I would only cut it through the pith
Ken
>Can't tell you how to cut it,but that looks like some beautifull grain pattern.As for oak,I have the worst luck with it,no matter how I cut and seal the blanks,that darn stuff splits on me.
Re: Bowl turning and reaction wood
Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin
>I've never turned hemlock, but the reaction wood in softwoods is compression wood as opposed to the tension reaction wood in hardwoods.
I'd cut it to isolate the two halves as Steve suggested. That gives blanks with the pith relatively centered in the middle of the blank face. This usually gives a more pleasing grain pattern in the bowl.
In my experience, hardwood reaction wood is a little harder to cut cleanly but often has some interesting wavy grain figure.
Thanks for the help
Ed Larson
>John, Steve, thanks for the help. I have cut logs like this vetically through the pith and now see the benifits of cutting horizontal. As for the Steve, John mixup I thought the response post would end up under Steves. Who knows under whos name this one will end up.