elbotool info.
joaz
>I just watched the utube video and it seemded very impressive. Anyone here have one or seen it in action. I'm drooling over the picture in Packard catalogue.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
elbotool info.
joaz
>I just watched the utube video and it seemded very impressive. Anyone here have one or seen it in action. I'm drooling over the picture in Packard catalogue.
Re: elbotool info. Reply - Long
Bill Clark
>Joaz, I've had one for about 6 months. There are pros and cons. The good points are it does make hollow form turning less stressful. However, I am still very comfortable with my Don Pencil set up. I can use all of my Don Pencil tool bars, cutters and scrapers with my Elbo Tool. Unlike the Pencil set up you do not have to hunch over the lathe to hold the tool. The Elbo Tool is much easier on your body. It works smoothly and without much effort. You do not have as much "feel" of the tool as it cuts as with a totally hand held tool however. When I first got it, I was happy with it except for the 1" square tool bar that came with the older units. I make rather small openings and the square corners were always bumping my entry hole. This forced me to always use the Don Pencil tool bars. This was OK as long as my vessels were not too deep. As they became deeper I found I was getting too much vibration because I could not use the heaver tool bar. The second problem is with the basic design. The tool is held in place by the tail stock. This means you cannot adjust the rear height of the tool. I continually find the the different tool bars and cutting bit assemblies require small variations in the rear tool height to keep the cutter at the proper height and angle. This cannot be done with only the front tool rest when dealing with a small opening. Finally the laser attachment system is poorly designed and very elementary. Adjusting and keeping the laser in the proper location is difficult. This is especially true when rough turning or hollowing deep within a vessel with the 3/4" tool bar bouncing around and the "Elbow" is almost straight. I find the elbow joints, even if properly adjusted, still give a little bit and flex adding to the vibration.
If I had it to do over again, I would take a long look at the Monster Articulated System. It appears to be more stout and the rear height can be adjusted for the subtle changes I like to make. I don't know anything about their laser system. I recently purchased a Jamison system to supplement my Elbo Tool as it allows me to go much deeper with much less vibration and the laser mounting system is much more stable and easier to adjust. I also have the 1 1/8" round tool bar that allows me to go very deep inside and keep the cutter much more stable.
Hopes this helps.
Re: elbotool info. Reply - Long
Bill Stehman
>Joaz,
I have never used the elbotool but after much consideration and talking with Randy @ monster I went with his system. He made rear mounts that work on my two 12" lathes and my 16". Totally adjustable to any height.
His articulating arm system allows me to rotate my head stock out to 30 degrees which is a joy for hollowing and relives back, neck and arm strain. It is solid. Just a consideration to ponder.
Re: elbotool info. Reply - Long
joaz
>Thanks Bill and Bill. Very helpful. I used the Jamison system for years with the home made rear support and not being able to adjust at the back was a real problem. I now use the Kelton rig with the Jamisson rods and have been happy with it but have found my back give me fits after using it for long periods of turning.
I tried using the laser, but find it to distracting. I guess I am too old school and always use the calipers.
I will definitly check out the Monster system.
Thanks again.
Monster Tools Articulated System
David Propst
>I had the Kelton Rig which I used for larger pieces, but I always felt I had to work around it instead of with it. It was also a relative pain to store when not in use. My back also gets really stiff when hollowing and the articulated systems seem to allow for a much better postural approach. There are several articulated systems available patterned after the Vicmarc system.
I recently looked into them and sold my Kelton rig to replace it with Randy Privett's large Monster Articulated System. For me, it had the best balance of stability, adjustability, robustness, and price.
There are several folks on other forums who had posted very favorable and complete reviews of Randy's system.
Randy has 3 YouTube videos of the Mini articulated system in action which were helpful. They are linked from his Mini Monster Page.
Randy was great to communicate with and when I receive it and get a bit comfortable with it I'll post a review.
David
Re: Monster Tools Articulated System
Wally Dickerman in Arizona
>The obvious next step will be a mini router to replace the cutter bit. Then hook it up to your computer and sit back...:-)
Wally
Re: elbotool info.
robo hippy
>I also have the Monster system. I love it. The down side is that you can't do deep forms. It is comfortable to about 8 inches deep, but beyond that it does start to chatter a bit. I have heard of people who have gone 12 inches deep with it. The laser system is great, but adjustment takes a bit of getting used to. The depth adjustment is very snug, so you have to loosen it up quite a bit to move it, so when you tighten it again, the pointer light will move foreward about 1/4 inch. I just set it 1/4 shallower than I want, and it gets it close enough. With the swing adjustment, you loosen it only enough to move it, not so much that it swings freely. Adjust, then tighten. If you get it really loose, it moves all over the place when you tighten it up again. I did have an adapter made that allows me to use my McNaughton cutters. The large (3/4) blades are just too long for this system (vibration), but the medium and small work fine if you have the adapters. With the cutters that Randy supplies, to hollow, you need an opening 1 inch plus wide. This isn't a problem if you use a collar, or don't mind a larger opening on your hollow forms. This articulated hollowing system makes hollowing easy.
robo hippy
Re: elbotool info.
Dick Hines
>I have a Jamieson and a Kelton rig. I find the Jamieson is some what easier to use that the Kelton. I am going to get some bigger bars made for the Kelton so I can go deeper than 12". The jamieson rig is a little hary when I get down arould 12". I like the laser on the Jamieson better than the Kelton. It is easier to adjust.
IA friend of mine has a Elbo like rig. I used it once and keep having bad thoughts about part of me getting pinched in the elbos. I have not heard of that being a problem though. Maybe it's just me.
Re: elbotool info.
Bill Clark
>Dick, I've taken my Elbo Tool to 9" deep in some soft end grain redwood with a 3/4" tool bar. It was vibrating badly and I was getting some tear out so I stopped. I wanted to go another inch but my walls were 3/16" and just didn't want the chance it. I was able to scrape the roughness out of the bottom and left it thicker than I originally wanted. That's when I decided to get the Jamison system with the 1 1/8" HD tool bar. It's a monster and very heavy. It should do the trick in the future.
Monster tool?
David Propst
>Hi Reed,
Have you used any other cutters than Randy's? Do you have his swan neck tool? In addition to Randy's cutters I plan on using my Jordan tools and Scorpion/Stinger set with it. I like fairly shallow topped forms, so there will be some I doubt I'll be able to take to finish thickness with the rig.
David