Choosing a Thompson Gouge
Steve in NC
>I am trying to decide which Thompson gouge to get. What are the diferences between the "U" and "V" shapres. (I am looking at either the 1/2 or 5/8)
Thanks for your input
Steve
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Choosing a Thompson Gouge
Steve in NC
>I am trying to decide which Thompson gouge to get. What are the diferences between the "U" and "V" shapres. (I am looking at either the 1/2 or 5/8)
Thanks for your input
Steve
Re: Choosing a Thompson Gouge *LINK*
Gordon Seto
>Steve,
This may help.
Re: Choosing a Thompson Gouge
Allen Neighbors
>Steve, I have three Thompson gouges; The 5/8 and 1/2 are U and the 3/8 detail gouge is closer to the V. I also have a V flute 1/2 of another brand. My V flute 1/2" gouge clogs up a few times on nearly every piece. The U flutes never have. I have a V flute 5/8 gouge of another brand also, and it has never clogged up on me. The 3/8 detail gouge has never clogged up, either.
My next gouge will be a 5/8 Thompson V flute.
You can't beat the Thompson Gouges!
Others may chime in here with more info.
Re: Choosing a Thompson Gouge
john lucas
>Steve most of the differences in V vs U is in the details. The nose is a little narrower on a V which is good for some things bad for others. The wings on the V gouge can be ground to a less acute angle because there is more metal there. This again can be good or bad. I like a very sharp wing for pull cuts but that means they dull faster. A slightly more blunt angle that you can get on the V gouge will hold an edge longer but takes more effort to cut through the wood.
So it really boils down to how you use the gouge. I don't know which to recommend because they both work equally well in most situations. When you get to the point that you are custom grinding the angles then you will find that you prefer one over the other.
Easy - One of Each
Fog Tanner
>At least one, two is better and four works the best (lets you do more tunring before breaking the rythm to sharpen). Of the 1/2" variety I have four, with the fifth on the way. I have them in both V and U shaped flutes. I got the U primarily for the back cutting the outside of bowls. The V flutes have different bevel angles for different parts and different shaped bowls. I also have three 5/8", two with V flutes and one with a U flute. The V flute has the swept back grind, while the U has the more "traditional" grind that Mahoney uses - he reground it and I am still learning how to use that.
Along with those I have a number of shallow and detail gouges, both 3/8" and 1/2". They all work well, and I use them for on parts of the bowls around the foot and for doing beads.
One thing about The Thompson "U" shaped flute as compared to Henry Taylor (my other brand that I use), is they have more steel under the flute. They don't flex as much as the other ones, which was one reason I didn't use the "U" flute that much before. You really can't go wrong with any one that you get, but part of the decision will be based on the size of bowls you tirn the most. If it is larger bowls (14"-23"), then a 5/8" smaller bowls (6"-13") a 1/2" and for the really fun ones (2"-5") a 3/8" (either bowl or shallow works). I also use a 1/2" shallow gouge for profiling the outside of bowls from 6" to 23", so you are not stuck with one gouge on the outside. A shallow gouge can be used on the inside, but a deep fluted (bowl) makes life a bit easier. Of course this is all dependant on how you turn, so you need to consider your particular style and what you are comfortable with.
Fog
Re: Any one you like....
Jesper, Denmark
>I have just received a total of 16 Thompson gouges for friends and other turners "over here". It is really too early to make a combined judgement, as most people are still figuring out how to drill handles in inch sizes.
I have the right drills and have started with the spindle gouges, which were the more interesting for me. They worked very well just out of the box, and the ones used without the handle to make the handles were just as sweet as can be.
U, V or the various spindle configurations are up to you. My first take is that this guy does good work and I am very pleased with everyting about this deal: Delivery, Price, service and the quality as well as value for money.
It is very satisfying that there is this type of supplier around. It confirms that the spirit of wanting to do good work and make a bit of money doing it is still alive and kicking.
Amen.
Re: Thanks All
Steve in NC
>Thanks for the input everyone. I am asking this decision because after three years of use my Crown PM 5/8 bowl gouge has gotten too short for larger bowls. It makes me sad to have to change from a tool that I am so comfortable using but based on a thread a week ago it sounds like a Thompson gouge with a Dave P handle will make me feel better.
Thanks again for your input. Once again WoodCentral has been a valuable resource.
Steve
I am overwhelmed... again...
Doug Thompson near Cleveland
>Sorry to hijack your thread Steve. I can not express in words how I feel right now but I'm the luckiest person in the world. These are trying times here at home but everyday I wake up to emails and phone calls from the best people you could ever ask to meet. Helpful beyond belief... (you know who you are).
Thank You again!
Doug
Steve - IMO a 1/2V for bowls 10 inches and under, the 5/8V for larger bowls. That's IMO only.
Like Crown PM... you will LOVE Thompson!
David Propst
>Steve,
I replaced my "too short for the jig" 5/8 Crown PM gouge with a Thompson V. If you liked the Crown PM you will be in absolute love with a Thompson V. I have several hours turning with it now, it is the best gouge I have owned. Very similar geometry, but a bit more metal under the flute.
Got a 1/2" V too. I've never used a U gouge, may try one soon.
Stop thinkin' and order!
David
Re: I am overwhelmed... again...
Mike Rubes, Apex, NC
>Hi Steve,
I'll echo part of Doug's note and say that I recommend a 1/2 inch V for bowls. I spin a Jet Mini and, in my opinion, the 1/2 inch V is the perfect size for that lathe. I spin bowls mostly in the 6 to 9 inch range and this tools fits that perfectly.
I can also highly recommend the Dave Peebles handle with this tool. That's a wonderful combination.
Good luck, let us know what you pick!
Mike
Color me a happy camper in Apex, NC!
Handle
Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!
>Hi Steve,
I am heading out tomorrow morning to pick up the aluminum for your special handle.
You are going to love that Thompson tool.
Best wishes,
Dave
Thanks Mike,
Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!
>That is music to my ears. It makes it all worth while.
Best wishes,
Dave
Re: Like Crown PM... you will LOVE Thompson!
Doug Thompson near Cleveland
>David, Thank you for the good words.
Re: Choosing a Thompson Gouge
Glenn Hodges/Nashville, Ga
>I choose the V Thompson Gouges for my 4 because I was using the V and happy with it. I saw no use to change. I have just ordered and received my 2nd 5/8 V Thompson which I use the most and the Peeple's handle which I am looking forward to trying to wear out. I have nothing but praise for the Thompson V's.