Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Robust Comfort Tool Rest

Posts

Robust Comfort Tool Rest

#1

Robust Comfort Tool Rest

Carole Valentine

>I recently got a 6" Robust tool rest and I will have to say that this is without a doubt the best tool rest I have ever used. The tool rest that came with my lathe (Nova) was awful so I had been using the round bar type rests and always got irritated when my hand would hit the post. This is a non-existent problem with the Robust design! In my mind, the perfect tool rest is one that I don't even notice as I am turning and that is the case with the Comfort Rest. It also allows me to get closer to the work than any other rest I have used, even when working in the tight areas adjacent to the spindle or tailstock. The embedded rod in the top of the rest allows the tool to glide and maneuver effortlessly.I plan on getting the larger rests as well and highly recommend them to anyone not happy with their current tool rest!

No affiliation - simply a delighted user!

Re: Robust Comfort Tool Rest

#2

Re: Robust Comfort Tool Rest

Gordon Seto

>Ditto everything Carole said. In addition to that, the tapered end (right side) allows the tool rest to get closer on the interior of bowls without using a curved tool rest. As compared to the round tool rest, the reduction in tool overhang is significant.

I also have a Nova; I have been using the Oneway tool rest, which is a major improvement. But the Comfort Rest is the ultimate tool rest.

I got the 4" and 9" from Bill Grumbine. He is the distributor.

Gordon


img

Re: Robust Comfort Tool Rest

#3

Bill Grumbine

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Will you be a vendor in Richmond? I was thinking about getting one of these rests but want to save shipping.

Re: Robust Comfort Tool Rest

#4

Double Ditto

Ron in Drums PA

>I own the 4" and the 6" rests and they are the best.

I purchased mine from Bill G

Re: Robust Comfort Tool Rest

#5

Re: Robust Comfort Tool Rest

Rick Allen

>I bought a 6" Robust comfort tool rest a couple of years ago. It is a very nice tool rest.

When turning platters, getting the tool rest close to the platter is important to me. For this to work the supporting edge of the tool rest needs to extend in front of the tool rest post far enough to clear the banjo. I found with my lathe the Robust comfort tool rest did not extend past the banjo. So when turning platters I could not position the Robust comfort tool rest closer than 3/8" from the platter. As the platter becomes dished out that gap increases to more than 3/4".

Many turners may never have the issue of overhang. Lathes with banjos that have smaller overhang requirements will not have this issue. Depending on the type of turning you like to do the overhang issue may be unimportant. I sold the Robust comfort tool rest several month ago.

The Robust comfort tool rest I had was without the rod on top. It is possible that my overhang issue has also been eliminated in the current Robust comfort tool rest.

Re: Robust Comfort Tool Rest

#6

Re: Bill Grumbine

Gordon Seto

>Barbara,

They will be directly shipped from Robust. The shipping was very fast.

Gordon

Re: Robust Comfort Tool Rest

#7

Re: Bill Grumbine

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Thanks Gordon. I just checked the vendor list for the Symposium and Robust is represented. I just want to save shipping. :-)

Re: Robust Comfort Tool Rest

#8

Re: Robust Comfort Tool Rest

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>Rick,

There has been an evolution of the Robust tool rest since I purchased my Robust lathe. The current rest is excellent, but it does not extend far from the centerline of the toolpost, so a heavy banjo may come into play when turning platters. The rise over run ratio reduces vibration and it allows one to get a good shear scrape angle, so the overhang is not large.

Ed

Re: Robust Comfort Tool Rest

#9

Re: Robust Comfort Tool Rest

Russ Fairfield

>Pay attention to what Rick Allen wrote. The Robust tool holder may not solve your problem.

Yes, the Robust tools rest is a big improvement over almost everything that is available on the market, and especially the POS that Nova provides with their lathes; but the rest is made for the Robust lathe, and may not solve the problem that Rick Allen describes for other lathes with big ttol posts on their banjos - the "resting edge" does not extend out past the vertical casting of the tool post on the banjo. In other words, the tool post casting hits the edge of a large flat piece, like a platter, before the tool rest. It that respect, the Robust is no better than the 24" Oneway rest. I don't know about other lathes.

I may be picky, but I don't like round tool rests, and hard round tool rests in particular. Regardless of their diameter, they are a couple of compromises that I am not willing to make, just so I don't have to use a file to keep the tool rest smooth.

Regardless of their diameter, they are still round with a fixed contact point. I may be picky, but I prefer a larger radius across the rest surface with the high point of the curve AT the front edge of the rest, not some distance behind it. A 1' diameter rod puts the support 1/2" back which is 1/2" to too far from the wood for good control for most turning, and a 1/4" rod moves the resting point 1/8" farther back than I like for turning a delicate finial.

The hard rod can be a problem if you use a gouge that has been ground back to where the soft steel behind the flute is on the rest, or if use a hard tool bit in a mild-steel holder such as a hollowing tool. That hard rod will make dents in the unhardened tool steel behind the flute, and in the soft steel of the tool holder, and a rough tool shank is no better than a rough tool rest. Both have to be smooth for good tool control and making a smooth cut.

Re: Robust Comfort Tool Rest

#10

Re: Robust Comfort Tool Rest

Molly Winton

>I have to parrot Carole's praise of the Robust tool rest. I recently acquired the 4", 6", and 9", and love them. While I don't make platters much anymore, so don't run into this issue, I primarily make hollow forms, and they are perfect for them. The particular issue I find appealing is when making my minis with my home-made allen wrench hollowers. The have very little reach beyond the typical tool rest because most rests have a 1/2" thickness. Using Robust's slender steel rod allows me to get very close to the piece, and thus extends my tool's reach. I've been using them with my larger pieces as well, and have yet to be disappointed in their function.

Re: Robust Comfort Tool Rest

#11

Thanks Rick and Russ

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Since I have a Oneway 1640 I will pay particular attention.

Re: Robust Comfort Tool Rest

#12

I think 1/8" is truly a non-issue

Ron in Drums PA

>I think the distance of1/8" away from the piece you are turning is a non-issue

Before I had my 3520, I would turn thin finials on my 1236 with a 1" round tool rest.

BTW - I'm using a 1/4" round skew.


Re: Robust Comfort Tool Rest

#13

Re: Robust Comfort Tool Rest

Barry Elder

>Good subject, good comments, thanks to all. Will file in the vault for future reference! Have a GREAT DAY!

Re: Robust Comfort Tool Rest

#14

Re: I think 1/8" is truly a non-issue

john lucas

>Ron I agree, I have the 3/4" tools rest from bestwoodtools and don't find the distance from the fulcrum point to the wood to be that be a deal except with really small gouges (and you know I have those). I don't like the center post being in the way.

The standard Powermatic tool rest has a good shape on the top with the fulcrum point being near the wood but overall rest is so thick you can't get small hands around it if you need to steady the spindle with your fingers.

I personally think that every rest on the market is a compromise for some styles of turnings. That's pretty understandable since there are so many of us turning all sorts of things. I really like the round rests for smaller turnings because I can reach around them. I think the Robust rest would definitely solve some problems but might have others. I like my Powermatic rests for some things and hate them for others.

Re: Robust Comfort Tool Rest

#15

Re: I think 1/8" is truly a non-issue

Ron in Drums PA

>That round rest was from BestWoodTools, so it must be 3/4" and not the 1" I mentioned.

And your are right, it's nice to be able to wrap your fingers around the rest for certain cuts.

Re: Robust Comfort Tool Rest

#16

Re: I think 1/8" is truly a non-issue

Bill Howatt

>I realize I am spitting in the face of physics, fulcrums and levers but I actually don't like putting my rest real tight to the work. I find I Have better control or more "comfort" with the fulrum point back a little.

Bill