Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

To scrape or not to scrape?

Posts

To scrape or not to scrape?

#1

To scrape or not to scrape?

Steve ponch

>I am a new turner, I have hade several instructors in turning. Some say its fine to use a scraper, others say its taboo. Whats your opinon?

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

#2

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

Ron in Drums PA

>I like breaking taboos.

I use whatever works, including scrapers and some magic incantations.

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

#3

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

Allen Neighbors

>I agree with Ron. If a scraper will do the job you want to do, and you want to use it... use it. I can sometimes get a smoother cut shearing with a scraper, than I can get with a gouge or skew. So, in my book, anything goes! :)

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

#4

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

john lucas

>I think the final product is all that matters, how you get there is up to you. It is best to understand the differences and then practice so that in the long run you use the most efficient method. Scraping generally does not leave as clean a surface on the wood as cutting but sometimes it's just the best tool.

If you want to turn a reverse V for example, it would be very hard to do with a scraper because it will tear the top of the V. A cutting edge would be better for this. For hollowing endgrain a scraper is a pretty efficient tool that leaves a decent finish. Experienced turners will use ring tools, hook tools, Hunter tools etc but I'll bet if you had all the box turners who use round nose scrapers hold up thier hands they would be in the majority.

Shear scraping is kind of inbetween scraping and cutting. I say kind of because it is actually a cutting action and leaves a very clean surface. What many turners do is to use cutting tools to get the shape as close as possible with no tearout and then use a shear scraping action to smooth off any tool marks and leave a level surface.

If you use a scraper to cut downhill with the grain is will leave a cleaner surface. Cutting a cove with a round nose scraper is a good example. People tend to push the scraper into the cut and the wiggle it back and forth to get the shape they want. This leave lots of tearout and will chip the top corners. A better method is to start near the out edges of the cove and move into the center getting deeper as you go. Make several passes. This is cutting down hill with the grain and leaves a cleaner surface. Then you can tilt the scraper to about 45 degrees and use the lower portion of the tip and shear scrape from the outer edge down toward the middle of the cove. Do this on both sides of the cove and you will have a pretty clean surface with little sanding.

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

#5

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

Steve ponch

>Thanks John, very informitive

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

#6

Whatever it takes

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>As I have learned about the evolution of turning, before there were bowl gouges, there were scrapers (among the other tools). What tool did the early, manual turners use to make bowls? scrapers.

I say, use a scraper if you can achieve the results you desire.

In this case, I believe the end justifies the means.

keithz

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

#7

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

Russ Fairfield

>The "real woodturners don't use scrapers" crowd forgets one thing. The fluted gouges as we know them have only been around for only the past 40 years, at the longest. Fluted bowl gouges came out in the late 70's, and the spindle gouges about 10 years before that. How do they think wood was turned for 1000 years before that?? It was turned with skew chisels and scrapers.

I see it not as an either/or, but rather as the best of both worlds.

The gouge has the advantage of being able to remove a lot of wood fast. The scraper has the ability to make a finishing cut that is smoother and a better curve than anything that can be done with a gouge. This will always get an argument, but anyone who can't do that with a scraper doesn't know how to use the tool.

I always find it interesting that the same "real woodturners don't use scrapers" crowd then use things they call "hollowing tools", most of which are nothing more than small scrapers, with the same cutting action, just a different use.

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

#8

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Steve, I've been teaching turning for quite a few years. When I teach bowl turning I stress the use of a bowl gouge, which of course is cutting not scraping. However, I also teach that it's okay to use a heavy duty round nose scraper to clean up the inside bottom of a bowl, and I teach students how to shear scrape, either with a bowl gouge or a designated shear scraper. However, when teaching spindle turning I stress that cutting, not scraping, is the way to go. Learning how to use a roughing gounge properly and learning the use of a spindle gouge is quite easy. Of course, as we all know, there is a learning curve to learning the proper use of skew chisel. It's a cutting tool, not a scraping tool.

Wally

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

#9

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

Bill Howatt

>Another "whatever it takes" vote. As a turner you need to build up an arsenal of tools, methods and techniques. No two pieces of wood are identical and there is an infinite number of shapes and locations to deal with so it is nice to be able to switch to another method when your favorite isn't doing too well.

General rule is to avoid scraping on softer woods. Scraping can leave a very nice surface on extremely hard exotics. There are also some locations that doing anything other than scraping is difficult - such as in the sharp interior corner of a box.

There are great turners who scrape and there are also some that never scrape (they say).

Bill

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

#10

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

Curt Fuller

>I'm a member of the 'use what works' group. In the turning I've done, I've found that you can cut or scrape with a gouge, but you can only scrape with a scraper. So I've always thought that those turners that claim to only use a gouge use it in place of a scraper when the situation calls for a scraper while others might change tools and pick up a scraper. It's more the presentation of the gouge to the wood that determines whether it's cutting or scraping.

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

#11

Steven Antonucci

Definitely.

steve antonucci

>Since the two are mutually exclusive, I suppose you have no choice but to be doing one or the other. Even if you are cutting, you are not scraping...

If you turn a lot more, you'll learn that it doesn't matter which way you go. In the end, most of us remove all visible signs of how the wood was removed anyway, so it really doesn't matter.

I cut when I can, and then shear scrape away any mistakes from cutting. Then, I sand away all of my shear scraping mistakes and finally put a coat of finsih on to highlight my sanding mistakes.

Steven

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

#12

Put a coat of finish on to Highlight

john lucas

>my sanding mistakes. Extremely well said Steve. That has been a proven technique for me. :) If I think I'm really getting cocky about my sanding I stain the wood first to really show up the scratches. We all know that scratches don't appear until you have at least 5 layers of finish on top of them. :)

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

#13

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

Tim Grenville-Cleave

>In my humble opinion if I could use C4 to give me a quality hollow form or a slice of SWMBO's sponge cake gave me a clean cut/scrape I would use them ... if it works and you are comfortable with it, why not!!

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

#14

Richard Allen

Smile and learn to use a bowl gouge

Richard Allen

>I was watching a demo a couple of years ago by an accomplished woodturner who was a proponent of scraping. He felt it was necessary to defend his scraping techniques over and over and over again.

When he finally started turning wood (scraping wood) the expression on his face showed a lot of fortitude and grimace. It is quite possible that this woodturner has that expression whenever he is doing something he enjoys.

By contrast most woodturners I know who cut wood with a bowl gouge have a smile on their face when turning wood.

If I didn't know any difference except for the quality of the finished pieces and the expression of there face when turning wood I would learn how to turn wood by cutting wood with a bowl gouge.

Cutting will almost always dull an edge more slowly than scraping will.

The forces used when scraping tend to be counteracted more by the hands and arms of the woodturner.

The forces used when cutting tend to be directed more into the wood.

You can use a bowl gouge with one hand, indeed one finger once the cut has been started.

Cutting wood is done with less effort than scraping wood.

If your goal is to have fun turning wood learning how to use a bowl gouge is going to help you in that goal more than scraping wood will.

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

#15

LOL, Steve!

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

#16

Mike Stafford

Back when I was teaching myself to turn...

Mike Stafford

>bowls, all I had to use was a 1/2" roundnose scraper and a 3/4" straight scraper. I did not have a bowl gouge and I was only turning shallow little bowls more akin to coasters. I turned dozens of these little coasters/shallow bowls. I soon learned that a scraper had to be sharp to be worth a darn and I also learned to shear scrape when I was near to my finished product.

As I started turning larger pieces of wood I found that scraping with a 1/2" tool was vastly inefficient so I went to the store and bought a 3/8" bowl gouge because that was the size recommended in a book I had. It took me a while to learn how to sharpen it but once I got the hang of it I was peeling off nice shavings at a much faster clip than with the scraper. But I still found that I had to refine the surface with the scraper.

Using a sharp scraper you are actually using a cutting tool but you are removing much smaller amounts of wood than you do with a bowl gouge. In my recent class with Jamie Donaldson he taught me how to use a bowl gouge in ways I had never dreamed of and shear scraping with it really improved the surface of what I was turning.

I don't think it is wrong to use both and whatever works is the philosophy I believe in. However if you have a chance to learn how to properly use your tools from someone who has experience I recommend doing that as early in the learning process as possible and you will not have to make as many coasters as I did....

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

#17

Jesper, Denmark

Re: So Wally, how do you shape your spindle gouges

Jesper, Denmark

>See the quest in the thread below..

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

#18

Re: So Wally, how do you shape your spindle gouges

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I like to shape spindle gouges with a fingernail grind with a little side grind. The side grind makes it a bit more versatile for using it for example, when shaping a foot on a small vessel. I can make a cut then roll the gouge and shear scrape. I don't know exactly, but I think that the nose is ground at about 35 deg.

Wally

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

#19

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

bowlman

>I've been tirning 30 years or so. I have always told students and anyone who would listen (most don't) that the end result is what matters most. Scrape it, cut it, carve it, nibble it away with trained termites, burn it, what ever gets the job done. Ever thought of using prima cord to do some wood removal? For many tasks, a well sharpened and properly used gouge is most efficient and , again, stressing proper use, can leave a wonderful fininsh right from the tool. That's mainly what the "big guns" are saying when they espouse gouges/skews only. But, even they will use a scraper if that's what it takes.

Dick Gerard

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

#20

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

bowlman

>P.S. Imagine a square nose scraper. Now image that you can bend around a round form that runs the length of the scraper and right dowm it's central axis, and goes pretty much back to the ferrule. What do you have?

A square across or "traditional" bowl gouge! If you used a round nose scraper, you'd wind up with a bowl gouge with a bit of a wing ... the start of a side ground bowl gouge or a spindle gouge.

And you thought high-school geometry would never be a part of your life after graduation!

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

#21

Re: So Wally, how do you shape your spindle gouges

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Perhaps I should mantion that when you grind the gouge the profile should have a convex surface, not concave.

Wally

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

#22

Re: To scrape or not to scrape?

robo hippy

>My daughter was on the computer all day so I am late in getting onto this thread. I have been wanting to post a thread about gouges vs scrapers for a while. I use a scraper for all of the roughing on my bowls, and for some of the finish cuts. I can get a smooth 220 grit finish cut with a gouge on the outside of a bowl, but not on the inside. This drives me crazy, and some days are better than others, but still, it is fact for me. I started playing around with scrapers a while back to see what those who use them know that I didn't. I can hog off material at least as fast or faster with a 1 1/2 by 3/8 inch scraper than I can with a 5/8 swept back grind gouge. I am talking 1 inch and wider shavings. It is easier for me to stall the lathe with a scraper than it is with the gouge (on my PM anyway, will have to see what the Robust does when I get it).

Now, there are 2 basic cuts we use when turning: a scraping cut and a shear cut. You can do both cuts with gouges and scrapers, it is all in how you present the tool to the wood. On harder woods (I am turning some Mountain Mahogany now, and it is at least as hard as Osage, and heavier) some times I can get a cleaner cut with a shear scraper than I can with a gouge or a flat scrape. A shear cut on the inside of the bowl is excellent for finishing up, and removing almost all tool marks. With softer woods, some times the shear scraper won't give as good of a cut as a gouge. As far as pressure required for a cut, it is about the same. If I am hogging off a lot of material, it takes a fair amount of pressure. If I am doing a finish cut that yields little whispy shavings that float in the air, it takes almost no pressure. I haven't noticed that either tool looses its edge faster than the other. That depends more on the wood than on the tool.

I do have Thompson gouges and scrapers, as well as other name brands. This holds true across the board. One other thing that contributes to the tool pressure is how far off the tool rest you are hanging, which is totally a leverage thing.

They both work, and work well.

robo hippy