Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Grinding of Spindle Gouges???

Posts

Grinding of Spindle Gouges???

#1

Jesper, Denmark

Grinding of Spindle Gouges???

Jesper, Denmark

>The forum and tool grind library seems to deal entirely with bowl turning and bowl turning tools. I find myself having/wanting to do some spindle turning, but find not so much information here to help. Like most, I did start learning with spindle turning, but the Dam...d skew and the fun of bowl or faceplate turning quickly took over.

I was fascinated by Jon Siegel's ideas of spindle turning many years ago. Jon is an accomplished spindle turner and has strong opinions of the techniques, including sharpening spindle gouges on a reversed belt sander. That seems to make some sense, but to me, the result also seems that the spindle gouges become - how shall I put it? slightly less cumbersome skew chisels.

Do we have opinions of how the spindle gouges should be ground? The alterneate to Jon Siegels ideas seem to be like bowl gouges, but with a 40� bevel in place of the normal 60� bevel for the bowl gouges.

To fill out the question, I have been ignoring the lathe for some years due to various personal reasons, but now want to get back into doing stuff that is more manual than the mental work I do for a living.

Re: Grinding of Spindle Gouges???

#2

Re: Grinding of Spindle Gouges???

Donna Banfield

>Jesper, Jon Siegel is a member of the NH turning club I attend, and I have tremendous amount of respect for his knowledge and skills as a woodturner. He has a background as a former HS teacher, and if I had him when I was in high school, I would have learned and (understood) a lot more!

If you are looking for a way to sharpen your spindle gouges using a bench grinder (as opposed to the belt sander method), you might look at Richard Raffan's videos, in particular his Turning Projects. It comes as a book/video companion, and covers several between center projects you can do on the lathe to work on your spindle turning skills. Raffan uses the bench grinder to sharpen his spindle gouges and shows how to do this in the video as well.

There may be other very good videos on spindle turning, it's just that I used the Raffan series myself, and found them to be very helpful. It's also helpful to hook up with a spindle turner in person for an afternoon or evening. Nothing beats hands-on help from someone who can recognize just from how you're holding the tool, "why you can't get that cut right."

Re: Grinding of Spindle Gouges???

#3

perfect timing

john lucas

>I had been planning to make some riser blocks so that I could sharpen my spingle gouges without changing the adjustment from the bowl gouge setting.

When I turn my hand mirrors I use both tools and would have to readjust the Oneway arm way to often. Most of my spindle gouges have a grind similar to the bowl gouge, with swept back wings and I use the Oneway Wolverine jig to sharpen them. I thought I could just build riser blocks that would give me the correct angle for the 40 degree or so angle on my spindle gouges.

Here is a photo of the block in use. I simply cut the corners off of a block I was about to turn. This gave me a block with one 90 degree corner and 2 45 degree corners. Then I layed the gouge and jig on the block and put the bevel flat on the grinding wheel. I marked a pencil mark on the block a little closer than the end of the Wolverine arm. Then I drilled a 3/8" shallow hole so the outer rim hit this line. Then I just carved away the back side of the hole until the bevel of the tool sat flat on the wheel. If you used a forestner style bit you could probably just "whittle" away at the hole to enlarge it enough.

I made one for the Detail gouge and one for the 1/2" spindle gouge. I have spindle gouges with several different grinds. Usually I arrived at these based on a need from experience however most of my grinds are very similar to the Ellsworth bowl gouge grind with steeper nose angles.


img

Re: Grinding of Spindle Gouges???

#4

riser blocks detail 

john lucas

>


img

Re: Grinding of Spindle Gouges???

#5

Re: Grinding of Spindle Gouges???

Allen Neighbors

>I sharpen my spindle gouges on a reversed belt sander with a 120 Grit belt. It works very well, and only takes a little honing to fine tune the edge.

For me, the reversed belt sander works better than the coarser grind stones.


img

Re: Grinding of Spindle Gouges???

#6

Re: Grinding of Spindle Gouges???

john lucas

>Allen I've been eyeballing the new Sorby pro edge sharpening system that is basically a belt sander running in reverse. Excellent looking tool.

Re: Grinding of Spindle Gouges???

#7

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Grinding of Spindle Gouges???

Jesper, Denmark

>Donna, I was a member of the NH Guild when I lived in NH and were at Jon's a few times when we had meetings there.

Re: Grinding of Spindle Gouges???

#8

Re: Grinding of Spindle Gouges???

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>John, I have a Sorby ProEdge and it is excellent for sharpening spindle gouges with the traditional grind. I am still working on a jig/adapter to do ellsworth-style fingernail grinds on my bowl and spindle gouges. The fingernail jig that comes with it only works for the factory fingernail grind on the Sorby's.

BTW, the ProEdge is excellent for every other edge out there and I am confident that it will work just as well for the ellsworth-style fingernail grinds.

keithz

Re: Grinding of Spindle Gouges???

#9

Re: Grinding of Spindle Gouges??? *LINK*

Gordon Seto

>One of our Club member made a Sorby look alike and took it to our Club meeting. He intents to make a few and sell as a kit. You can see it in page 3 in our newsletter.

I have too much invested in the heavy duty Delta grinder, Oneway balancer, Norton SG wheels and Wolverine jigs, I am not going to switch. I don't know whether he wants his contact information posted. But if anyone is interested, can PM me for his email address.

Gordon


Belt sander sharpening system

Re: Grinding of Spindle Gouges???

#10

Jesper, Denmark

Clarifications.....

Jesper, Denmark

>I understand how to use the oneway jig to grind the gouges to the fingernail profile and also Jon Siegel's (and apparently others)method.

I was more interested in what spindle turners prefer and why? There is quite a bit difference in the geometry between a cylindrical/conical grind on a wheel, Jon's flat cylinder/cone and the fingernails.

Re: Grinding of Spindle Gouges???

#11

Re: Grinding of Spindle Gouges???

Allen Neighbors

>Thanks, John, it really does the job. All I did was build a wooden bracket to turn the motor around (since it wasn't reversible).

The "v" block adjusts for different tools.

This is a copy of one I saw online, and forgot where I saw it. Whoever it was, "Thank you!"

Re: Grinding of Spindle Gouges???

#12

Re: Grinding of Spindle Gouges???

Allen Neighbors

>Jesper, to clarify... I use this converted sander because I like a flat bevel on my skews and spindle gouges.