Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Bandsaw Choice

Posts

Bandsaw Choice

#1

Bandsaw Choice

Tommy Holmes

>I'm looking at the Rikon 14" Deluxe to add to the toy shop. Has anyone had any experience with this saw? Also thought about the Powermatic 14" with a riser block. The Rikon has a 13" resaw capacity. Comparisons to other saws are welcome also. Really don't want to go over $1000 though. Thanks

Re: Bandsaw Choice

#2

Re: Bandsaw Choice

Clancy Courtney

>I recently looked at the Rikon, Delta, Jet, Powermatic, Steel City and Grizzly, chose the PM because I felt I would spend more on the others getting their saws to the PM level. I'm very pleased with it.

Re: Bandsaw Choice

#3

Dick Hines

Re: Bandsaw Choice

Dick Hines

>I have a Jet with a riser block. It will cut most anything I want. If I run into somwthing that the Jet will not handle I go to my chain saw.

Re: Bandsaw Choice

#4

Re: Bandsaw Choice (Long)

Tim Grenville-Cleave

>I am watching this with a great deal of interest. I am also looking for a new Bandsaw, but my options are slightly different. I do not have the same choice of manufacturers here in the UK as you do. But there is a huge range nevertheless. One that has caught my eye is the Laguna LT 14SE.

I must show my ignorance here as well and ask 'What is a Riser Block?' I can only assume it is some form of device to increase the cutting depth of a saw, but I am at a loss as to how this item could be fitted.

As to what use I will be putting it to ... I strive to be a competent turner, but I do not see cutting veneer slices anywhere in the future.

I am very aware of the old adage 'You get what you pay for' and bearing in mind everything over here is close to twice the price you lucky folks pay, my budget is somewhere around 2K USD.

I would value any advice or views on Bandsaw choice anyone may have to offer.

Re: Bandsaw Choice

#5

JL

Re: Riser block

JL

>As you surmised, a riser block is a device to increase the cutting depth of a band saw. It is typically a cast iron block that fits in the "C" part of a band saw. You unbolt the "C" frame and bolt the block in place. A 4" block would increase the height 4" and increase the length of the blade 8".

You might also have to get an extension for your guides as they may no longer be long enough.

Re: Bandsaw Choice

#6

Riser block

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>As JL said, it is a block that fits in the neck of the band saw. The Delta 14" saw uses two separate castings for the top and bottom, and the riser block fits in the joint between the castings. The riser block kit comes with a longer guide post and blade return channel for the neck. All the Delta 14" clones and copies have that feature - Powermatic, Grizzly, etc.

Most other band saws use a single casting for the frame and can't be extended.

Re: Bandsaw Choice

#7

Dick Hines

Re: Riser block

Dick Hines

>The riser block that I got for my Jet came with all that was needed to convert the saw. Extended guides and blade guard. All I had to do was buy the new 105" blade

Re: Bandsaw Choice

#8

Re: Riser block

john lucas

>All riser blocks won't fit all 14" look alike saws. I've converted 2 saws for friends and each riser block is different as well as the blade guide extensions. fortunately they can usually be modified by a handy person or a machinist friend.

I upgraded from the oriental lookalikes to the Delta 14" and it has been a dream saw. I thought I would buy a big horsepower large steel bandsaw like the Mini-max or laguna but in actual use this 14" with riser block is all I need. You can't cut real fast I've milled a bunch of logs into turning stock with little effort. I would still like to try one of the bigger saws especially the 20" powermatic but that's a huge price difference.

Re: Bandsaw Choice

#9

Re: Bandsaw Choice

Chuck Taylor

>I bought the Rikon 14" bandsaw recently, and am quite pleased with it. The blade that came with it isn't very good, but with a Timberwolf blade the Rikon cuts 12" of hardwood easily. You can find a review here (scroll down to '14" Steel Frame Band Saws'):

http://www.popularwoodworking.com/toolreviews

I looked at the Powermatic, but chose the Rikon. When you buy a cast-iron frame band saw and add a separate riser, alignment can be an issue, at least according to what I found in the archives of various forums. With a steel frame band saw such as the Rikon, that isn't an issue because it was designed from the start to handle a 13" vertical cut.

The 14" Rikon comes pre-wired for 115V, but I'm running it on 230V.

On the negative side, alignment of the lower guides and initial alignment of the table is a bit fiddly.

Re: Bandsaw Choice

#10

Re: Bandsaw Choice *LINK*

Russ Fairfield

>The only thing I know about the 14" Rikon is from the local Woodcraft store and using one in the classroom. It looks good in comparison with the others on the floor, the one in the classroom works well, it has been their No. 1 selling bandsaw, and there have been no complaints that I know about.

I have one objection with the saw that are big enough that I would never buy the saw because of it. The upper guide holder is in front of the blade, rather than behind it as on other saws, and in the way of my being able to see a line on the wood without raising the guide higher than I would like it to be for accurate sawing; and there is no way that it can be modified. This wouldn't be an important factor if you aren't going to be using the saw for following layout lines.

I still prefer the Delta for precision sawing because of the visibility of the blade where it enters the wood; and the bottom guides that are closer to the underside of the table than the others. The closer the guides, the better the support of the blade for accurate sawing. The Delta cast iron trunion is also a sturdier table support than any of the others, with the Powermatic a close 2nd. The table support of all other saws falls short of these two. Again, none of these factors will be of concern if you are just using the saw for cuting wood up for the lathe, but they can be a concern if you are trying to make accurate cuts.

Everything I can say about a bandsaw is in 2 articles on my website. There are several new saws on the market since this was written and revised, but the information is still good.


http://www.woodturnerruss.com/Bandsaw-Using.html

Re: Bandsaw Choice

#11

Re: Bandsaw Choice (Long)

Fog Tanner

>Since you are looking at a Laguna, you are looking at a steel frame saw and now need for a riser block, not that you could add one. I have a 14" Jet with the riser block to allow cutting of larger peices of wood. I learned fairly quickly, it is pretty worless for resawing. You cannot get a wide enough blade on my Jet to do any accurate resawing. And after a few years when I moved to larger bowls, it would not cut a 22" blank. I keep a 3/8" blade on it and use it for smaller flat stock, making templates for the plasma cutter.

I bought a 16" MiniMax, which is a steel frame saw. It will do resawing and I have started making my own venier for segemented pieces. I have a couple of 1" blades and a couple over that(either 1 1/4" or 1 1/2") which do a great job at accurate resawing wide boards.There is a world of difference between the cast iron and steel frames. But, part of that is because it is really an industrial saw. The MiniMax and Laguna are both Italian made saws.

There are three big band saw manufacturers in Italy. MiniMax imports theirs from one and Laguna from another, and the third is sold under another name (which I cannot rmember at the moment). When I bought my saw a couple of years ago, MiniMax was importing the industrial version and Laguna was bringing in the commercial version, I don't know if that has changed. The steel frame Jet and Delta are really no better than their cast iron frame models, just cost more. They flex just as much as the cast iron versions. With the money you are spending, you are better off with an industrial steel frame.

My only regret is not buying the MiniMax earlier and bypassing the 14" Jet. I have found that for a number of things I will use the band saw now instead of the table saw. With the carbide blade on it, I don't even need to go to the planer to smooth the cut. When I am cutting 22" bowl blanks, I don't have to continually keep tightening the table to keep it from tilting like my jet. I was going to make some support legs for the table when I decided to buy the MiniMax because I was tired of the table slipping while I was cutting. It has a 4hp motor which also helps with the large blanks.

Since you are in the UK, you might look at the saws from Italy directly or possibly under another name there. Without the shipping accross the Atlantic, you should be able to get the same saw for less than I paid for mine which was a little over you 2k budget.

Goof luck in your quest,

Fog

Re: Bandsaw Choice

#12

Re: Bandsaw Choice

Chuck Taylor

>Russ Fairfield wrote, about the Rikon 14" band saw:

"I have one objection with the saw that [is] big enough that I would never buy the saw because of it. The upper guide holder is in front of the blade, rather than behind it as on other saws, and in the way of my being able to see a line on the wood without raising the guide higher than I would like it to be for accurate sawing..."

On my saw there is a plexiglass window (3/4" wide by 2" high) at the bottom of the front of the upper guide holder that lets you see where the blade is cutting. It does need to be wiped off occasionally. Perhaps this is a recent modification to the design, added after the saws you objected to were manufactured, and for the reason you pointed out.

By the way, thanks for the pointer on your web site to the Supercut blades.

Re: Bandsaw Choice

#13

Re: Bandsaw Choice

Tommy Holmes

>Thanks all for the information. It's seems it's never an easy decision buying equipment.

Re: Bandsaw Choice

#14

Re: Bandsaw Choice

Tim Grenville-Cleave

>And a big thanks from me as well, I must get down to a lot of comparing of specs ...

Tim

Re: Bandsaw Choice

#15

Re: Bandsaw Choice

Russ Fairfield

>Quit looking. Just order a Mini-Max. It is the best bandsaw on the market. It might not be the cheapest, but it is the best. And that's my opinion. Others may disagree.

Re: Bandsaw Choice

#16

Re: Bandsaw Choice *LINK*

Jerry Hall

>I agree on the Mini Max. I have the Laguna 16, and it's fine too. But I have examined and admired the heft and design improvements on the Mini Max 16. Great fence too.

See link for good discussion.


http://www.sawmillcreek.org/showthread.php?t=45339

Re: Bandsaw Choice

#17

Re: Bandsaw Choice

John Scheideman

>I have the MiniMax MM16. I agree with Russ.....it is the best, or at least one of the best, out there. And MiniMax reps will give you service like you can't believe. That is rare these days. They even called me a year after I bought it to see if everything was going OK. My only complaints are that I've never liked the table insert very well and that you have to move the lower guide down in order to tilt the table very far...which is a little time consuming. But those are pretty minor complaints. Overall, it is a great saw and cuts turning blanks like melted butter. The extra expense is worth every penny when you never have to fight with it to cut what you want it to cut. That's my two cents...

John

Re: Bandsaw Choice

#18

Re: Bandsaw Choice

Bob Macgregor

>One of the band saws in the Popular Woodworking review appears not to be available anymore, the Craftsman (22401)...at least I couldn't find it on the web site. The sears.com site shows 9", 10", 12" and 18" saws, but no 14".

The same saw seems to still be available in Canada (model 092 827 960 10 at Sears.ca), but the the PW review said US list price was a $479 whereas Sears Canada is claiming $549 is $200 off the regular price!!

Everything I've read suggests the Craftsman is a good saw, if your budget is tight. Even with the jack-up Canadian price, I'm favouring it. However, if I could catch my wife in a really (really!) good mood, I'd try for the Rikon; it sounds like a lot more machine.

BOB

Re: Bandsaw Choice

#19

Re: Bandsaw Choice

Bob Macgregor

>I spoke too soon. Although the Craftsman 14" saw doesn't show up when you search for band saws, it does come up if you put the model number into the search box! Unfortunately, they have bumped the price up by $50 from what it was when PW reviewed it (which makes the "sale" price in Canada just about equal to the regular price in the US, given the exchange rate).

BOB

Re: Bandsaw Choice

#20

Re: Bandsaw Choice

Steven Kubien

>Hey Bob,

I've got the 14" Craftsman saw and for those of us on a budget, it's a nice machine. Sure, it could use another horse and a few inches in height but a Laguna or Minimax or big SteelCity was not in my budget at the time. The guides are nice, the table size is best measured in acres, especially compared to other 14" saws and blade changes are not too bad. It was really easy to set up and everything has stayed in alignment perfectly so far (about 5 months).

HTH

Steve Kubien