>I have been using a spindle gouge for roughing and would like to try a real roughing gouge to see if I want to buy a high dollar one, could be almost gone and without a handle as I can make a handle.
>I'm not sure what a"real" roughing gouge is. I have several of what I call roughing gouges. The are like big U shaped things. I only use them for spindle roughing. I think a good bowl gouge is a better roughing tool.
One of the best roughing tools has just come out. Eddie Graham from Chattanooga has just built what he calls "the big stick"
This think will remove wood unbelievably fast and safe. I also like his other tool handles. They whould work great with the thompson tools as well. His other handles come with R8 collets that are interchangeable so they should fit almost any tools.
>The picture is IMO the best and the second best SRG.
The top one is Thompson A-11 steel.
The bottom is P&N regular HSS.
The flutes are almost identical. The tang of Thompson is 3/4" and I don't understand why the P&N has to be reduced to 1/2". Even half inch diameter, it is still much stronger than the flat tang of other SRG.
The problem with the Thompson SRG is currently "out of stock".
>Mike The Thompson tools are just as easy to sharpen as any others. I do like the P@N gouge as well. In fact I was going to buy the P@N detail gouge until I saw the Thompson. At about the same price I thought the superior edge holding capability was worth it.