Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

hollow form drying question

Posts

hollow form drying question

#1

hollow form drying question

Steven Kubien

>Evening everyone,

I have turned exactly one hollow form and it was with dry wood and a home made tool. A lot of thinking (and some uneasiness/fear) led me to a captured rig and now I want to explore forms more and more.

In working with green wood to be finish-turned when dry, how thick do you leave the walls and bottom? I assume I should aim for the 10% rule like with bowls but I thought I should ask first. Do I need to consider anything significant regarding the opening?

Thanks,

Steve Kubien

Re: hollow form drying question

#2

Dick Hines

Re: hollow form drying question

Dick Hines

>10% should do it. Unless the wood is just cut and real wet I just turn the hollow forms as thin as I dare and let the piece do what it wants. It has to be the same "thinest" top to bottom. If your bottom is thicker than the walls it will more than likely crack.

Re: hollow form drying question

#3

Steven Antonucci

Turn from start to finish

steve antonucci

>I've had no luck at all roughing out hollowforms and drying them. The almost all split, horribly. I turn from log to finished product in one session, unless the form is really big and I can't finsih it.

If it is too big to hollow in one session, I will wet the outside, and pack it in a bag with fresh shavings to try to keep it from splitting. Sometimes, even this fails, since we're cutting away all of the "dry wood" and relieving a lot of internal stresses...

Steven

Re: hollow form drying question

#4

Re: hollow form drying question

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Steve, there are several things to consider when roughing out HF's. End grain pieces won't distort much but side grain pieces probably will. Depends on the kind of wood and how wet it is. 10% is a pretty good rule. Thickness should be about the same throughout.

After the piece is roughed out it's important to protect it from cracking. My method is to very liberally coat the piece with Johnson's paste wax. Outside only. If it's very wet and is a wood that's prone to cracking I'll paper bag it for a while. Otherwise it just goes on a shelf. Right now I have at least 60 rough turned HF's in my shop. None are cracked. I put the date it was turned on the piece. It'll be dry and ready to re-turn within 6 months or less. I Almost never turn wet wood to completion. Nothing wrong with doing that however.

Wally

Re: hollow form drying question

#5

Re: Turn from start to finish

Texian

>Steven,

On pieces too big to do in one session, ever try just covering (on the lathe) with close fitting plastic bag? Squeeze bag snugly around the piece to exclude excess air and secure at the chuck with rubber bands. Just a thought.

Re: hollow form drying question

#6

Re: hollow form drying question

Chip in Plano

>I'm rather impatient but I have had good luck dropping the rough out piece in my bucket of denatured alcohol. I almost always forget about it and it sits in there for 2-3 days. My most recent pieces were wet mesquite, bradford pear and some wild walnut. My only mistake was not sealing the walnut after taking it out of the DNA. It cracked down the side. But that just gave me an excuse to embellish the crack and fill it with some turquoise inlace.

Re: hollow form drying question

#7

Thanks everyone

Steven Kubien

>Your responses are a mixture of what I was thinking... turn to finish if possible, if only roughing out go 10%, DNA soak and wrap, etc etc. I figured things were similar to bowls and your responses confirm that thinking, despite people having their own ways and experiences. At least I know I am on the right track and I can experiment with confidence.

Cheers,

Steve

Re: hollow form drying question

#8

Steven K., Steve A., and Texian...

Allen Neighbors

>If I have a green piece of wood on the lathe, and have to leave it, I spray the entire outside of it with soapy water (old 409 bottle)and wrap it in a plastic bag like Texian suggests. I've never had one crack on the lathe. This goes for bowls and hollowforms too.

Usually when I have to leave, it's for a fire call, and some of those last all night, so I leave a piece for overnight quite often.

If I'm turning a green one to soak and dry-turn later, I try to leave it about 3/4" thick throughout except for the bottom, which I leave at about 1/2". Steve's right, they most often crack anyway, so most of the time I'll turn them start to finish thickness, wet sand, and let them do what they want to do.

Re: hollow form drying question

#9

Steven Antonucci

In general anything thicker than an inch splits

steve antonucci

>in my shop. It's probably really more like 1/2", but if I get them that close, I usually finish them.

I bag them with shavings, sometimes wetting them first to keep the humidity up. My shop is heated and pretty dry, so I probably need to do more than most people. I even had a piece of wood that I would have called dry split horribly along a spalt line, but I'll add some epoxy to fill in the gap and it'll be fine.

Steve

Re: hollow form drying question

#10

CrackedTurnings....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I don't know what some turners do or don't do to have so many roughed out pieces crack. I live in hot dry Arizona, and I seldom have a roughed out piece crack. I think that some turners don't coat the wood with a wood sealer. Instead they use shavings (which I've never figured out...What do dry shavings do to reduce cracking?), DNA, soap or nothing at all. For a lot of years I've used Johnson's paste wax or I use Anchorseal on wood that's wet and prone to cracking. My success rate is very high.

Wally

Re: hollow form drying question

#11

Steven Antonucci

My answer is: I'm lazy

steve antonucci

>I don't always get out the anchorseal on every piece. I've even had some larger piece crack, even though they were double coated. I think a lot of the "mystery" probably has to do with species, time of year, where it's stored, and what ever other variables you might think of. I almost never lose stuff to cracking in the winter if I store it outside. As it warms up, I might get some small end checks, but I leave it "long in the log" to bypass this problem.

During the hotter months, everything cracks, but it's too hot to turn, so I don't really care. One other thing that I thought of to answer your question is: desert woods tend to be "drier" than what we're used to here in the Northeast. Fresh maple has left sap stains on the back wall behind the lathe, and it's like taking a walk through a garden hose. Never had that happen with manzanita.

Steven

Re: hollow form drying question

#12

Question, Wally.

Allen Neighbors

>Wally, I don't know what the differences is in our locations. A couple of years ago, after you told me to try the Johnson's Paste Wax, I put it on a couple of large bowls, and in a couple of days, it had dried out and flaked off of them. (I didn't have them bagged.) I just never thought about it again, since that happened. I've got some Elm and Pecan bowls that I just recently (two weeks ago) got out of the soap and bagged. I'll try to get a couple of them out of the bags, waxed up, and rebagged tomorrow, and give it a try again. Maybe rebagging them will slow down the effects of the heat.

We're in for a long hot summer here. We'll see humidity down in the 20's for most of the summer... maybe that's why it all flaked off. What's the average humidity where you live?

Re: hollow form drying question

#13

Re: Question, Wally.

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Alan, I live in the desert. Humidity right now is about 7 to 10 percent. Dewpoint is around 10 to 15. I don't have AC in my shop so it can get pretty warm in the afternoons during the summer. I live at 3000 ft. elevation so we have cool nights even in the summer. My shop is quite comfortable until around 3 PM when it gets up to about 95.

If Johnson's wax doesn't work for you I suggest Anchorseal. I recently went through my stash of about 60 rough turned pieces to see what was ready to re-turn. Not one was cracked. I would be very very disappointed if I found a lot of cracked pieces.

I turn some mesquite but most of my turnings are of Oregon maple, madrone and myrtlewood. We go up to the NW for a few weeks every summer and I usually get a pallet of new wood.

I don't rough turn during the very hot months unless the wood is fairly dry already.

Wally

Re: hollow form drying question

#14

Re: Question, Wally.

Russ Fairfield

>Allen, did I see the word "SOAP" in your message?? That may be the answer to your question. Wax neither penetrates nor sticks to wood that has been soaked in soap or detergent. It will just lie on the surface, dry out, and flake off. I have no idea what the detergents will do to a water soluble wax like Anchorseal, but I would suspect nothing good.

Re: hollow form drying question

#15

Denis Putland

Re: Question, Wally.

Denis Putland

>I also have had the paste wax flake off of some very wet items rough turnned and coated during our cold winter months. Have never tried it in the summer time as I do almost all my rough turning in the winter time.

I have reasonable success rate with just leaving them (bowls and what ever) not coated, no bags or what ever in an unheated shed after rough turnning in the winter. They seem to slowly freeze dry,I have a small fan running to circulate the air.

I know this does not help you poor guys down in the sweat belt:::)))

Denis

Re: hollow form drying question

#16

Re: hollow form drying question

Mike Nelson

>White glue, cheap and works. I pour it over wet maple or the complete outside or hollow forms.

Re: hollow form drying question

#17

Re: Question, Wally.

Allen Neighbors

>Cool nights may be one answer. It's always almost as hot during the night, here. Sometimes it doesn't get under 85, and by three o'clock my shop is up to 110 degrees quite often.

Also, Russ may have hit upon the reason the wax flakes off. Soap.

I'll try the anchor seal.

Re: hollow form drying question

#18

Re: Question, Wally.

Allen Neighbors

>I think you hit the nail on the head, Russ. I never thought about the detergent having that effect on the wax, but that's got to be what caused the flaking.

I'm going to try some anchor seal on some today, and see what it does. I don't think it'll flake like the JPW, but I may be disappointed. I may have to go to the alcohol or just plain water to soak in. It surely wouldn't be as expensive to use clear water. Some of my Australian friends use it, and swear by it.

Thanks for posting, Russ, you never lead us astray. :)