Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Liability from a charity auction?

Posts

Liability from a charity auction?

#1

Liability from a charity auction?

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

>Hi all,

I'm not looking for legal advice here, but just curious how others have done this.

Like Steve a few threads below, I've decided to offer an "Afternoon of turning" as a bid object at my kid's school fundrasier this spring. Talking to some of the people on the PTA, this idea is being very well received and I think it will generate some money for the school. When people see a piece I've done, they often ask "How did you do that?" This is a way to show/instruct someone who is really interested in this.

However, should I in any way be concerned about the liability of having a stranger in my shop and my teaching them to turn? Like all woodshops, there are lots of sharp things and the potential, however slight on a lathe, for personal injury is there. Also, though, I would obviously never let someone try something that I thought was dangerous and would be helping them along the entire project. The only tool they will be allowed to use is the lathe. I will have the blank prepped and ready to go.

For those that have done this, did you have your winning bidder sign a liability form or anything? Is that something I can write myself and have them sign or does a lawyer have to be involved to make it more legal? I'm not balking at the cost of hiring a lawyer to do this, but if it is not needed, then I won't persue it.

To be clear, I myself will not get any money for this, I am not being paid, all the money is being donated to the school.

Thanks!

Mike

Just covering the bases in Apex, NC

Re: Liability from a charity auction?

#2

Re: Liability from a charity auction?

Chuck Engstrom

>I am neither lawyer nor insurance agent but you might want to speak to one of each, maybe more. The liability element of your homeowner's may -- or may not -- offer some protection, since you are involved in charity work rather than acting as a paid professional, but you'd better ask your agent, and possibly the school's agent as well, since they are in the loop.

Getting your winner to sign a release may help but that might not prevent a suit anyway, with associated aggravation and expense.

Our club went through this issue about a year ago when a local arts center asked us to do a kids program in their building under their sponsorship. Their contract specifically placed all liability on the instructor, for any damage both to himself or to students. We declined on that basis, though some of our members do accept the perceived lesser risk of teaching adults there. During our discussions one of our members told us that his insurance agent had told him he'd better stop teaching in his home because his policy didn't cover him. Another member pays a couple hundred extra a year for specific coverage for his shop.

Good luck with it. It's a fine thing that you want to do, but don't find yourself giving away your shop if someone catches a splinter. Be careful, be very careful.

Best-

Chuck Engstrom

Re: Liability from a charity auction?

#3

What a sad posting....

Stuart Johnson

>It is a shame there is such a fear of law suites making a charitable donation needs to even have this question raised. Yet, in today's society with such a sue and settle mentality there is no option.

Re: Liability from a charity auction?

#4

We just had a review at our club

Robert W

>A recent review of our club liability policy by the legal powers that be concluded that there was no protection for any activities of any kind unless it was at a club sanctioned meeting. Those who thought they were covered by the AAW policy were informed otherwise. Only club business, period.

The letter went on to explain that home teaching shops, home get togethers away from the club, home instruction that is paid or unpaid may or my not be covered by a homeowner's policy. It was specific of course that paid activities were not covered unless a separate policy was purchased.

I would call my insurance company (not agent) and ask if providing a service to a group or organization (which by the way has value, whether or not you charge for it) and ask if said value would consitute an exchange of goods, therefore making it a transaction.

Personally, I don't think you will be covered, charity or not. There is an assumed relationship between an instructor and student that exists, and I wouldn't want to hang my shop keys on some ambulance chasing attorney to find out what that exact chain of liability might be.

Just my 0.02.

Robert

Re: Liability from a charity auction?

#5

Re: I pursued this topic many.....

Jamie Donaldson

>...years ago with both my attorney and insurance agent. I have had a large liability policy for my photography business, required for independant contractor status with jobs like state fairs, public events, school systems,etc. I carried that policy over when I retired, and it now covers my woodturning business in addition to my homeowners rider for shop equipment. I also have my students sign a liability waiver, although they may not completely cover your exposure should someone really decide to sue for reasons like negligence.

Re: Liability from a charity auction?

#6

Re: Liability in general

Steve in NC

>Mike

I have thought about the liability aspect as well. Not only for this charity auction but for other events as well. I have been opening my shop to cub scouts to help build Pinewood Derby cars for over 15 years. In addition, I have hosted various girl scout and boy scout activties in my shop for many years.

Several years ago, I added an umbrella rider to my homeowner's policy. It is pretty comprehensive and I am told it covers liabilty related to volunteer activites. I hope I never have to find out what it really covers.

I have wondered about liability in other areas as well. I sell very few items but what if someone starts a fire using one of my oil lamps...

I have considered forming a LLC just in case. For now, I will be very careful adn carry on.

Good Thought

Steve

Re: Liability from a charity auction?

#7

Reality Check

Rick Davenport

>My 12 year old nephew wanted to make a pen for his mom last Christmas.

I turned one first, explaining how it was done.

Then I mounted a new blank for him.

I turned away to get him my mask (he already had safety glasses on).

He promptly fired up the lathe and stuck a skew into the blank.

Pieces of wood flew.

Luckily, none of them hit him or me.

Lesson learned, and only at the cost of a bent mandrel.

Woodturning and woodworking is inherently dangerous.

And we must be responsible for our actions.

I would be scared to death having a bunch of kids in my shop.

The moral liability, let alone legal liability is just too great.

R

Re: Liability from a charity auction?

#8

The AAW...

Peter Teubel

>There is liability insurance available thru the AAW to cover just this scenario....teaching in your shop. It is NOT the liability policy provided for club events/meetings, it's a separate policy entirely. More info is available at their web site.

Re: Liability from a charity auction?

#9

Home get togethers!

Stephen Mushinski

>Club sponsored get together's are covered are far as our legal team was concerned. There must be a paper trail. As long as it is a Chapter sponsored event then you are covered. Now you have to get into the meat and potatoes and who is first - home owners policy or AAW. That would be the grey area.

Note I am not a lawyer either just passing the information as our club lawyer gave us after reviewing the full AAW policy.

Re: Liability from a charity auction?

#10

Re: Liability from a charity auction?

Ted Owen, Pittsburgh

>Mike, I won't offer legal advice, as I'm now retired. Speaking for myself only, I'd probably self-insure if I didn't have an umbrella policy.

I would, however, have another adult, perhaps a family member, present at all times.

Whether you receive compensation has little relevance.

Really quite admirable that you'd offer such a generous prize. Hope it works out well for you.

Best, Ted