Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Does larger chuck mean less vibration?

Posts

Does larger chuck mean less vibration?

#1

Aage Rendalen

Does larger chuck mean less vibration?

Aage Rendalen

>When it comes to reducing vibrations in larger bowls and platters, what role do chuck size (weight) and jaw size play? I'm wondering if I should replace my Supernova (with normal jaws) with a Stronghold with bigger jaws.

Re: Does larger chuck mean less vibration?

#2

Re: Does larger chuck mean less vibration?

jwoodwright

>Isn't vibration a factor of roundness and speed?

Re: Does larger chuck mean less vibration?

#3

Re: Does larger chuck mean less vibration?

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>A less expensive option is to get larger jaws for your Nova chuck.

Larger jaws will reduce the vibration because the support area is bigger. How well the jaws match the tenon or recess is very important. Jaws that are expanded into a recess that is too large, or gripping a tenon tenon that is too large, only support the turning at a couple of points and vibration will be more of a problem.

Re: Does larger chuck mean less vibration?

#4

Re: Does larger chuck mean less vibration?

Greg Haugen

>Vibration can be cause by a few things, the biggest are usually tool angle/presentation to the piece/grind and support. Speed can play a role but not as much as the others. Most often it's a dull tool/improper angle or poor support. You can produce vibration by rubbing or in this case pushing on the bevel too hard or having the wrong grind for that particular application.

As far as chucks go, it's debateable, about the large or small chuck question. What is fact, as previously, stated are the jaws. In my opinion, a Small chuck with large jaws is just as good as a large chuck with regular or medium jaws.

Another factor, for bowls at least, is the "quality" of the tenon. If the tenon isn't properly made, there's no flat "seat" section at the tenons's base where the top of the jaws are in FULL contact with the bowl that can cause vibration. Under the force of the gouge can actually be pushed out of "true" while cutting without a proper tenon.

I'd look at alot of the factors and if needed different jaws before I drop the money on a new chuck.

Greg H.

Re: Does larger chuck mean less vibration?

#5

Re: Does larger chuck mean less vibration?

Texian

>None, none, and probably not. Assuming your chuck is fully threaded onto the spindle and has a firm grip on the wood, the source of vibration is probably imbalance of the workpiece. A chuck tends to hold best when in the nearly closed position, either clamping onto a tenon or expanding into a recess, as this maximizes the contact area between the jaws and the wood. Unless you are trying to hold a huge piece in a tiny chuck, the chuck size is irrelevant.

The source of vibration is imbalance.