Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

A question for the professional turners?

Posts

A question for the professional turners?

#1

Steven Antonucci

A question for the professional turners?

steve antonucci

>I enjoyed reading the thread below, and I think that there are certainly some agreed upon facts about the challenges around a life in woodworking.

One thing I didn't hear anyone comment on was "outsourcing" some of the work. I'm not talking about teaching your kids to sand a bowl (although I've tried...:-), but more the marketing and administrivia that come with running your own business. For those of you turning for profit (where it actually gets declared as an income source on your taxes), why don't you enlist the help of others to lessen the burden? Seems like a way of producing more and selling more?

Might be your wife handling the books or calling designers to market the goods. Could be a CPA reviewing the books. Might be a marketing professional helping you secure business so you can focus on making things.

What prevents you from enlisting the help of others?

Steven

Re: A question for the professional turners?

#2

Re: A question for the professional turners?

Ron in Drums PA

>I do outsourcing in my business so I have an idea of the costs involved.

I would think that unless a turner has a wife that can do the books and/or the marketing, the cost would be prohibitive for the average Pro-Turner.

Bill Grumbine said,

I'll tell you what does get my dander up though. It is when some sanctimonious twit proclaims his righteousness over those of us who do this for a living because what we do for money, they give away for free. This is the person who delights in casting professionals as greedy money grubbers, who if they had any decency at all, would also be giving it away for free. I always wonder if this attitude seeps over to their own profession, or way of making a living. I don't think these types think that far though. Since this is their hobby, it should be everyones' hobby.

Robert W said:

I hear this many scenario or something like it several times a year. The project may change, but the gist is the same. I bid putting up 3 layer crown molding in an odd shaped room (or some other kind of specialty carpentry) in a house, and I have to listen to the client's neighbor (who showed up for this purpose) tell him how easy it is, how it won't take long, and how it shouldn't cost much. We go to the neighbor's house to "share ideas" and take a look at his efforts (he is now bragging to my client that he has put up crown molding in several venues at half my price) an we look at his work. It looks like a child beat it on the wall with a shovel. Yet he is proud because he has no training, no company to support, and he did it after hours. Amazing to me how cheap crappy work can be done with no overhead!

---

You think this is bad, its worse when it comes to marketing. You would be surprised to find how many people with a desktop computer, an inkjet printer and some bundled software who think they are a genius when it comes to marketing and design while they really don't have a clue with either. I see too many brochures and business cards spouting professional services that have misspelled words and poor grammar. And the canned layout and clip art looks cheesy at best and is a dead giveaway for an amateur working on a shoe string budget.

Marketing Tip:

Collect names and address of every person who is interested in your turning and/or who has purchased an item from you. Have some post cards professionally designed and printed with a good photograph of the type of turning you specialize in. Mail out around special events like holidays and buying seasons (think vacation areas, galleries).

Now here is the trick on how this will work... you need to do this 4 times a year for at least 4 years. That right, minimum of 16 times to the same person to get results.

You think this is expensive? Then don't turn pro

Re: A question for the professional turners?

#3

Re: Easy answer Steve-$$$$$$$$$$!

Jamie Donaldson

>

Re: A question for the professional turners?

#4

Steven Antonucci

I figured, but wrong is always cheaper...

steve antonucci

>I'm not talking about hiring someone who doesn't know much more than you do to get rid of the work. I'm talking about hiring the right people for the parts of the job YOU may not be very good at.

As an example, there are some very well know galleries that will sell turned objects for you. They provide the space, the marketing, the "education" and the clientele. There is value there. Obviously, the wrong gallery won't help, but the right ones will move your work for you so you can concentrate on being in the shop instead of meetings.

It just seemed to me that some folks haven't figured out the cost of DIY on the business side vs. hiring a professional. If you think your time is worth X, and you spend 1/2 of it "not turning", wouldn't you benefit from moving the non core work to someone more capable than you? I have an accountant who does my tax prep. I have mechanics to work on my cars. Why not someone to do business development for my work?

Can't have my cake and eat it too...

S

Re: A question for the professional turners?

#5

Oregon Coast Woodturners...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>The cottage industry of woodturners on the Oregon Coast is a good example of woodturners earning a living at their trade. The fact that Myrtlewood grows only on the SE Oregon coastal area has provided a way for numerous small woodturning shops, scattered along the coast, to operate selling unique turned objects to tourists. Myrtlewood bowls, platters, candle holders etc.

Many of these small shops, with a gallery in the front and a turning shop in the back are "Mom and Pop" operated. Some of the larger shops hire turners to rough out the pieces. After drying in a kiln the turners finsh turning the pieces then turn then turn them over to what are probably lesser paid people to remount them on a spindle for sanding and finishing.

It's interesting to note that (unless they've changed recently) many of the pro turners use very heavy duty scrapers to hollow their bowls instead of bowl gouges. These scrapers have tips made of Tantung steel which will hold an edge for a long time. Some that I watched are very aggressive with these scrapers. It takes them just a few minutes to rough out a bowl. Most of them use screwchucks which allows the piece to be remounted several times. There will alsways be a small label in the center of the bottom. It covers the screw hole.

Wally

Re: A question for the professional turners?

#6

Re: I figured, but wrong is always cheaper...

Ron in Drums PA

>Depending where you live, you are talking $100 to $250 per hour to hire someone who knows what they are doing. Most weekend warriors feel the can do it cheaper.

Re: A question for the professional turners?

#7

Steven Antonucci

Any "good" people will work on commission

steve antonucci

>In my line of work (sales and marketing), most of the money comes from commission. It's a pay for play model- and the achievers do very well.

I'd be leary of entering an arrangement with someone who wanted $250/hr with no performance guarantees for their work. Stuffing envelopes with flyers is not what I had in mind, but moreover, having contacts in the architectural communities, galleries, or wherever else you might be trying to build a clientele.

In software, companies hire a financial services guy, a telco guy, a pharma guy- strictly for their Rolodex. Why not turning?

Steve

Re: A question for the professional turners?

#8

10% on 20,000 a year?

Ron in Drums PA

>How many turners do you think sell that much per year?

And those that do, how many are willing to fork over $2,000.

The marketing tip I presented in my first post would cost less than half that and will produce results, AND you don't have to pay me commission

Your ideas work for big corporations with a big budget. A team that works for commission only do so if they feel it is worth their while (in other words, they have to feel they can make money from you).

Now if you are talking about hiring manager like artists and actors do, you would just be a small part of their big herd.

Re: A question for the professional turners?

#9

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: I figured, but wrong is always cheaper...

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

>Quoting from your posting:

As an example, there are some very well known galleries that will sell turned objects for you. They provide the space, the marketing, the "education" and the clientele. There is value there. Obviously, the wrong gallery won't help, but the right ones will move your work for you so you can concentrate on being in the shop instead of meetings.

(My reply is that many of my items are in galleries but their cut is an extra 100% on my goods therefore making a decent platter too expensive. Couple that with the travel costs and depreciation on my vehicle plus the insurance costs, it works out to be pretty expensive way of doing things, but I have the choice.)

It just seemed to me that some folks haven't figured out the cost of DIY on the business side vs. hiring a professional. If you think your time is worth X, and you spend 1/2 of it "not turning", wouldn't you benefit from moving the non core work to someone more capable than you? I have an accountant who does my tax prep. I have mechanics to work on my cars. Why not someone to do business development for my work?

(My reply is that I do not earn enough to employ an accountant for tax purposes, instead I took an evening course to do the same and merely ask someone to check the figures before the Inland Revenue leap on my back! I repair my own vehicle and do as much as I possibly can to cut costs but even then it is a struggle!

Nevertheless I do still enjoy labouring in my shop to produce beautiful pieces, admittedly some of the gloss has been knocked off over the years and the inspirational section is a little thin now and then but on the whole I couldn't imagine going back to the 9 to 5!)

Regards, Peter.

Re: A question for the professional turners?

#10

Re: A question for the professional turners?

Steven Kubien

>"Everything else you can buy (marketing help, financial people, web developers, legal help)"

What you are talking about is what I basically said a few days ago. Stick to what you are good at, and this goes for any business you may start on your own. If you are not an accountant, don't do your own taxes. Not a lawyer? Better find one to write up contracts. Why don't turners do this? I think the better question would be why would anyone starting their own business try to be the jack-of-all-trades.

My thoughts only...

Steve Kubien

Re: A question for the professional turners?

#11

Re: A question for the professional turners?

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Outsourcing or networking? Two sides of the same coin to my way of thinking. One of the things I considered before embarking on my own business was how to do the business end of things. What could I do myself and what should I have someone else do. One of the quickest ways to business failure is to not recognize all the business stuff that goes on. It is not enough to love turning, or building stuff in the shop. You have to have a sense for business, and you have to like dealing with people. I know a whole bunch of people - none here of course - who make beautiful stuff, but should not be let out in public. These folks are not going to sell much, not because their stuff isn't worth it, but because they don't know how to interact with other human beings.

Keeping the books was easy - get someone else. If I had to keep my own books, I would be in jail for terminal sloppiness. I blame my artistic side for not being a good paperwork person. So SWMBO, who is very organized in that regard, took advantage of one of her job perks at the time and took three or four accounting courses so she could keep the books for me.

Selling. Easy again. I have an ability to sell, and I enjoy doing it. I had a fair amount of sales experience coming into the deal, so I sell my own stuff most of the time.

Marketing. This is different than selling. Some might argue that, but it is. When I started out, I had no money at all, not even any to pay me, much less a "marketing staff", so I joined the Chamber of Commerce local to me and attended as many functions as possible. I talked with people, attended seminars, bought space at business to business trade shows, and reevaluated my plans on a regular basis to see if I was achieving the results I wanted. One tricky thing about marketing is that if you are going to hire someone else to do it for you, they have to understand your business. Otherwise you are going to get a college class template marketing plan that sucks up money with little result. Two examples I can think of were two sales/marketing people I spoke with in the past. One wanted me to spend a bundle of money on phone book covers. That's a great idea for a pizza place or a Chinese takeout restaurant, but for people looking to spend a bunch of money on woodworking, the phone book cover is not the first (or any) place they are going to look. The other person was the one who wanted me to spend several thousand dollars to advertise on the radio. Right. Compete with Crazy Eddie and all that.

Legal stuff. I have been able to trade woodturning or instruction for legal help all along the way. Most business proposals can be handled with boilerplate documents slightly modified. A lot of what I do is handshake stuff, although bigger jobs require deposits. I've only been burned once, and that was by another woodworker. Actually, it was by a lawyer pretending he is a woodworker. The guy owns a small company doing limited runs of furniture. I came to discover he has burned a number of other people like me in much the same manner. The handshake and gentleman's agreement didn't hold water for him.

Collections. I see a lot of people who get tired of chasing money. I have never had that problem. I think it is because if it looks like a problem might arise, I tell the person that I am my own collection agency. I've had two bad checks and one bounced credit card after the person took possession of the merchandise. The one guy with the bad check made good on it immediately. The other two people were literally shaking in fear when they came to me, and I had not even raised my voice yet. But all debts were covered with no loss of revenue and virtually no loss in time. Even the lawyer that burned me didn't cause me too much grief. I bought a machine to support a job for him which he backed out on. I had to sit on it for a while, but I was able to sell it for the same amount I paid, so loss there was minimal.

Ron is right when it comes to hiring someone else out. I can't do everything, but I look long and hard at the quality other people are putting out at their own business. I see a lot of perky people trying to wow me with Dilbertesque terms to try and get their hand in my pocket, but I can see through that most of the time. I am very results oriented, and I expect quality when I am going to pay for something. That is when the networking comes in. I am in the unusual position that I am a fairly well known instructor now, so often others will propose to me that I teach them in exchange for whatever service they have to offer me. That has worked out very well. And sometimes I pay cash money!

And let me put in a plug for Ron. He designed my business card. It is a tiny portfolio of one piece of my work, but boy does it get attention! A business card is a small thing, but getting someone to do it right makes it a huge influence in my business.

Bill

Re: A question for the professional turners?

#12

Steven Antonucci

How many turners market well enough to sell $20K?

steve antonucci

>Take out the $2K and you're still left with $18K. And lucky if you can find someone willing to work that hard for $2K. That's $2/hr on 2000 man hours year if you spend half your time "not turning".

Best turner in the world with no marketing = $0. Best turner in the world with bad marketing only does slightly better...

Would I pay someone $2K if I was going to make $18K just to turn.

You betcha I would.

S

Re: A question for the professional turners?

#13

Re: How many turners market well enough to sell $2

Ron in Drums PA

>Steve said

In my line of work (sales and marketing), most of the money comes from commission. It's a pay for play model- and the achievers do very well.

snip

In software, companies hire a financial services guy, a telco guy, a pharma guy- strictly for their Rolodex.

And how many people with work for you at $2,000 a year so you can make $18,000 a year turning. No hypothetical, name one person.

I hate to say this, and I assure you this is not meant as a dis to the quality of your work, but you can make more than $18,000 a year working full time at McDonald's. I just saw an ad in the local paper where they are will to pay someone $10 per hour.

Good conversation Steve, no hard feelings, but I'm tired.

Re: A question for the professional turners?

#14

Steven Antonucci

A couple of nails on the head.

steve antonucci

>I agree that Sales and Marketing are two very different disciplines. One makes the phone ring. The other makes money.

A great many people think sales is a necessary "evil", but the truth be told, isn't evil at all. Marketing generates the interest in your product, but for everyone that's ever expressed an interest in something we produce, we're lucky if one in ten spends money on it.

Marketing helps identify where you shoudl concentrate your sales resources so that you know where the people who will buy your product are, not the people who are interested in your product. Everyone complains about how poorly craft shows work out, but nobody seems to learn from it. You either lose because you were outsold or because you should have never been there in the first place.

I met a guy last night who has a new tool on the market for spindle turning. He was a chairmaker, and his tool works great and is unique, but he didn't understand the "woodturning" market. Harvey Fein and I tried to convince him to get down to Richmond because he should be able to sell out his entire production run of 500 if he goes. There were only 16 people at the meeting, and he sold the 6 he brought after his demo.

Smart business move to "demo" at the club for free. I'll bet he finds a few more local clubs to take him up on a free demo and brings more tools with him next time. I've attached a link to his website if anyone wants to take a look... (I have no commercial interest...)

Steven

Re: A question for the professional turners?

#15

Steven Antonucci

Yeah-$18K a year as a full time would be tough

steve antonucci

>I meant it more as a side business. I wouldn't want to be a full time turner either.

Never make your vacation your vocation.

Steve

Married to a failed artist trying to break into the high profile world of sock monkeys...

Re: A question for the professional turners?

#16

No link...

Peter Teubel

>

Re: A question for the professional turners?

#17

Wally, Myrtlewood is a fake name for what the

henthorn

>guys in Oregon sell. It does not grow just in Oregon but also in California. It's popular name is California Laurel. Other names are pepperwood, bay, bay berry, etc. The bay leaves used for cooking come from this tree. It is a pretty wood though. I had a big one come down behind my former home in Lake County, California, because of a huge fire. I got a lot of good wood from that tree and still have some pieces I turned from it.

Re: A question for the professional turners?

#18

Steven Antonucci

trying again

steve antonucci

>not sure what happened?

Re: A question for the professional turners?

#19

Steven Antonucci

That's weird, it dropped it again? *LINK*

steve antonucci

>http://www.petergalbertchairmaker.com


Peter Galbert

Re: A question for the professional turners?

#20

Bill Grumbine Collection Agency

GolfSteve in Calgary

>Quote from Bill Grumbine"I tell the person that I am my own collection agency"

I almost peed myself! Reminds me of when I was in the bad part of New Orleans and my 300 lb, black, mean looking, taxi driver said to me, a 90 lb, white, Canuck weakling that "there's nothing to be scared of in New Orleans, I walk around this neighbourhood all the time."

The "Bill Grumbine Collection Agency" knockin' at your door - Our motto is "collecting debts is as easy as knockin' down trees",

:-)

Cheers,

Steven


img

Re: A question for the professional turners?

#21

Re: Oregon Coast Woodturners...

ThomD

>Nothing to do with my ego, but I was once asked to show one of these guys how to improve their production by using gouges ! :) One of my cherished experiences.

Four things that stand out about these shops are:

1) they are providing what the customer wants, not what the turner last saw in an AAW publication. Or for that mater the unique new thing he thinks will make the cover.

2) They sell a range of stuff made by them and others. The priary model is gift shop, and it "just happens" that they are turning stuff in the back.

3) Myrtlewood is a neat tie-in with the local environment

4) Great location.

Of course this does fall a little short on some fronts. No Sadie Bromfman awards being handed out.

Re: A question for the professional turners?

#22

Thanks!

Peter Teubel

>That caliper he invented looks like it'd be EXTREMELY useful for spindle turners. I emailed him an order one.

Re: A question for the professional turners?

#23

Steven Antonucci

Walk softly and carry a big stick!

steve antonucci

>

Re: A question for the professional turners?

#24

Steven Antonucci

Glad to be of assistance

steve antonucci

>The caliper is as usefulas it looks, and has no learning curve. He's also a pretty interesting guy when it comes to "production" work, in that he does and doesn't do production work at the same time. Read his blog for a feel, and perhaps ask him to come up to your local club for something very different.

Steven

Re: A question for the professional turners?

#25

Nothing Fake About It.....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>The sawmills that cut myrtlewood and the furniture factories in SW Oregon, along with the turning industry are an important part of the economy in the area.

Go up to Oregon from California and tell them that myrtlewood is a fake name and they'll show you the way back to California.

History shows that the golden spike celebrating the completion of the first transcontinental railroad was driven into an Oregon myrtlewood tie.

Wally