Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable

Posts

OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable

#1

OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable

Dick Coers

>Well Comcast took over our local cable and put in a price increase right away. Does anyone recommend DirectTV or similar over direct cable? I live in Peoria, IL.

Re: OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable

#2

Steven Antonucci

I love my DirecTV

steve antonucci

>You might want to "survey" your area first to see what your line of sight to the satellite is. We had some issues originally, but eventually found a place to mount a dish. If it rains really hard, we lose TV off and on, but it doesn't bother me as much as it used to.

All of them tout how many HD channels they have and how many total channels they have, but you need to look at the line-up. I don't care how many channels they have, but how many will I watch? LifeTime in HD is not my thing...

Steven

Re: OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable

#3

Re: OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable

Dennis Yoder

>I have Direct because they carry the programs that I watch the most and were cheaper here. Like Steve says the pix drops out during heavy rain and pixulates occasionally but not bad. HD is awsome. Dennis Y

Re: OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable

#4

Re: OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable

Jack Riley

>I had Directv for over 25 years. I live in the country where that was my only option. No cable, no DSL and neither were ever planning to run in front of my farm. I was stuck with dial-up! Dtv finally offered high speed internet but at a cost that is still way too expensive. My only alternative was to buy and bury my own cable and run it over 1/2 mile from my nearest neighbor with access to cable. No more dial-up! The high definition with cable is 1080p while the best Dtv offers is 720p. They don't mention that in their advertising! I loved Dtv but their cost just became ridiculous. Weather outages were rare and then only if a severe thunderstorm (or ice coated my dish) were overhead.

Re: OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable

#5

Re: OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable

John K Jordan

>I didn't have Direct TV, but the Dish Network (with Direcway satellite for internet). Out in the country, we didn't have a choice since cable was unavailable.

When cable finally became available (with a 600' underground cable for me), I switched TV and internet to cable. It is reliable, at least in this area, and costs less than the satellite if you don't opt for their high end package with HBO, etc. I don't watch TV, but my family does and they are happy with the normal and HD channel selection. The internet access over cable is far, far better than the satellite connection.

I hope we never have to go back to satellite.

JKJ

Re: OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable

#6

Re: OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable *LINK*

Craig Daymon

>I have DirecTV and I'd rate it way above Comcast. I'd probably switch to Verizon Fios if it was available here, but it's not. There was an article recently from a videofile magazine talking about how Comcast is compressing their high def digital video, claiming no loss, but how this is not the case and that the picture is definitely degraded. I linked the article below.

I've only seen one station on DirecTV that looks compressed, but I feel fairly certain that is the station and not the doing of DirecTV. That would be the Chiller station (257), dedicated to horror. (Mostly "Tales from the Crypt" and "Friday the 13th" reruns.) And, of course, ALL stations on DirecTV are digital.

-Craig


Todd SpanglerWhat Comcast's Crunched HD Looks Lik

Re: OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable

#7

Re: OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable

don at central illinois

>Dick, I have an uncle that lives just outside of Springfield and they have problems during rain and especially when it is snowing. Since both of you will have basically the same weather, something to think about.

Re: OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable

#8

Dick Hines

Re: OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable

Dick Hines

>I have DirectTV. It's that or 3 local networks. We are not clost to a cable network. I also have Hughes net because I got tired of dial-up. It's the only disadvantage to living in the country. Then I am not sure it's a disadvantage.

Heavy snot, which we get little of in Va.,and heavy rain will kill the signal. But then you i have lots of turning books to read.

Re: OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable

#9

Re: OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable

Bruce Lane

>I have Verizon FiOS and love the reliability. In fact, we use it for our land line, cell, TV and Internet. Internet is blazing fast and have had very few issues. Single bill for all services. Greatness.

Re: OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable

#10

Wire question

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>I have the same situation and was wondering what type of cable did you run. Thanks

Ray

Re: OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable

#11

Re: OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable

Gordon Seto

>Initially we had problem with losing signal with DirectTV during raining. It turned out that the installer forgot to hook up the ground wire. Now we no longer have any reception problem during rain or snow.

We had the problem while we were still at the trial period. Eventually they sent a technician out instead of the lip service.

Gordon

Re: OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable

#12

Re: Wire question

John K Jordan

>Ray,

I know you asked Jack, but I'll chime in with my underground cable experience.

Comcast installed around 650 ft for me. They said they would install up to 600 ft underground at no charge but I guess 650 was close enough. They use a contractor who does all of this work. These guys ran a ditchwitch with an attachment that sliced into the ground with a blade and buried a hard but flexible conduit nearly 2" in diameter as it moved. The ground was left nearly undisturbed. This process was extremely quick and they only disrupted my phone line and my power to the barn! (Contrary to their promise, they started the work when I was not there.) The cable inside the conduit looked to me like what they string on the poles - much larger diameter than standard coax. The cable was terminated at a box in the yard which connected to house with a standard underground coax.

This works like a charm. Note that Comcast refused to connect my house for several years. I found out it was because the signal in our rural area was not strong enough to go the distance - in fact it was so bad that neighbors were switching from cable to satellite. After they upgraded the system, the signal was sufficient.

JKJ

Re: OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable

#13

Re: Wire question

Jack Riley

>The wire is underground cable about 3/4 inch diameter supplied by the cable company. Had I been a month earlier, they would have supplied the cable free but I had to pay 37 cents per foot. I rented a ditch witch and buried the cable two feet deep having to negotiate under buried water, telephone, electric, and natural gas lines. The cable terminates at a junction box where it ties into underground coax that I had buried when I built our house. I own the cable therefore if anyone owning property along the road builds and wants cable, they will have to pay me a percentage of my investment in the line. None to date but there are three properties that could build some day. This was the only option I had for high speed internet at a reasonable rate after suffering with dial-up for so many years!

Re: OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable

#14

Re: OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable

The MountainMan

>Direct TV is the best - reception is great, the scheduling software is easy to use, and you will not have to buy a new TV for the Digital signal (unless yours will not pick up Digital..) I think that would also be true if you had a VCR upstram of the TV... I still haven't bought one... I'm waiting out the HD/Blue-tooth thingy!!

Regards

the MountainMan

Re: OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable

#15

Re: I love my DirecTV

Glenn Hodges/Nashville, Ga

>My neighbors have Direct and we have Dish. They like our Dish Newwork said when their contract was up they will convert to Dish.

Re: OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable

#16

Direct TV raises rates.....again

Mike Nelson

>We have no access to cable and are forced to use DTV or Dish. Our rates just jumped to 58.00 this happens regularly with no warning, even though we have no movie channels, just the basics with diy. We desperately need competition not monopolies. At least we get high speed Internet through ATT (14.95). Don't let the phone companies try to charge you 19.95, if you bitch, they will go to 14.95.

Re: OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable

#17

Sorry , thought I posted that with the OT

Mike Nelson

>

Re: OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable

#18

Re: I love my DirecTV

Carole Valentine

>I get really aggravated that nearly half of the channels in Dish's advertised top 120 are either shopping, paid advertising, music or Spanish channels. I wonder if that is the case with DTV? I am an advocate of the a la cart channel pricing since there are only about 4 channels that I ever bother to watch.

Re: OT DirectTV versus Comcast direct cable

#19

I Like My Comcast..........

Barry Turner

>I had Dish until my trees got so overgrown I could no longer get a signal. After cutting a couple of trees back rather severely, I gave up and called Comcast. Reception is great. Service......well I've never had to call them after about three (3) years or so.

The downside? The bill comes every month! And we pay a least $20 more ($92.00) than we were paying for roughly the same channels on Dish Network. We have HBO. You're right, about half (or more) of the channels are music, Spanish, religious broadcasting or dupicated channels in regular and HD broadcasting, and listings of channels that you have to pay even more to get.