Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Hollowing Systems Gleaned From Wed Nite Chat *LINK*

Posts

Hollowing Systems Gleaned From Wed Nite Chat *LINK*

#1

Hollowing Systems Gleaned From Wed Nite Chat *LINK*

charlie belden

>Missed the Wednesday Night Chat on Hollowing Tools and Systems - but went through and gleaned from the chat log various systems mentioned. Searched the web and put what I found on a web page so participants in that chat, and anyone else interested in "captured systems" for hollowing can see pics of them on one page.

http://web.hypersurf.com/~charlie2/Turning/HollowingSystems/HollowingSystems1.html

As noted at the bottom of that page, if you make one of these tools and don't want it on my site, or if I put up some incorrect info, or if you know of another system I missed - please e-mail me.

As always, comments, suggestions, constructive criticism are welcomed.

charlie belden


hollowing systems compendium

Re: Hollowing Systems Gleaned From Wed Nite Chat *LINK*

#2

Steven Antonucci

I have a "correction" (At least from what I do)

steve antonucci

>In your website, you mention that you "can't use a bowl gouge inside a hollowform". Well, I do it all of the time.

I agree that the hole size limits the tool entering, but I used a bowl gouge inside a hollowform for two specific areas. The first is "rough out", since the amount of time can be reduced since the gouge cuts so fast (you lose it right back in trying to blow the noodles out of a hollowform vs. sawdust).

The second area is in finishing the bottoms. Most hollowform bottoms are just bowls, right? So you know it will work, but acquiring the skill is not always a "first timer". You can actually practice by holding the tool on the tool rest a good 5-6" away from the bottom of a bowl and see if you can cut it with control. I actually turn a lot of vessels with voids, and I use the bowl gouge to clean up the inside with a final pass.

Good overview, though. One other thing I'd add is that there is no penatly for making many, many boring bars of different thickness, length, bend, etc. I have at least a solid dozen, and steel stock to make another 50 or so.

Steven

Re: Hollowing Systems Gleaned From Wed Nite Chat *LINK*

#3

Re: Hollowing Systems Gleaned From Wed Nite Chat

adrien Coblentz

>You missed the Vermec "Ultimate Deep Hollowing Set"

Company is in Queensland, Australia,

email is vermec@netspace.net.au

I don't know how i got the 2005 catalog, cause I couldn't find a web site.

the set went for $AU358 at that time. I'll email you a copy.

Re: Hollowing Systems Gleaned From Wed Nite Chat *LINK*

#4

Re: Hollowing Systems Gleaned From Wed Nite Chat

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Good review of most available captured boring bar systems. Except for turning very small HF's you seemed to dismiss hand held hollowing tools.

Charlie, you put down my favorite hollowing tool by including in your statement:

"tuck the end of the handle under your arm (if you're totally insane and have absolutely no self preservation instinct) to use your full body weight as a counterbalance"

I'm quite sane and I've been using the Stewart arm brace system for many years. (It's tucked under my arm and is against my body) I've turned a lot of hollow forms and have yet to injure myself or even come close. There is a misunderstanding among most turners about getting big bowl-busting catches. Almost all big catches start out as small catches and when the turner loses control of the tool it becomes a big catch. Controling the tool by holding it under the arm and tucking it into the body avoids most of the big catches and is entirely safe.

The deepest hollow form I've turned is around 20 inches. I turned several using my 21 inch Stewart hooker tool most of the way and finishing with a 6 foot long, telescoping boring bar that weighs 9 pounds. I still have that boring bar but haven't used it for years. Instead, for deep turning I use a Nichols captured system which is almost identical to the Don Derry tool minus the laser rig.

I do agree that using a captured sysem of some sort for deep turning makes a lot of sense. But I don't agree with dismissing the use of hand held hollowing tools.

Wally

Re: Hollowing Systems Gleaned From Wed Nite Chat *LINK*

#5

You Rock, Wally!

Allen Neighbors

>I have a homemade deep hollowing rig that I built about a year ago. But I still use my harpoon (nearly 4' long, foam-padded handle) quite a bit, that tucks under my arm. Very good control.

I also use my Don Pencil rig that is balanced against my side, under my elbow. Very good control.

Charlie, that's a nice assortment of rigs on your Site, though. I didn't see the Spin-Doctor's rig, did I? It might have been there and I just missed it... He's from Oklahoma City, and builds humongous rigs.

Re: Hollowing Systems Gleaned From Wed Nite Chat *LINK*

#6

Re: Hollowing Systems Gleaned From Wed Nite Chat

charlie belden

>Added the Vermec and Spin Doctor rigs - thanks guys. Also revised the text re: bowl gouge use per Steve A's info.

Re: hand held tools and deep hollowing - question - IF - these captured systems were available - and you could afford getting one - would you still go with hand held?

I see now that there are two uses for these "captured" systems - one for Deep Reach pieces and one for "merely" doing "normal size" hollow forms. Since I have a relatively small capacity lathe - the JET VS mini/midi, it was the latter I was looking into. But I can see the attraction some of these heavier duty rigs have for folks with Stubbys and the like.

More input please. If you'd care to do a review of any of these systems, or have a link to reviews - like the one for the Spin Doctor's Rig, please e-mail them to me or post it here and I'll include them with the stuff I've got - so far.

charlie belden

who very much appreciates what a great resource this and other turning forums provide

Re: Hollowing Systems Gleaned From Wed Nite Chat *LINK*

#7

Re: Hollowing Systems Gleaned From Wed Nite Chat

David Propst

>Hi Charlie,

Nice review. I agree with Wally that you make hand held tools sound far more dangerous than they are. Light cuts and bracing of the tool against the body are the rule when hollowing blind with these tools.

I am a fan of the outrigger type tool pictured. Here is a review and instructions for using it from the Kestrel Creek site. Why this type tool is not more popular befuddles me. Paul Porter has posted pics of his similar type tool here (check the archives).

Below are a couple more articulated systems available.

Vicmarc Articulated System

Elbo Tool Articulated Hollowing System

Best Regards,

David

Re: Hollowing Systems Gleaned From Wed Nite Chat *LINK*

#8

Re: Hollowing Systems Gleaned From Wed Nite Chat

Mark Wollschlager

>I also use the 'fork' stabilized hollowing system.

One of the tool makers in our club makes an add on fork with a collar and welded arm that can be moved from bar to bar ( straight, angle, swan neck).

You just set the angle of the cutter/scraper and lock the collar and hollow away.

Very simple and effective.

The only issues I have with it are keeping the tool rest in the correct position for both the bar and the fork when doing other than straight boring.

Minor issue.

Mark

Re: Hollowing Systems Gleaned From Wed Nite Chat *LINK*

#9

Re: Hollowing Systems Gleaned From Wed Nite Chat

charlie belden

>Man there sure are a lot of hollowing systems out there I'd never have found without the help of folks here at WoodCentral. Thanks once again to all who contributed (to making my purchasing choice SO much harder ; ).

I wasn't even aware of "deep boring", as opposed to hollowing things like hollow forms, apparently one of the many specialized branches of turning.

As for my impression of the risk of hand held hollowing of larger hollow forms - the president of our turning club, a guy who has been turning everything under the sun for 25+ years, and a turning tool phreak - with a Stubby - tore his shoulder up bad enough to require surgery - using one of the crank handled, arm cuff tools. He was in semi-deep (8 to 10") and "took his eye off the ball" for a fraction of a second. The tool caught and lifted up and rotated at the same time - not just dislocating his shoulder, but damaging the somewhat delicate shoulder joint, including muscles, tendons and ligaments enough to require surgery.

While clearly it is possible to do larger hollow forms with just hand held tools, some of you do it regularly, my personal risk evaluation says "that ain't for me" - you make your own choice. There are people who make handheld freehand complex cuts on a bandsaw (Sam Maloof has been doing things for years that seem dangerous as hell to me - and he admits that it is dangerous), and folks that don't use a push stick when ripping on a table saw. I'm NOT one of those people. When it comes to things that can remove, or severely damage a part or parts of my anatomy - I want to do everything within reason to protect myself - from the tool - and from my potential stupidity/ignorance.

Since the stuff I put up on hollowing systems started out as just another web page on my turning journey and was going to be about the Mini O system I saw at a club meeting, it wasn't intended to be an objective treaties on hollowing and hollowing systems. As is typical for me, I start out heading one way and end up somewhere else. In this case I'm putting together a first cut at a "hollowing systems compendium" which may make others aware of what's available. I've now reorganizing this stuff so that my personal views are on a separate page from the "compendium" info.

I hope the "compendium page" serves as another resource for turners.

Anyone else know of a "captured system" not included in this compendium - yet?

charlie belden

Re: Hollowing Systems Gleaned From Wed Nite Chat *LINK*

#10

Monster system

robo hippy

>One person did ask about this system, and it got no responce. I just got one after reading a lot of comments about it on other chat groups. I just love it. It really makes hollow forms easy. I imagine the other articulated systems do the same. They are for forms up to 8 or so inches deep, and some have gone up to 12 inches. Really smooth and easy to use. The only draw back that I can see is that you need a slightly larger opening to use them, about 1 inch plus. If you are doing collars, then no problem. I had an adapter made so I could use my McNaughton bars in it. The large set are just a bit too long, and I get some chatter. Have to try the smaller ones. Yes, I do turn things other than bowls. Specialization is for insects! (Robert Heinlien, from Time Enough for Love)

robo hippy

Re: Hollowing Systems Gleaned From Wed Nite Chat *LINK*

#11

Re: Hollowing Systems Gleaned From Wed Nite Chat

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>C'mon Charlie, comparing poor and dangerous shop practices such as freehand complex cuts with and a bandsaw and not using a push stick with a table saw to using hand held hollowing tools just tells me that you have had no experience with using hollowing tools.

Are you putting down the masters of hollowing such as Ellsworth, Jordan, Brennion and many more? They all have been using hand held tools safely for many years as have thousands of other turners.

Wally

Re: Hollowing Systems Gleaned From Wed Nite Chat *LINK*

#12

Re: Hollowing Systems Gleaned From Wed Nite Chat

don at central illinois

>I haven't had a chance to look at all of the post's, but did you include the Korbra from Indyfest?

Re: Hollowing Systems Gleaned From Wed Nite Chat *LINK*

#13

Re: Hollowing Systems Gleaned From Wed Nite Chat

charlie belden

>Wally:

I'm not putting anyone or any method down. If you're comfortable with hand held tools for hollowing and have developed a method that works for you that's great. I admire the skills involved and understand why you enjoy the experience.

For me, with all the things I want to try and turn - and furniture I want to make - if there's a tool that will let me do that in my "comfort zone", doesn't require days or weeks of practice to learn to use well and I can afford - then I'm interested in it - and may buy it and use it. In this case, a hollowing system may let me spend the time on the outside of a piece, getting the shape and curves and proportions just right - then do the grunt work on the inside quickly, easily and more safely. And hopefully I won't blow through the sides of anoher piece I spent a couple of hours getting the outside to my liking.

Re: Hollowing Systems Gleaned From Wed Nite Chat *LINK*

#14

Re: Hollowing Systems Gleaned From Wed Nite Chat

ThomD

>Well so they say. Ed Moultrop in the AAW tape mentions being thrown over the top of the lathe and into the wall behind his lathe. Sounded reasonably serious. Not to say that will happen more generally, but technology to the rescue sounds about right.

Re: Hollowing Systems Gleaned From Wed Nite Chat *LINK*

#15

Re: Hollowing Systems Gleaned From Wed Nite Chat

charlie belden

>Yes, BOTH Kobra's are now included - the mini and the "real lathe" ; ) version.

After checking these systems out I note that some allow the tool to be rotated about its long axis - and some don't. Because they all basically scrape - and scrapers require that the tool be presented to the wood at a specific orientation, I'm wondering how important being able to rotate the tool is.

Anyone have an opinion on that question?

charlie belden

Re: Hollowing Systems Gleaned From Wed Nite Chat *LINK*

#16

One Advantage of Using...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Hand held hollowing tools. The pistol grip on my Stewart tool allows me to have good control when I tip the tool for shear cutting. This is especially true when using a round scraper blade.

Wally