Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

turning for a living

Posts

Re: turning for a living

#26

Great Topic

James McClure

>I would love to see a well researched article on this. As others have illuded, there aren't a lot of statistics out there so we end up with lots of speculation and hearsay. The feedback that has already been given is probably about the best you can get when posing a question like this. I think it is partially based on our culture. When you start asking about income and peronal business, people naturally shy away from answering those types of quesitons.

We strive to achieve new skills, we spend hard earned money on tools, equiment, and supplies, and we make beautiful objects as a result. It's a shame that it is not easier to get a return on those objects. Short of starting an artist commune or taking a vow of poverty, I don't think it's going to get any easier any time soon and my wife won't let me take a vow of poverty.

Re: turning for a living

#27

Re: turning for a living

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Just to add a little more to what I wrote yesterday...

As I and someone else mentioned, turning is a small part of a turning business. So it is not just a love of turning, but you have to love being self employed. There is an unstructured freedom that comes with it in that no two days are ever the same. That can be a source of frustration as well, especially when deadlines have to be met. The best laid plans of mice and men, and all that...

I do not worry about people who are doing it just for fun, or just to cover their expenses. Very often they are not doing the same kind of stuff I am doing. Most of the ones I know hate doing spindles for other people, and just about all of them do not account for their time. In other words, while they may siphon off some customers, I have not found it a significant problem.

[rant on]

I'll tell you what does get my dander up though. It is when some sanctimonious twit proclaims his righteousness over those of us who do this for a living because what we do for money, they give away for free. This is the person who delights in casting professionals as greedy money grubbers, who if they had any decency at all, would also be giving it away for free. I always wonder if this attitude seeps over to their own profession, or way of making a living. I don't think these types think that far though. Since this is their hobby, it should be everyones' hobby.

[rant off]

Taking a hobby you love and turning it into a business is a danger, because you may come to hate it. On the other hand, you may come to love the thrill of the sale, the satisfaction of delighted customers, and the variety of activity that comes with running your own business. I will never get rich, but I love what I do, and that is way more important than piles of money.

Bill

Re: turning for a living

#28

Well said Bill

James McClure

>Find a job you love and you'll never have to work a day in your life!

Re: turning for a living

#29

Talk about "spot on" Bill

Robert W

>Bill Grumbine wrote:

>>I'll tell you what does get my dander up though. It is when some sanctimonious twit proclaims his righteousness over those of us who do this for a living because what we do for money, they give away for free. This is the person who delights in casting professionals as greedy money grubbers, who if they had any decency at all, would also be giving it away for free.<<

Well, I'm gonna throw my rant in on top of yours.

I hear this many scenario or something like it several times a year. The project may change, but the gist is the same. I bid putting up 3 layer crown molding in an odd shaped room (or some other kind of specialty carpentry) in a house, and I have to listen to the client's neighbor (who showed up for this purpose) tell him how easy it is, how it won't take long, and how it shouldn't cost much. We go to the neighbor's house to "share ideas" and take a look at his efforts (he is now bragging to my client that he has put up crown molding in several venues at half my price) an we look at his work. It looks like a child beat it on the wall with a shovel. Yet he is proud because he has no training, no company to support, and he did it after hours. Amazing to me how cheap crappy work can be done with no overhead!

As for woodturning, I am NOT knocking the retirees, but our club certainly fits the model of the average woodturner being in his later 60s. We live in a military town, and many come back here to retire to stay by the medical facilities. They have nice military retirements. ATT is here, and there are lots of retirees from there as well, all getting good retirements. The are not trying to support themselves, or their families, or build a retirement, or pay my $500 a month medical insurance. Turning is their hobby, a lark. They crow like a rooster when they sell something, and they sell it cheap to make sure they get it sold. They want bragging rights as selling something must make them some kind of artist. They freely admit they don't care about the money, and they love to dig at how much other get for their work.

They don't care how much time they have in the piece, how much time it took to sell, or anything else. I was selling custom pens many years ago to pay for my lathes and all the tools I was buying. I got $65 each for a pen with a laser engraved sentiment on it, delivered in a gift box. When those guys found our how much I was getting, they promptly starting selling theirs for $30. With the kit price, the blank and the cost of engraving, they were making around $7 a pen, unless you count in gasoline, delivery costs, etc. A year later, they announced to me "there was no money in it". Too late, though, they killed the market.

rant off

You hit a touchy spot, there Mr. Grumbine. Due to the fact a lot of my business is upgrade remodeling, it is slow now, and all the "This Old House" warriors seem to be coming out of the woodwork. They have learned all they need to know to be contractors, simply by watching TV. They dilute the market with inferior work, and charge little for it. It is maddening.

My woodturning sales make me enough money to buy a few new tools if I need them, and occasional chuck, and keep me easily in supplies. I sell only around Christmas time, and usually clear about $750 - $1000.

I can't imagine having to do 3 - 4X that amount of work to support myself. Where in the world would that market be, day in an day out?

None of my comments were meant to hurt anyone here, so I hope no one takes them personally.

Robert

Re: turning for a living

#30

Re: turning for a living

bowlman

>Quote from Bill Grumbine: "... I will never get rich ..."

I consider myself a professional turner who was/is very lucky. When the turning bug infected my life, I had a full time job. After talking it over with SWMBO, we decided i should go for it, but we had a plan. I would keep working my day job, turn on evenings and weekends, do a few shows, and let the day job pay for entry fees, lodging, meals, etc. and tools. Not just hand tools, but bandsaws, drill press, the lathe, grinder, etc. This was in 1985.

I worked 2 full time jobs essentially. Day job, plus as many hours turning as I could afford. I did this from 1986 through 1995 when SWMBO said "no more outdoor shows". A few months later we mutually agreed, "no more whoelsale shows". A year later and she pronounced, "No more indoor shows". When I finally retired from the day job, all was paid for, we had a nice nest egg, I had a fund set up for my now sole job as a professional woodturner, and we had a client list a word of mouth referral.

We don't live in poverty, and, like Bill Grumbine said, we are not financially rich nor will we ever be. But we ARE RICH beyond measure in the experiences we have had, our ongoing freindships with other turners, both well known and relatively unknown. We can go to just about anyplace in the US and a woodturner will host us. We were even hosted in Australia, Mexico, Bermuda and the Caribbean. I do miss the one on one with potential customers, but I don't miss it when someone says, "Honey, I can do that at home" and walks away. Nor do I miss getting rained on, the set up ritual, the frantic tear down, etc. But that is all part of being a pro and selling both product and self.

Just my 2 cents worth.

Dick Gerard

Re: turning for a living

#31

Re: turning for a living

Thom Sayles

>I am one of those guys that sells cheaply at the craft fairs. I thought I was doing nicely but have been thinking lately if it is worth doing for 27 cents and hour. It does keep me occuppied and I do enjoy the turning but is it worth it? Selling the stuff is fun and I like selling myself. This thread makes me see others are in the same boat. As the grass grows longer in my yard and I contemplate the situation, I just don't know.

Re: turning for a living

#32

Re: turning for a living - My Word

Russ Fairfield

>Each of us has to determine what skills we have that are either unique or better than the competition, learn how to use them to our advantage, learn where to sell them, learn how to sell them, and then get out and do it.

Ten things I learned along the way to making a profit from woodturning:

1. This is an individual undertaking that we will have to figure out for ourselves to suit our personality, circumstances, and income requirements. Everyone is different and will have different goals.

2. Ask the question, "Am I ready for this?" Make a brutal analysis of our skills and the quality of our work. Quality sells, and if we don't have the same or better quality as the others in the same venue, we won't sell anything.

3. Do we have a "name"? If we are selling "art", our name is worth half the selling price. In other words, the name will double the price of the art. If we don't have a "name" we will have to be prepared to make one for ourselves. This takes time and a lot of self-promotion.

4. Always charge the market price for our work. Just because we chose to persue woodturning as a hobby, don't cheat the full-timer out of an income by selling the same things at reduculously low prices just to be getting rid of them. That low price just determined the value of turned wood in that market.

5. Don't believe what the famous woodturners in our club are telling us about how well they are doing at the shows and galleries. Woodturners are worse than fishermen when it comes to bragging and lieing. Listening to them would make anyone think this was a sure way to make a fortune. Do some investigating. It doesn't take a genius to see that their work isn't moving in the gallery, and that the real definition of, "the best show I have ever had", is "I recovered my entry fee and paid for supper".

6. There are more people who are willing to pay to learn how to turn wood for themselves than there are people willing to buy what we make.

7. Be flexible in what we make to sell. The market changes over time, as the economics of people's lives change. We have 2 choices - we can either make what fits the venue we chose, or we can chose the venus that fits what we make. It is easier to change our product.

8. Art doesn't sell during an election year, and this one has lasted for 2 years and it isn't over yet.

9. Learn to use a skew and spindle gouge fast and well. There ia lot more money to be made in turning furniture parts and architectural items for both restoration and new construction than there is in selling art. This market will never go away because 99% of the woodturners look down their nose at this kind of turning. They would rather turn bowls and art they can't sell than turn spinsles that will sell.

10. Making it a success is 20% skill, and 80% salesmanship and advertising. You may be successful for awhile if you rely on skill, but you are doomed to failure if you can't handle the sales and promotion of your greatest asset - you.

Re: turning for a living

#33

Re: turning for a living - My Word-No.11

Russ Fairfield

>I forgot No.11. It might be the most important one of them all.

11. Don't forget who our customer is. We often get caught up in trying to please other woodturners. The truth is that, while they will have a lot to say and many suggestions to offer, other woodturners don't buy anything from us. Other people do, and we need to make what serves their needs, and what they are willing to accept.

Re: turning for a living

#34

Re: Talk about "spot on" Bill

dtewell at central illinois

>I agree. In my photo business, anyone with a new digital camera is 'instantly' a 'professional' photogpher. We do weddings and see people with camera's I can't afford. But owning a Nikon does not make you a 'professional', just a Nikon owner. Same with turning, owning an "Elsworth gouge, jig and DVD" only makes you an owner of and "Elsworth gouge, jig and DVD" not a professional turner.

Re: turning for a living

#35

Re: turning for a living *LINK*

Mark Wollschlager

>Cindy Drozda offers some business plan worksheets on he website.

They can be helpful in figuring out how much work goes into the job aside from turning.

mark.

( Who will keep the day job, and turn for personal enrichment )


Handout sheets from Cindy Drozda's website

Re: turning for a living

#36

Re: turning for a living

Ed Davidson (Colorado Springs)

>Teach, demonstrate, make DVD's, create products for the trade (sell to other turners), and last (and least)...make stuff to sell to the public.

Re: turning for a living

#37

Amen Bill!! Perfectly stated!!

Greg Haugen

>

Re: turning for a living

#38

Great BPs

Ron in Drums PA

>These business plan worksheets are excellent.

None of that ridiculous 3x cost or $10 per inch nonsense that you hear all the time.

Thanks Mark.

Re: turning for a living

#39

Re: turning for a living

Curt Fuller

>My friend, Clead Christiansen, has been a professional, self employed, turner for 25-30 years at least. Our turning club meets monthly at his shop, The Turning Post, in North Ogden, Utah. Since I've gotten to know him and hung around his business quite a bit I've decided that turning for a living would be the last thing I would want to do. He's in his early 60's, has had multiple back surgeries, wears a heavy back brace, and walks with a cane now. Over the years he's been an instructor at the Utah Symposium, traveled the country selling his work, and has a studio in his shop where he now sells his "ornamental" work. But in the few years I've known him, I've vary rarely seen him have time to turn anything for pleasure. It's usually production runs of ballusters on one of his pattern lathes, or wrestling a big porch post or 8" newel post onto a lathe. That's his bread and butter. The romance of creating one artistic, big dollar piece after another isn't there. It's back breaking hard labor, not to mention sitting down each night to do the books and hounding people for the money. And being self employed it comes without the benefit of health insurance, vacation pay, retirement plans or other perks associated with most 'jobs'. But he's turned some of the most beautiful things I've ever seen and knows far more about turning than anyone else I've ever met. And I know he loves what he does. He would have to to keep at it for as long as he has.

Re: turning for a living

#40

may be slightly OT, but still related

Ilya Zavorin

>After reading this response, I remembered a recent conversation with a friend who has been doing various crafts for several years, mostly glass and ceramics. I am a beginner turner, mostly bowls at this point, and when someone asked me what I'd do with all the bowls that I make, I'd said that I could always give them out as gifts. When I mentioned this to her, our friend said that she used to think this way too, until she realized that these gifts were not as much appreciated as she had originally thought. Furthermore, many people think that you're simply being cheap when you give them something you made. I guess the reason for this is that unless someone had actually made a bowl or a vase or something similar with their own hands, they often can't appreciate the effort that you put into your creation. I personally haven't experienced this yet, perhaps because I just haven't made enough bowls to give them to many people. ;-) But I am wondering if other people have experienced this.

Re: turning for a living

#41

Re: may be slightly OT, but still related

Stuart Johnson

>I don't have any idea if the items I have given as gifts are received with the thought I'm too cheap to purchase them something. They are gifts, no more or no less. As a gift I try to give them the best I have. I want them to be very happy that I cared enough to give them something I made. If they are the type of person that is going to feel cheated because their gift didn't cost a lot then I probably don't care how they feel. Besides, most of my turnings are Mesquite and they can alway toss it on the BBQ.

Re: turning for a living

#42

Re: turning for a living - My Word

Ron McKinley

>Russ, you really hit it right on the head! I've noticed over the years that all the "pros" had working wives that actually paid the bills. On the other hand, doing what you really love is really "peace on earth". Just find a spouse that is willing to support your lifestyle.........Ron

Re: turning for a living

#43

Re: turning for a living

Barry Elder

>When I first started turning, God provided me with a seemingly endless supply of wood, courtesy of hurricanes Frances and Jeanne in Sept. of 2004. After 6 months of searching out and cutting up and sealing different kinds of wood, I thought I was ready to rock and roll. BUT, the learning experience is very rich, the people were stripped by the hurricanes (10,000 homes de-roofed), and I was amazed at the beauty of each piece of wood. No two were alike, and each offered a different challenge. That put an end to the thought of profit because I was having too much fun. While I give away more than I sell, what I sell is at my price, not on the cheap. But enjoying the turning of beautiful wood is much more important to me than any profit could hope to be. My 2 cents!

Re: turning for a living

#44

Re: turning for a living (long)

Dick Coers

>I thought I would add some experienced information on making a hobby a profession. I left my day job as a designer for Caterpillar to start a custom woodworking business. I had started the business in the basement, part-time for 8 or 9 years before making the plunge. I had a backlog of 6+ months of work, and great interest from a couple of interior designers for commercial work, when I hung out the shingle. I never did tire from the woodworking part, it was the business side that ate me up. You think you hate taxes and insurance now? Wait till you start a business. I kept the business going for 8 years. I was reaching a burnout stage when I got an offer to go to work for Woodworker's Journal. That was like custom woodworking with benefits, so I shut down the shop. What brought about the burnout? Doing "business" related work for the first half day (5 hours), woodworking for the other half day (5 hours of mostly fun), then eating with the family, then going out for customer visits/design meetings/sales calls after dinner. I met people and went places I never would have if I had not run the business. It also opened up the new job at the magazine (that only lasted 3 years when the magazine title and subscription list was sold to Roeckler). The greatest benefit of running the woodworking business was that I have never as proud as when I was telling people about my profession. One last comment that my cousin used to describe her husbands woodworking business, she told me that "Marty only works half days in the shop, that's 12 hours you know!"

Re: turning for a living

#45

Re: may be slightly OT, but still related

Allen Neighbors

>I give away some, and most are certainly appreciated. The last two I gave away were: a bowl to a young man that helped me load the wood. (He called me from Wichita Falls to tell me he appreciated my thoughtfulness, and his Mother told me he took it to school to show off). And a hollow form to a man for a present for his Fiance. (..whom I have known since she was a baby. She called to thank me, and then came over to thank me in person the next time she was in town.)

Choose who you give the turnings to, and they'll more than likely be appreciated. :)

Re: turning for a living

#46

Re: turning for a living - My Word

ThomD

>"4. Always charge the market price for our work. Just because we chose to persue woodturning as a hobby, don't cheat the full-timer out of an income by selling the same things at reduculously low prices just to be getting rid of them. That low price just determined the value of turned wood in that market.

6. There are more people who are willing to pay to learn how to turn wood for themselves than there are people willing to buy what we make. "

"4" isn't in the interest of the amateur woodworker, and "6" determines that the pro will never develop sufficient space between what he does and what the amateur does.

separate point:

I was watching AAW on Rude, and three point from it came across:

1) He turned something like dozens of candlestick before breakfast each day then taught at college:

a) worked real hard, had depresion mentality

b) had a product that he could turn out quickly, and therefore that a gallery could sell with a decent markup, or that he could afford to market.

2) Didn't pay for wood, mostly. I mean, we all know free wood isn't free, but costly wood is another hurdle to price over.

3) Said to other turners that they would start to make money if they turned spindles.

4) And a fourth that occurs to me is that he made his own tools. He didn't drop 10K on stuff to play with, which is fine if you are willing to have that as your Rollex. Or maybe try to make money off the tool end of it.