Talk about "spot on" Bill
Robert W
>Bill Grumbine wrote:
>>I'll tell you what does get my dander up though. It is when some sanctimonious twit proclaims his righteousness over those of us who do this for a living because what we do for money, they give away for free. This is the person who delights in casting professionals as greedy money grubbers, who if they had any decency at all, would also be giving it away for free.<<
Well, I'm gonna throw my rant in on top of yours.
I hear this many scenario or something like it several times a year. The project may change, but the gist is the same. I bid putting up 3 layer crown molding in an odd shaped room (or some other kind of specialty carpentry) in a house, and I have to listen to the client's neighbor (who showed up for this purpose) tell him how easy it is, how it won't take long, and how it shouldn't cost much. We go to the neighbor's house to "share ideas" and take a look at his efforts (he is now bragging to my client that he has put up crown molding in several venues at half my price) an we look at his work. It looks like a child beat it on the wall with a shovel. Yet he is proud because he has no training, no company to support, and he did it after hours. Amazing to me how cheap crappy work can be done with no overhead!
As for woodturning, I am NOT knocking the retirees, but our club certainly fits the model of the average woodturner being in his later 60s. We live in a military town, and many come back here to retire to stay by the medical facilities. They have nice military retirements. ATT is here, and there are lots of retirees from there as well, all getting good retirements. The are not trying to support themselves, or their families, or build a retirement, or pay my $500 a month medical insurance. Turning is their hobby, a lark. They crow like a rooster when they sell something, and they sell it cheap to make sure they get it sold. They want bragging rights as selling something must make them some kind of artist. They freely admit they don't care about the money, and they love to dig at how much other get for their work.
They don't care how much time they have in the piece, how much time it took to sell, or anything else. I was selling custom pens many years ago to pay for my lathes and all the tools I was buying. I got $65 each for a pen with a laser engraved sentiment on it, delivered in a gift box. When those guys found our how much I was getting, they promptly starting selling theirs for $30. With the kit price, the blank and the cost of engraving, they were making around $7 a pen, unless you count in gasoline, delivery costs, etc. A year later, they announced to me "there was no money in it". Too late, though, they killed the market.
rant off
You hit a touchy spot, there Mr. Grumbine. Due to the fact a lot of my business is upgrade remodeling, it is slow now, and all the "This Old House" warriors seem to be coming out of the woodwork. They have learned all they need to know to be contractors, simply by watching TV. They dilute the market with inferior work, and charge little for it. It is maddening.
My woodturning sales make me enough money to buy a few new tools if I need them, and occasional chuck, and keep me easily in supplies. I sell only around Christmas time, and usually clear about $750 - $1000.
I can't imagine having to do 3 - 4X that amount of work to support myself. Where in the world would that market be, day in an day out?
None of my comments were meant to hurt anyone here, so I hope no one takes them personally.
Robert