Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Turning - The Adrenaline Factor

Posts

Turning - The Adrenaline Factor

#1

Turning - The Adrenaline Factor

charlie belden

>Turning - The Adrenaline Factor

(This was prompted by the Chat about hollowing systems. There sure are a lot of them out there, and more being added by the day)

Turning involves

A. grinding strange profiles on the ends of oddly shaped pieces of steel, often spraying hot sparks of glowing metal all over the place

B. honing sharp ground edges to rediculous degrees of sharpness

C. attaching, by various means, a moderately large to insanely large piece of wood, often asymetrically shaped, directly or indirectly

to the shaft of an electric motor in the 1/2 to 3 horsepower range

that spins at, or up to, 3560 rpms

D. applying the rediculously sharp cutting edge create by �B� to the

outside of thenow spinning piece of wood described in �C�

AND THEN

E. Applying said sharp cutting edge to the INSIDE of the spinning piece

of wood

Now �A� through �E� should satisfy even moderately extreme

Adrenaline Junkies with enough opportunities to meet their daily

Adrenaline Fix (DUH!).

But there�s always the One Percenters who aren�t satsified with

the normal adrenaline generating parts of turning. Oh no, not nearly

enough BUZZ. These folks want to turn B I G!

- or

D

E

E

P

!

- or both!

Three foot diameter piece? Too small.

26 inches of tool hanging over the end of the tool rest?

Too short.

That which does not kill you, or maim you, makes you

strong? Well maybe not, BUT - it does give you an

adrenaline rush, assuming it doesn�t kill you before

the adrenaline kicks in.

And then the Buzz Killers get in the act.

My GAWD - that�s dangerous as hell! Why don�t you

- put some kind of depth of cut limiter on the cutting

end so it can�t dive deep into the wood?

- make something to keep the tool from flipping you

up in the air? What you need is something that will

keep the handle from kicking up when the other end

gets caught in a cut and is pulled down.

- figure out a way to keep the handle end of the tool

from rotating about its long axis when the side of

the cutting edge catches in the wood? Maybe some

kind of bar or handle sticking out 90s to the shaft?

AND maybe rather than just a round handle, how about

if it were D-shaped - AND you trap the D between two

steel rods, or maybe two pieces of angle iron bolted

together with a spacer for the D-Handle.

Now, when something goes wrong, or horribly wrong,

it�s the tool and its handle that get beat up - and maybe

the piece explodes - but, with the exception of the

explode part, YOU are saved.

Then some Techno-Weenie will come along and ask

�Why use steel (or carbide) to cut the wood - why not

just Laser it out? No mechanical catches to deal with

AND - there�s intense energy concentrated in a little

tiny dot - that can cut steel (and maybe even carbide).

A tool, or part of the piece, being shot who knows

where, maybe through the roof, or door - that�s

BORING. BUY - a laser beam, that, if it gets away.

can instantly burn a hole through you, and the door

and char the side of your neighbor�s house. NOW

THERE�S an Adrenaline Generator. A crushed digit

or two, a broken arm or dislocated shoulder are

pretty impressive Adrenaline Junky badges of honor

(read �indicators of stupidity� if a Fraidy Kat) - but

- a nice clean hole, through your palm, forearm or

ear - now there�s a conversation starter amongst

Adrenaline Phreaks. REAL Adrenaline Junkies will

be easy to spot - they�ll look like Swiss Cheese - AND

whistle when the wind blows hard enough.

I can hardly wait!

So how important is the Adrenaline Factor to you?

charlie belden

Re: Turning - The Adrenaline Factor

#2

Re: Turning - The Adrenaline Factor

Carole Valentine

>Charlie, have you run out of wood or something? Is your lathe on the fritz? ;))

Re: Turning - The Adrenaline Factor

#3

Re: Turning - The Adrenaline Factor

Justin Fields

>This was amusing.

Actually, in the few months I've done it, I have found turning really relaxing. Either I get a nice turned piece or I get firewood and a lesson learned. Whichever way it turns out, I get to make shavings and do something creative. It is a good change to spend time doing something manual in the midst of my computer-oriented technological world.

As for adrenaline, I skydive. And if I want more thrill and danger than that, I can always try to justify new woodworking tools to my wife.

Justin

Re: Turning - The Adrenaline Factor

#4

Dick Hines

Re: Turning - The Adrenaline Factor

Dick Hines

>I get my adrenaline flying down the interstate at 70MPH+ on two wheels.

Re: Turning - The Adrenaline Factor

#5

Steven Antonucci

Actually, I don't want an adreneline rush at the

steve antonucci

>lathe!

It's probably the last thing I want, because it means I shouldn't be there. I know what you mean, but I turn to AVOID a rapid pulse.

For the most part, an adreneline rush usually results in a momentary session of using bad words, some stomping, and occassionally "spiking" whatever's left on the lathe to avoid spending lots of time trying to figure out how to fix something.

If I want to get my heart rate pumping, I go for a hike.

Steven

Re: Turning - The Adrenaline Factor

#6

Charlie...

Steven Kubien

>...you posted this at 12:24am. Is it possible something bad happened in the shop tonight, or do you just need to catch some Zzzzz's?

In all seriousness, I am with Steve A. and I do not look for the adrenaline rush when using machines. Sure, there is excitment when starting into a hunk of wood you suspect will reveal spectacular figure, colour or whatever but I'm not sure that's the same as adrenaline. My heart rate rises when making that final pass on the inside of a bowl, hoping that it will be the last pass because I got it right (not because it blew apart). Again, I don't think this is quite the same as what you describe.

Now I am not a doctor and I don't play one on TV but I believe adrenaline-rush is result/factor in the fight/flight instinct. By extension, I only expect that fight/flight reaction when the stuff hits the fan (fight to hang on the tool or run from heaven-knows-what).

I suppose we could extend your "extreme" break-down of what turning involves into lots of other activities (I love doing this sort of stuff)... Put yourself in a steel box, no better yet, strap yourself in. Sit in front of a tank full of highly volatile liquid which can explode at any moment and make sure that you've got an insanely high-powered engine of some kind in front of you. Now drive this steel box down the road at 30, 50, 70 mph! Not enough for you? Ok, get hundred's of others to do the same thing, at the same time (!), in different directions (!). Still not doing it for you? Simple, make sure some of the people (perhaps yourself) are talking on the phone while driving their steel boxes (or putting on their make-up, exercising their parenting skills, eating lunch etc). Barely a flicker on your ticker? Add adolescent-ingnorance/machismo (sp) and for the purists...alcohol. Anyone sleepy? No problem, drive your steel box well into the night because the adrenaline will surely keep you awake.

Come to think of it, I am going to go do this right now and I am going to get myself a coffee so I can add jittery-caffeine symptoms to the mix.

Thanks Charlie. I am not sure what your intent was with this and I may have taken on a wide detour, but I did enjoy it!

Have a great day everyone!

Steve Kubien

Re: Turning - The Adrenaline Factor

#7

Three years in the paratroops...

Allen Neighbors

>two years in VietNam, twenty-two years in the Army, and eighteen years in the Fire Service have just about depleted my Adrenaline supply. I just turn 'cause it's fun!!

Thanks for the laughs, everyone.

Re: Turning - The Adrenaline Factor

#8

Do Captured Hollowing Systems Take the Fun Out?

charile belden

>What I was reacting to was the Chat on Hollowing Tools. As in any art or craft, someone will push the limits of the tools and materials, or invent some new tool or material - and make "signature" pieces - the style immediately recongizable as the work of "fill in the blank - think Ellsworth or Escoulen or Binh Pho." Since it was hollowing tools and hollowing systems let's go with David Ellsworth - and specifically - his small opening, tall, hollow forms.

Since none, or almost none, of the hollowing tools that are out there today were available to him he had to have had some adrenaline rush experiences early on. And he had to trial and error his way through various ideas for turning tools he could make himself, or find someone to make. And then there's the Ellsworth Grind - that probably took several tries and a lot of experimenting (some of which must have been adrenaline experiences) before settling on one that did what he wanted it to do.

Now, with one of the available hollowing system, an intermediate beginner can, with the help of a laser accessory, turn some pretty thin walled hollow forms through a pretty small opening - with little or no possibility of an adrenaline rush experience. When anyone with a lathe - and some disposable income - can BUY the ability to turn things that previously were the domain of advanced (or some may think - suicidal) turners, is something lost in the turning world? Old School turners might harrumph at the idea of a newbie skipping over all the things THEY had to learn - sharpening, honing, gouge or chisel selection, miles of cylinders and beads and coves and ogees using THE right tool for each of the classic spindle elements BEFORE even thinking about doing any of the other branches of wood turning.

When I was making lost wax cast jewelry and small sculpture, there were always budding jewelers who'd buy every New AND Improved jewelry making tool that came out, thinking that the mere possession of such things would make them good jewelers. The fact that it didn't in no way dissuaded them from buying the next New AND Improved tool that came out. The fact that they couldn't draw a straight line with a ruler, couldn't design, let alone make, an actual piece of jewelry to save their lives and coudln't even give their pieces away was completely ignored - "the world just hasn't caught up with my work - yet" being the rationale for continuing in a field for which they either had no talent for, or the willingness to learn.

So back to hollow forms and hollowing systems. I'm ambivalent about them. On the one hand, one of them might allow me to turn things I'm currently unable, or unwilling to try. On the other hand, for me, hollow form turning's "cut where you can't see" and the possibility of cutting right through the wall of the piece is part of the appeal - the little adrenaline bump thing.

When the outcome is almost guaranteed, is something lost? If "willingness to take a risk" were substituted for Adrenaline is that a factor in why you put a chunk of wood on a lathe, spin it really fast then apply the sharp edge of a steel or carbide tool to it?

charlie belden

Re: Turning - The Adrenaline Factor

#9

Re: Hooked

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>On Endorphins.

Does occasionally hasten a load of laundry out of the normal rotation, but hey, what's a few gallons of water and a few ounces of phosphates, eh?

Re: Turning - The Adrenaline Factor

#10

You just hit on something significant

Steven Kubien

>Charlie,

You just spoke about jewellers who couldn't design to save their lives. Same goes for turners. No tool, gizmo or new-fangled-doohickey is going to make you (any of us) a better designer. Myself, I have played with hollowing using home-made, Ellsworth-like tools and I don't really enjoy it. Right now I am waiting to receive a Jamieson captured system. Will it make me a better turner? No way (!) because it will not help me with form and the elusive, perfect curve. But, it will help me take care of the garbage you can't see (the inside) and perhaps make a few less funnels. Do some of the more experienced veterans of the spinning arts think we cheat or skip steps using lasers, captured rigs and the like? Beats me. I'm only 36 and I am not sure I have ever bought into the idea of needing to pay ones dues. In fact, I am FIRMLY on the fence on that issue.

This is an intersting thread. Thanks for bringing it up.

Steve Kubien

Re: Turning - The Adrenaline Factor

#11

Re: Do Captured Hollowing Systems Take the Fun Out

Peter Teubel

>Charlie wrote:

"When anyone with a lathe - and some disposable income - can BUY the ability to turn things that previously were the domain of advanced (or some may think - suicidal) turners, is something lost in the turning world? Old School turners might harrumph at the idea of a newbie skipping over all the things THEY had to learn - sharpening, honing, gouge or chisel selection, miles of cylinders and beads and coves and ogees using THE right tool for each of the classic spindle elements BEFORE even thinking about doing any of the other branches of wood turning."

============

Just playing devil's advocate here for the sake of example.

So, when someone today (with or without disposable income) can simply BUY a program to do a task on a computer, is something lost in the realm of computer programming? The old school techno geeks may harrumph at the idea of a non-computer literate person skipping over all the things THEY had to learn...building/assembling, programming, configuring, troubleshooting BEFORE even thinking of surfing the web.

I believe it's called "progress" and we simply have to accept it or be labeled Luddites. Nothing wrong with learning and using the "old ways", but we shouldn't be chastising the use of modern conveniences simply because we didn't have them when we started.

Re: Turning - The Adrenaline Factor

#12

Re: Do Captured Hollowing Systems Take the Fun Out

Steven Kubien

>Well put Peter and I agree. Although, I am studying a 400 year old art from Japan which will only have practial application in today's world if someone attacks me with a samurai sword. I know there are easier, more modern ways to handle things but man it's fun!!!!!

Cheers,

Steve Kubien

Re: Turning - The Adrenaline Factor

#13

Steven Antonucci

You mean cheater bars? :-)

steve antonucci

>That's at least my "pet name" for them. I understand that captured systems solve a lot of problems that plague hollowform turners, but I would feel disconnected from the process if I was standing 6 feet from the work guiding a bar from a handle. Next thing in the world of "progress" will be a ball mill on a flex shaft to hollow, followed by a CNC attachment to control the motion.

If all we care about is the end result and not how we got there, why bother turning?

Steve

P.S. I'm being somewhat facetious about captured systems. Somewhat.

Re: Turning - The Adrenaline Factor

#14

Six feet from turning tool *LINK*

Stuart Johnson

>Try out a tool like the one being used in this video if you want to stand 6 feet away.


Big Tool

Re: Turning - The Adrenaline Factor

#15

Steven Antonucci

That was a very cool video!

steve antonucci

>I thought I was the only person who had made a short hollowing gouge! I broke a 1/4" gouge many years back and put it in a bar similar to the one he had. My stabilizer is a pair of vise grips, but I'm looking to upgrade for undercut vessels!

I also got a kick out of the length of the boring bar. I'd be in my backyard if I had a bar that long. Bet he can't feel anything at that distance with all of that mass.

Thanks for posting.

Steven

P.S. Will we be seeing a cherry platter any time soon ;-)

Re: Turning - The Adrenaline Factor

#16

Re: That was a very cool video!

Stuart Johnson

>Will we be seeing a cherry platter any time soon ;-)

Turned, soaked, dried and re-turned just some off the lathe sanding and some finish left. I thought I was done with the sanding and took it off the lathe only to find someone had come in and added some torn grain along with some scratch marks. It's too nice a piece of wood to leave them.